Phoenix Sinclair inquiry's latest delay frustrates lawyer
CBC News
Posted: Mar 14, 2013 6:39 AM CT
Last Updated: Mar 14, 2013 6:04 PM CT
The Manitoba public inquiry into the death of five-year-old Phoenix Sinclair has once again ground to a halt, frustrating at least one lawyer involved in the case.
Phoenix Sinclair, seen in an undated photograph, died in 2005 at the age of five. A public inquiry, which has been examining the circumstances surrounding her death, is now held over at least until mid-April. (Phoenix Sinclair inquiry)Inquiry hearings are now on hold at least until mid-April, while officials sort out a conflict-of-interest issue.
The Phoenix Sinclair inquiry has been examining how Manitoba's child welfare system failed to protect Phoenix, a former foster child who was beaten to death in 2005 after social workers gave her back to her biological mother, Samantha Kematch.
Both Kematch and Karl McKay, Kematch's common-law partner, were convicted of first-degree murder in 2008 and sentenced to life in prison.
The public inquiry has already faced several lengthy delays due to legal wrangling, frustrating those who are involved in the proceedings.
"All the people involved, of course, all want to see it come to some conclusion, right? So nobody's happy about it being delayed," Jeff Gindin, the lawyer representing Phoenix's biological father at the inquiry, told CBC News.
"We've all got this time set aside. As far as the lawyers go, we don't have other cases slotted in."
Conflict-of-interest concerns
The latest delay comes as inquiry officials deal with a conflict-of-interest issue involving another lawyer, Kris Saxberg, who has represented several Manitoba child and family services agencies as well as the supervisor who closed Phoenix's file prior to her death.
Inquiry commissioner Ted Hughes said last month that Saxberg appeared to be in a conflict of interest in representing multiple clients, based on conflicting testimony from some of those individuals.
Hughes recently asked the Law Society of Manitoba for an opinion, and the society agreed that there is a conflict.
In a letter released Wednesday, Saxberg informed the inquiry that some of his clients will be getting new lawyers.
Hughes has given Saxberg until Friday afternoon to deliver his response to questions about his potential continued or limited involvement in the inquiry.
Hughes will then issue a decision on the matter next Tuesday.
The inquiry was originally set to conclude in May, but that date will probably be pushed back.
The provincial government recently extended the deadline for Hughes's final report by six months to September and may be forced to push it back further due to the most recent delay.
"It is frustrating … but in terms of the final result, I hope that a bit of delay here and there doesn't affect the actual decision we're all waiting for and the recommendations that will come out," Gindin said.
"I mean, obviously it's nice to have recommendations as soon as possible."
Inquiry's price tag grows
Meanwhile, the inquiry's price tag has grown to more than $6 million and is expected to keep growing.
The province has approved another $1.4 million, for the fiscal year that ends March 31, to fund the inquiry.
That's on top of $4.7 million originally budgeted, and more money is expected in the upcoming fiscal year.
Finance Minister Stan Struthers says he is willing to spend whatever is necessary to ensure Hughes can complete the inquiry and come up with recommendations.
"I think anytime you're dealing with the protection of children, it's worth spending the money to accomplish that," Struthers told CBC News on Thursday.
"We've said to him [Hughes] very clearly that he has the tools necessary to be thorough with this inquiry. We were not going to pull the rug out from under his feet part-way through."
Struthers admitted that the inquiry's numerous delays have added to the price tag.
With files from The Canadian PressShare Tools
Latest Manitoba News Headlines
- Kids of MANFF officials paid for mileage, overtime
- The agency in charge of disbursing federal money to 2011 flood evacuees paid thousands of dollars in overtime and mileage expenses –in some cases, to a senior official or the children of senior officials, CBC News has learned. more »
- 2 killed in semi crash on Trans-Canada
- RCMP are investigating after a semi and a vehicle collided on the Trans-Canada Highway just west of Portage la Prairie Wednesday afternoon. more »
- Gretna border closed as North Dakota grapples with flood
- Canada and United States border officials have closed the Gretna border crossing in Manitoba after overland flooding made portions of Highway 30 impassable. more »
- City golf course plan OK'd by executive committee
- The controversial plan to lease out four municipal golf courses to a private manager and sell another was narrowly passed by the City of Winnipeg's executive policy committee. more »
Must Watch
Top News Headlines
- Harper 'not consulted' about Duffy Senate expense repayment

- Prime Minister Stephen Harper says that not only did he not know about his chief of staff's "gift" to repay Senator Mike Duffy's expenses before the story broke in the media, he was not consulted and did not sign off on Nigel Wright's decision to write a personal cheque. more »
- 2 infants confirmed among dead of Oklahoma tornado
- Rescue workers raced to complete the search for survivors and the dead in the Oklahoma City suburb where a mammoth tornado destroyed countless homes, cleared lots down to bare red earth and claimed 24 lives, including those of 10 children. more »
- 'You will see him again in heaven,' Sharlene Bosma tells daughter
- Sharlene Bosma told more than 1,000 people at the public memorial service for her slain husband, Tim Bosma, about the love they shared. more »
- Mayor Ford stays silent while his brother defends him
- Toronto Mayor Rob Ford continues to stonewall the media over allegations that he was recorded on video smoking what appears to be crack cocaine, but his brother Coun. Doug Ford told reporters Wednesday that the story is untrue. more »
- Emterra crew dumps trash, recycling in same truck
- Winnipeg's tallest highrise to go up at Graham, Garry
- 'Unbelievable' rain soaks southern Manitoba
- City golf course plan OK'd by executive committee
- Castoff couches, mattresses choking Winnipeg alleys
- Man dies after car plunges into Winnipeg pond
- Winnipeg's downtown too sparse for grocers, report says
- 2 killed in semi crash on Trans-Canada
- Manitobans weigh into the senate scandal

