Manitoba judge's lawyer wants sex inquiry quashed
The Canadian Press
Posted: Aug 20, 2012 5:21 PM CT
Last Updated: Aug 20, 2012 8:51 PM CT
Another round of legal wrangling has erupted that could derail the inquiry into a Manitoba judge whose nude photos appeared on the internet.
Lori Douglas's lawyer, Sheila Block, filed an application Monday with the Federal Court of Canada to quash the inquiry due to a "reasonable apprehension of bias".
Block alleges that George Macintosh, the lawyer who has been asking questions on behalf of the five-member committee overseeing the inquiry, has engaged in "aggressive and argumentative questions, sexist and insulting references, misstatements and distortions of the evidence and attacks on (Douglas's) character and credibility".
Guy Pratte, the independent lawyer leading the inquiry, filed a similar but separate motion Monday.
He did not ask the Federal Court to end the inquiry, but only to prevent Macintosh from asking any more questions and strike his previous questions from the record.
Pratte said the inquiry committee, which includes the chief justices of Alberta, Prince Edward Island and Newfoundland and Labrador, has over-stepped its bounds by becoming involved in a hearing while also presiding over it.
"The procedure adopted by the committee is beyond its jurisdiction, violates the (Canadian Judicial Council) bylaws and policies and … is inconsistent with the principles of fairness by which the committee is legally bound," Pratte wrote.
The inquiry committee is examining whether Douglas should be removed from the bench. Douglas is an associate chief justice of the Manitoba Court of Queen's Bench, heading up the family court division.
Sexually explicit photos posted
The inquiry is examining a controversy that began when Douglas's husband, Jack King, sexually harassed a client.
In 2003, when Douglas and King were family law lawyers at the same firm, King uploaded sexually explicit photos of Douglas on a website dedicated to interracial sex. Some showed her in bondage gear or performing sex acts. He also emailed photos to a client named Alexander Chapman and asked him to have sex with Douglas.
Chapman complained to the law firm and King settled the matter within weeks by paying Chapman $25,000 to return all the photos and to never discuss the matter.
Chapman broke that deal in 2010 and complained to the judicial council, insisting Douglas was part of the sexual harassment.
Among the allegations before the inquiry is that Douglas did not disclose the matter when she applied to be a judge. She applied three times before finally being accepted in 2005.
The inquiry is also examining whether the very existence of the photos precludes Douglas from continuing in her job.
Douglas has said all along that her husband acted without her knowledge, and that she should not be punished for her husband's misdeeds.
Macintosh grilled Douglas's husband last month, suggesting it was impossible that Douglas never knew about the nude photos.
With rapid-fire questions, he repeatedly asked King how could Douglas not be alarmed that he was snapping more than 100 pictures of her over the years, with digital, film and instant cameras.
Lawyer tried to quash inquiry before
Block objected to Macintosh's questions and asked the committee to end the inquiry. The committee rejected that idea and said Macintosh needed to ask questions to get to the truth.
It's not clear when Block or Pratte's applications to the Federal Court might be heard. The inquiry itself is on a break.
It was originally scheduled to finish hearing evidence last month, but most witnesses have yet to testify. The committee had talked about resuming hearings in the fall, although no firm dates have been set.
The Canadian Judicial Council has only held inquiries into judges nine times in 40 years. It has only once recommended that a judge be removed.
In 2009, the council recommended to the federal government that Paul Cosgrove be removed as a justice of the Ontario Superior Court due to incompetence and abuse of his powers.
Cosgrove resigned before the federal government could make its decision.
Latest Manitoba News Headlines
- Winnipeg couple fights schizophrenia challenges together
- Winnipeggers Sean and Doris Miller have been married for 14 years, but reaching that anniversary has been a feat in itself since Sean was diagnosed with schizophrenia. more »
- Manitoba grandparents prep for provincial bodybuilding contest
- One Manitoba couple is among dozens going to great lengths to grab a title from an amateur bodybuilding competition this weekend. more »
- Man breaks into Wellington Crescent home while girl sleeps
- Winnipeg police are looking for a suspect after a man broke into a home on Wellington Crescent while a girl slept inside. more »
- Doors Open Winnipeg offers access to architectural gems
- The 10th annual Doors Open Winnipeg is an initiative of Heritage Winnipeg that opens the doors of more than 80 buildings and sites on May 25 and 26. more »
Top News Headlines
- Washington police blame bridge collapse on Alberta trucker
- Washington State police say an Alberta trucker was responsible for hitting a steel beam precipitating a bridge collapse on one of the busiest routes in the American northwest. more »
- Royal Bank pledges not to outsource jobs for cash savings
- Royal Bank has promised it will never outsource a Canadian job to a foreign worker solely to save money. more »
- Canada ranks 3rd last in paid vacations
- Canada ranks third last among economically advanced countries in the amount of paid vacation time it guarantees its workers, a new U.S. study indicates. more »
- Group calls for probe of Tory database used in election robocalls
- The Council of Canadians is calling on the Conservative Party to make a list of everyone who had access to its electoral database during the last federal election and turn the information over to the RCMP and the commissioner of elections. "Anything less at this point would be a coverup," the council said in a press release Friday. more »
- Massive church service to test Bomber’s parking plan
- Skyscraper developers ordered to pay $3M in 2011
- Window shattered on bus in Winnipeg
- Early summer bad time for crashes, Manitoba RCMP say
- Winnipeg gets first urban reserve
- MTS to sell Allstream, put $200M to pension and debt
- Manitoba ex-MPs 'vindicated' with robocalls ruling
- Survivors of day schools share stories of abuse, pain
- Possible explosive device prompts large police presence