Supervisors' notes missing, Phoenix Sinclair inquiry learns
CBC News
Posted: Nov 27, 2012 10:34 AM CST
Last Updated: Nov 27, 2012 8:02 PM CST
Phoenix only lived to be five years old, spending her life in and out of foster care before she died on the Fisher River First Nation in 2005. (Phoenix Sinclair inquiry)
Related
Related Stories
All the notes that Manitoba child and family services (CFS) supervisors took during Phoenix Sinclair's short life have gone missing, an inquiry into her death has learned.
Over the course of five-year-old Phoenix's life, at least 10 supervisors oversaw social workers who were handling her troubled family's file.
But all the supervisory notes written throughout the little girl's life ā much of which was spent in and out of foster care ā cannot be found, lawyers for the inquiry told reporters late Tuesday.
"You don't get a sense of what actually was happening at the time. There may be information in the notes that isn't available to the inquiry," said Derek Olson, an inquiry counsel.
Gordon McKinnon, a lawyer for Manitoba's Family Services Department, said the missing notes will not have a big impact on the inquiry because the information may show up in other files.
The Phoenix Sinclair inquiry is looking at how Manitoba's child and family services officials handled Phoenix's case.
She spent her life in and out of the child welfare system before she died in 2005, shortly after she was returned to her biological mother, Samantha Kematch.
Kematch and her common-law husband, Karl McKay, were convicted in 2008 of first-degree murder in connection with Phoenix's death. The girl had been neglected, confined and repeatedly abused.
The stunning admission about the missing notes was made on Tuesday, during the testimony of former CFS supervisor Angela Balan.
Balan told the inquiry that she kept detailed records of her social workers' caseloads and conducted regular reviews with workers about each of their cases.
Balan said she also supported her staff with readily available information, and she would even accompany them into the field if they wanted.
But inquiry counsel Derek Olson said not only were Balan's case notes missing, but notes belonging to all supervisors involved with Phoenix's case cannot be found.
Balan confirmed that Gordon McKinnon, the lawyer for Manitoba's Department of Family Services, told her that the notes were lost.
'I can't recall' continued
Earlier on Tuesday, the inquiry heard more testimony about why it took a social worker months to make contact with Phoenix's family.
The inquiry has heard that Phoenix was taken into the care of CFS workers within days of her birth in April 2000, but was returned to Kematch and biological father Steve Sinclair in September of that year.
Delores Chief-Abigosis has been unable to recall much about her time monitoring Phoenix Sinclair's care. (CBC)As a part of that agreement, the family was supposed to get regular visits from a social worker.
The social worker assigned to their case, Delores Chief-Abigosis, was unable to make contact with the family until February 2001.
Chief-Abigosis, who answered more than 70 questions about the girl's care on Monday by saying, "I can't recall," continued on the stand Tuesday with the same responses, far surpassing the 100 mark.
She explained she was under a lot of stress at the time, juggling a full caseload at work, taking full-time university courses and commuting to Winnipeg from Brokenhead.
Chief-Abigosis was grilled by lawyer Jeff Gindin, who asked whether she even tried to contact the family in 2000, when there are no notes about it.
"So, either you were not documenting important things, or you weren't doing them. It's one or the other. Right?" he said.
"I disagree. I may have documented them, I may not have documented. I may have attended a home, I may not have attended but I believe there was attempts to visit the family," Chief-Abigosis said.
"And if you did document them in notes, we don't have those notes," Gindin responded.
"I don't see them," Chief-Abigosis said.
Share Tools
Latest Manitoba News Headlines
- Second man charged in death of Winnipeg model
- Winnipeg police have charged a second man in connection with the death of a young model who was shot to death in March of last year. more »
- One person killed in head-on crash near Brandon
- One person has died after a head-on crash involving a pickup truck and a semi carrying fertilizer, just north of Brandon, Man. Friday night. more »
- Steinbach RCMP find marijuana grow-op, 65 plants seized
- A Friday morning assault has led police officers in Steinbach, Man. to a marijuana grow op and the seizure of about 65 plants. more »
- Elijah Harper, key player in Meech Lake accord, dies at 64
- Elijah Harper, a former Manitoba MLA and MP who was a key player in defeating the Meech Lake accord, has died at age 64. more »
Must Watch
Top News Headlines
- Senator Pamela Wallin leaves Conservative caucus
- Senator Pamela Wallin says she is recusing herself from the Conservative caucus while her travel expense claims are under scrutiny. Wallin's departure comes one day after Senator Mike Duffy left the Tory caucus amid controversy over his expense claims. more »
- Toronto Mayor Rob Ford cancels weekly radio show
- Toronto Mayor Rob Ford will not be hosting his weekly radio show this weekend after explosive allegations that he was recorded on video appearing to smoke crack cocaine. more »
- WHO concerned coronavirus spreading person to person
- The World Health Organization has issued a blunt assessment of the coronavirus outbreak in Saudi Arabia, acknowledging for the first time that there are concerns the virus may be spreading from person to person, at least in a limited way. more »
- Body found after fishing boat capsizes off New Brunswick
- A man's body has been found after a lobster fishing boat capsized off the eastern coast of New Brunswick. more »
- Elijah Harper, key player in Meech Lake accord, dies at 64
- Two bodies found in Charleswood home
- 6 tips for Manitoba gardeners this long weekend
- Athletics Manitoba director dies in highway crash
- One person killed in head-on crash near Brandon
- Winnipeg golf course privatization plan OK'd by committee
- Vince Li gets Winnipeg visitation privileges
- Winnipeg police charge 2 women in Johnny Gās killing
- UFO sightings soar in Manitoba, across Canada

