Canadian links sought in U.S. counterfeit drug probe
Canadians named in legal documents in fake cancer drugs case
By Karen Pauls, CBC News
Posted: Jun 20, 2012 4:08 AM CT
Last Updated: Jun 20, 2012 5:43 PM CT
Related
Related Stories
External Links
- U.S. FDA warning about counterfeit Altuzan (April 2012)
- U.S. FDA warning about counterfeit Avastin (February 2012)
(Note:CBC does not endorse and is not responsible for the content of external links.)
U.S. authorities are looking into connections between two Canadian businessmen and the sale of counterfeit cancer drugs to American oncologists earlier this year, CBC News has learned.
Legal documents link the Canadians and some of their companies to the U.S. Food and Drug Administration's investigation of two cases of counterfeit versions of bevacizumab, an injectable cancer medication that goes by the brand names Avastin and Altuzan.
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration released these images in April of versions of Altuzan that it found to be counterfeit. (U.S. Food and Drug Administration)The fake cancer drugs were purchased by nearly 100 physicians, mostly in California, and the FDA is now trying to track where they came from.
CBC News has obtained a copy of a U.S. grand jury subpoena, asking doctors to hand over documents related to the purchase of foreign-market drugs from a long list of companies and people — many of which have Canadian connections.
"We're taking it very seriously," said Connie Jung of the FDA's Centre for Drug Evaluation and Research in Washington.
"These medical practices are buying unapproved products from foreign sources. Because of this risky practice, what it does is put our patients at risk," she said.
"We don't know where they are coming from, we don't know where they've been manufactured. We don't know how they've been handled."
Doctors horrified
Benjamin Gluck, a Los Angeles-based lawyer who represents several affected physicians, says his clients were horrified to discover they may have given patients fake drugs.
"As far as the doctors knew, they were dealing with a licensed pharmacy in Montana," Gluck said.
"Once they understood … they may have been misled about that, frankly, they feel they are victims of this as well."
The physicians were approached by a drug salesman named Paul Bottomley, who provided them with an order form from a company called Montana Healthcare Solutions (MHCS).
CBC News has obtained a copy of the order form, in which MHCS was offering 400-milligram vials of Altuzan and Avastin for up to $1,875 US — about $400 less than the manufacturer's price.
According to Gluck, Bottomley told physicians he could offer good prices on approved drugs that they were already buying from other distributors.
"The prices were cheap enough that it was worth buying from them, but they were never so cheap that it raised any kind of suspicion with the doctors," Gluck said.
"Quite frankly, as one of my clients explained, even with the discounts local hospitals [have] — because they have these special buying groups and can get special discounts — [they] were probably paying less than he was."
Some of the physicians did some due diligence, and found Montana Healthcare Solutions was a registered pharmacy based in Montana. They bought and gave the drugs to their patients, Gluck said.
The FDA now says some of those drugs were counterfeit and did not contain any active ingredients.
Gluck said his clients were distressed to hear that, and shocked that they inadvertently bought drugs that were brought in from a foreign supplier, which is illegal in the U.S.
"It appears now that the supplier, the distributor, the people behind this scheme were taking great efforts to make sure there was no indication. For example, when the practices had to call Montana Supply, they called a phone number with a Montana area code and Montana telephone exchange," Gluck said.
"We are told now that, in fact, those phones may have in fact been ringing somewhere else — maybe in Canada or Barbados."
Calls allegedly rerouted to Winnipeg call centre
According to allegations contained in court documents, phone calls to Montana Healthcare Solutions were rerouted to a call centre in Winnipeg, at the headquarters of CanadaDrugs.com.
Kris Thorkelson is seen working at CanadaDrugs.com's facility in Winnipeg in 2003. (CBC)That company is owned by internet and wholesale pharmacist Kris Thorkelson, who is one of the men named in the U.S. grand jury subpoena.
The Barbados connection is through Thomas Haughton, a Canadian citizen who is Thorkelson's brother-in-law.
Haughton owns several drug distribution companies in Barbados and the United Kingdom.
Court documents also reveal that in 2010, Bottomley sold Montana Healthcare Solutions to Rockley Ventures, which is owned by Haughton. MHCS is also known as Quality Specialty Products (QSP).
"We have information that indicates that doctors purchase from QSP, Quality Specialty Products, and they basically supplied unapproved drugs to the medical practices," Jung said.
Bottomley's lawyer, Jay Lansing, told CBC News in an email that his client has not been charged.
"During the time that Mr. Bottomley owned and operated Montana Healthcare Solutions, he never sold Avastin or Altuzan; he never sold any counterfeit medications; and he never sold any adulterated medications," Lansing wrote.
But while Bottomley has not been charged criminally, authorities in the U.S. have seized nearly $1.4 million in cash and two vehicles worth nearly $200,000, based on accusations that Bottomley may have profited from selling illegal pharmaceuticals.
The U.S. Attorney's Office is also seeking the forfeiture of 11 parcels of Montana property owned by Bottomley, according to court documents obtained by CBC News. None of the allegations against him have been proven in court.
'Chain of custody'
The tragedy is that these two counterfeit cancer drugs were given to very sick people, said Len Lichtenfeld, deputy chief medical officer for the American Cancer Society in Atlanta.
"Imagine the people or families who have been treated at this time, who passed away. They must be wondering whether or not this drug made a difference in the lives of their loved ones. That to me is absolutely the worst scenario," he said.
"Everybody is on notice, especially the doctors who buy drugs. That the chain of custody of that drug — from the person who manufactures it, through the middlemen who sell it, to the final step into that doctor's office — that chain of custody is critically important."
The FDA and its counterparts in Europe are trying to trace where the counterfeit drugs came from.
The chain is murky, but it's believed the product may have originated in Turkey, been purchased by a Syrian middleman, and resold to an Egyptian company called SAWA.
It used the product to fill an order for Hadicon AG, a Swiss drug distributor, which sold the product to Caremed of Denmark, which sent the counterfeit product to two wholesalers in the United Kingdom.
One of the U.K. wholesalers is River East Supplies Ltd., which is owned by Haughton.
It may have been repackaged and relabelled in Barbados before being sent to Montana Healthcare Solutions, which is also known as QSP.
Some of the counterfeit drugs were then sold to American oncologists before they were confiscated by the FDA.
'I have nothing to hide'
The claims against Thorkelson and Haughton have not been proven in court.
Neither Thorkelson nor Haughton has returned any calls or emails from CBC News requesting comment.
But in a recent interview with CBS News in Barbados, Haughton confirmed that River East Supplies sent some of the counterfeit Avastin to the U.S.
Haughton said he did not realize the product was fake.
"For me, that's shocking and so disappointing," he told the U.S. television network.
"I have nothing to hide. The businesses I have are ethical, safe and legal."
U.S. authorities consider Haughton's business of shipping foreign-made drugs to American buyers illegal, but Haughton said he is breaking no laws in the countries from which he operates.
Wholesalers ship foreign drugs to the U.S. because American pharmaceuticals are some of the most expensive in the world. The traders buy the product at a discount overseas and sell it at a markup.
"It was only a matter of time before counterfeit penetration occurred," said David MacKay, a former executive director of the Canadian International Pharmacy Association, and a former employee of CanadaDrugs.com.
"If you think about the various points of distribution, the insertion of counterfeit [drugs] could have occurred anywhere," he added.
"If there was lax or minimal regulatory oversight, one might not know, because the network is so vast with so much product moving through it, that being able to catch a small amount of counterfeit product is immensely difficult."
Share Tools
Latest Manitoba News Headlines
- Kids of MANFF officials paid for mileage, overtime
- The agency in charge of disbursing federal money to 2011 flood evacuees paid thousands of dollars in overtime and mileage expenses –in some cases, to a senior official or the children of senior officials, CBC News has learned. more »
- Disputed city golf course plan goes to executive committee
- The City of Winnipeg's controversial golf plan is up for debate today at city hall. more »
- Winnipeg house fire sends 1 to hospital
- A woman was taken to hospital after house fire in Winnipeg on Wednesday. more »
- Eritreans in Canada say consul still demands cash from them
- Evidence obtained by CBC News suggests Eritrea's top diplomat in Canada is again soliciting taxes from the Eritrean community despite a threat by Canada eight months ago not to renew his credentials if he kept at it. more »
Must Watch
Top News Headlines
- Oklahoma residents begin to return home after deadly tornado
- Rescue workers raced to complete the search for survivors and the dead in the Oklahoma City suburb where a mammoth tornado destroyed countless homes, cleared lots down to bare red earth and claimed 24 lives, including those of nine children.
more »
- Video forensics: How easy would it be to fake a Rob Ford video?
- Two media outlets reported last week that they had seen a cellphone video of Mayor Rob Ford allegedly smoking crack, a claim that has gone global. If a video does surface, how easy would it be to determine its authenticity? CBC News asked video forensic analyst David McKay. more »
- Tim Bosma memorial today in hall that hosted his wedding reception
- The widow of Tim Bosma, the Hamilton man killed after taking two strangers on a test drive in a truck he had listed for sale online, will say goodbye to her husband at a public memorial today in the same hall where they celebrated their marriage just three years ago. more »
- Eritreans in Canada say consul still demands cash from them
- Evidence obtained by CBC News suggests Eritrea's top diplomat in Canada is again soliciting taxes from the Eritrean community despite a threat by Canada eight months ago not to renew his credentials if he kept at it. more »
- How the weather info that storm chasers use can keep you safe
- Radar imagery and a stream of weather information are readily available to the public when severe weather bears down. more »
- "Unbelievable" rain soaks southern Manitoba
- Manitobans weigh into the senate scandal
- Man dies after car plunges into Winnipeg pond
- Manitoba residents question weather warning system
- Legendary grocer Joe Cantor dies
- Winnipeg car-sharing program doubles fleet
- Manitoba RCMP lay 43 impaired driving charges in a week
- Winnipeg UFC main event scrapped due to Renan Barao injury
- Country song penned by CBC Manitoba listeners
