Phoenix Sinclair's godmother lashes out during inquiry
'I would have eliminated' Phoenix's mother, Kim Edwards testified
CBC News
Posted: Dec 13, 2012 10:28 AM CST
Last Updated: Dec 13, 2012 8:48 PM CST
Related
Related Stories
The public inquiry into the death of Phoenix Sinclair heard explosive testimony on Thursday from Kim Edwards, the child's godmother, whose temper exploded at times during cross-examination.
The inquiry has heard that Edwards and her former husband, Rohan Stephenson, cared for Phoenix on many occasions during the girl's short life.
Phoenix was bounced between foster care, Edwards's home and her own family before she was beaten to death in 2005, at the age of five, by her mother, Samantha Kematch, and Karl McKay, Kematch's boyfriend.
Kematch and McKay were convicted in 2008 of first-degree murder in connection with Phoenix's death.
Edwards, who began testifying at the inquiry on Wednesday, faced tough questions on Thursday based on Manitoba Child and Family Services (CFS) records on Phoenix's care and other documents.
Edwards refuted the information contained in almost every CFS record, calling some of the details "outright lies" and suggesting that CFS workers fabricate documents.
Lawyers also grilled Edwards about whether she went to CFS authorities with her concerns about Phoenix in April 2004, after Kematch took the girl from Edwards's home.
"We didn't think she was in danger because nobody knew that this woman was a psychopath except for the CFS workers who had her in-care file," Edwards responded.
"I didn't have her in-care file, like all these social workers who went out and touched this case."
Inquiry commissioner Ted Hughes called for several breaks in Thursday's hearing to allow Edwards to calm down, but she still made some shocking claims in her testimony, including one statement about Kematch.
"We didn't know Samantha was going to do this. Had I [known], I would have eliminated Samantha," Edwards told the inquiry.
CFS document to remain sealed
Earlier on Thursday, Hughes decided against unsealing a CFS file on Edwards's own involvement with the CFS system.
Edwards revealed on Wednesday that when she was a teenager, her own daughter was apprehended by CFS because Edwards was in an abusive relationship at the time.
Lawyers for CFS had wanted that file, dating back to when Edwards was 17 years old, entered into evidence. But Hughes instructed lawyer Kris Saxberg to return the document to wherever it had come from.
Edwards and Stephenson cared for Phoenix many times, including in the summer of 2003, when Phoenix had been taken from her father, Steven Sinclair.
While Phoenix was killed by Kematch and McKay in 2005, her body was found in March 2006 — nine months later — wrapped in plastic in an unmarked shallow grave near the landfill on the Fisher River First Nation.
The Phoenix Sinclair inquiry is looking at how CFS officials handled the girl's case and why her death went undiscovered for months.
The inquiry adjourned after Edwards's testimony concluded on Thursday and will resume on Monday.
With files from The Canadian PressShare Tools
Latest Manitoba News Headlines
- Tory MLA vows to talk for days on controversial PST hike
- He's got a pack of throat lozenges in his pocket and a list of procedural tricks up his sleeve. Tory MLA Kelvin Goertzen said Tuesday he is ready to start talking in the Manitoba legislature about why the government should not raise the PST. more »
- Tory MP bows to Elections Canada in fight over expenses
- Conservative MP Shelly Glover has bowed to Elections Canada in a battle over her 2011 campaign expenses, days after filing a court challenge against the agency. more »
- Judge rules on brothers’ testimony in archbishop sex trial
- Two brothers who say they were sexually abused by an Orthodox priest in Winnipeg will have their testimony considered jointly. more »
- City eyes special officers for Winnipeg Transit buses
- A new report is recommending more protections for Winnipeg's bus drivers -- including officers on problem routes and fines for unruly passengers. more »
- Mosquito numbers not high enough to fog, city says
- The city is asking Winnipeggers to do their part to get rid of nuisance mosquitoes, but officials said they have no plans to start fogging. more »
Must Watch
Top News Headlines
- G8 leaders agree to 7-point plan on Syria as summit wraps
- Prime Minister Stephen Harper and the other G8 leaders reach a seven-point plan aimed at stopping the conflict in Syria, wrapping up a two-day summit in Northern Ireland following talks on trade, tax evasion, poverty and terrorism. more »
- Are e-cigarettes safe to puff?
- As electronic or e-cigarettes grow in popularity, some health advocates want them to be regulated. more »
- In Bangladesh's garment trade, empowerment comes at $20 a week
- The pay is laughable by Western standards, and the shantytowns of Dhaka offer a difficult life. But the surge of mostly young women into the country's increasingly important clothing industry is having a profound change on this largely Islamic society, Margaret Evans writes. more »
- Tory MP bows to Elections Canada in fight over expenses
- Conservative MP Shelly Glover has bowed to Elections Canada in a battle over her 2011 campaign expenses, days after filing a court challenge against the agency. more »
- Has the lost bell of Batoche been found in Manitoba?
- Girl, 3, in critical after car hits building in West End
- Manitoba RCMP dog killed in Saskatchewan crash
- Mosquito numbers not high enough to fog, city says
- Old math replaces new math in Manitoba
- Winnipeg thieves smash and grab from Calgary visitors' car
- Shots fired at Winnipeg home
- Chez Sophie opens on Esplanade Riel
- St. Mary's Road construction stymies traffic, business


A New Home for the Bombers