Phoenix Sinclair inquiry needs full disclosure, woman says
CBC News
Posted: Jul 5, 2012 1:03 PM CT
Last Updated: Jul 5, 2012 1:53 PM CT
A woman who was at the centre of a high-profile Manitoba inquiry in 1989 says the media should be free to publish the names of social workers involved in the upcoming Phoenix Sinclair inquiry.
Marion Willis, a child welfare worker, had been accused of concealing evidence in the 1988 suicide of Lester Norman Desjarlais, a teenager born on Sandy Bay Ojibway First Nation.
He hanged himself in the backyard of his foster home after suffering years of sexual abuse.
Phoenix Sinclair, seen in this undated photo, was discovered dead in March 2006 on the Fisher River First Nation in Manitoba. (Family photo)The subsequent inquest under provincial court judge Brian Giesbrecht exonerated Willis completely and instead found the case rife with political interference on the part of the First Nation leaders.
The inquest report subsequently called for the banning of band leaders from sitting on the boards of native child and family services agencies.
Willis told the CBC's Information Radio program that she believes everything about the case had to be transparent in order for the inquiry to succeed.
"Initially it was a horrific experience, but at the same time, I realize then as I do now that within any system — and especially when it involves children — we have to open ourselves up to public scrutiny," she said in an interview Thursday.
"In my situation, I had absolutely nothing to hide and I knew that if I was allowed to tell the story, the truth would unfold, and that's exactly what did happen."
Publication ban argued
A hearing is presently underway in Winnipeg over whether media outlets should be allowed to identify social workers involved in the tragic life and death of Phoenix Sinclair.
A public inquiry is set for September to examine how the child welfare system failed to protect Phoenix, who was beaten to death in her home at the age of five.
Lawyers for the union representing child welfare authorities and the social workers, as well as lawyers for several child welfare agencies, are asking for a publication ban that would forbid reporters from naming or photographing any of the workers who were involved in Phoenix's case.
The Manitoba Government Employees Union argues that naming social workers in the inquiry could expose them to persecution.
Willis disagrees.
"The workers will indeed face a lot of challenges but again, I stood by my principles back in the '80s and I stick by them now; our child welfare system exists to protect children, not those that work in it," she said.
"The entire point of a public inquiry is to bring truth to the public and expose wrongdoing. If there is a media ban this will not happen," she added.
"It is also very important for the community to see that things are proceeding in a transparent and open way. If the media is blocked out, then this won't happen."
At the same time she hopes that individual workers do not become the focus of the inquiry.
"Whenever anything ever goes wrong within the child welfare system, the system always looks for someone to blame when in fact the culprit is usually the system itself," she said.
"There's supposed to be layers of oversight here, it doesn't just falls on the workers, it falls on the system."
Share Tools
Latest Manitoba News Headlines
- Downtown food, cycling tour attracts over 50 people
- Winnipeg's first-ever restaurant bicycle tour attracted over 50 people Wednesday evening. more »
- Manitoba aboriginal child poverty rate over 60%
- Manitoba's aboriginal child poverty rate is well above the national average, according to a new report from the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives. more »
- Would-be Brandon thief makes off with single glass of wine
- A Brandon homeowner was left scratching her head after a mysterious break in Tuesday morning. more »
- More seniors dying in bedrail accidents, reports show
- More seniors have died in Manitoba after becoming trapped in their bed rails, despite years of warnings from U.S. and Canadian health authorities. more »
Must Watch
Top News Headlines
- Sopranos star James Gandolfini dies in Italy
- Actor James Gandolfini, best known for his Emmy-winning portrayal of a conflicted New Jersey mob boss in the acclaimed HBO cable television series The Sopranos, has died while vacationing in Rome, the network said on Wednesday. more »
- Canada buys rare War of 1812 collection for $573K
- The government of Canada was the winning bidder for a large collection of letters, maps and other papers that once belonged to Sir John Sherbrooke, the lieutenant-governor of Nova Scotia who conquered Maine for the British during the War of 1812. The collection sold for $573,000 at auction in London. more »
- Caregiving dads pay steep penalties at work, study says
- Fathers who participate in child rearing and housework are likely to be labeled slackers and "failed men" at work, according to a study spearheaded by researchers at the University of Toronto and Long Island University. Are active dads the norm at your workplace? more »
- Dozens of children seized from Manitoba Mennonite community
- Child welfare authorities have removed all but one child from a small Mennonite community in rural Manitoba. more »
- Dozens of children seized from Manitoba Mennonite community
- Lick It List resurrected for 2nd dying dog
- Winnipegger warns drivers of photo radar trap
- Has the lost bell of Batoche been found in Manitoba?
- Thousands of caterpillars descend on Lake Manitoba
- Taylor Swift concert plan targets stadium traffic woes
- More seniors dying in bedrail accidents, reports show
- Search continues for Jennifer Catcheway 5 years later
- Would-be Brandon thief makes off with single glass of wine


A New Home for the Bombers