Manitoba union could delay Phoenix Sinclair inquiry
MGEU challenges legal validity of inquiry into girl's death
CBC News
Posted: Feb 5, 2012 9:20 PM CST
Last Updated: Feb 6, 2012 9:45 AM CST
Related
Related Links
A public inquiry into the murder of a five-year-old Manitoba girl could be delayed by the union representing the province's child-welfare workers.
The Manitoba Government and General Employees' Union (MGEU) has filed a motion questioning the legal validity and jurisdiction of the provincial inquiry into the 2005 death of Phoenix Victoria Hope Sinclair.
The body of Phoenix Sinclair, seen here in an undated photo, was discovered in March 2006 on the Fisher River First Nation. A public inquiry into her death is slated to begin May 23. (Family photo)Phoenix was killed on the Fisher River First Nation in June 2005, but it wasn't until March 2006 that her body was found wrapped in plastic and in an unmarked shallow grave.
The girl died after neglect and repeated abuse by her mother, Samantha Kematch, and stepfather, Karl McKay, both of whom were convicted of first-degree murder in December 2008.
The inquiry, which was ordered by the province in 2006, aims to examine how Manitoba's Child and Family Services officials failed to protect Phoenix and why her death went undiscovered for months.
The inquiry is set to begin on May 23, but that start date could be pushed back if the MGEU succeeds with its motion.
Jeff Gindin, the lawyer representing both Phoenix's biological father and her former foster mother, told CBC News he was served with the motion last week.
"The inquiry was called quite some time ago. A lot of people have been working very hard in preparing for the inquiry, including the commission counsel interviewing witnesses," Gindin said Sunday.
"MGEU has filed a motion some time ago, trying to restrict publication of the names of their employees who may testify," he added. "Now, with a few months to go, they file this motion."
Lawyers for the union will appear in a Winnipeg courtroom on Thursday to get a hearing date set.
Was in foster care
Phoenix had spent much of her young life in foster care before Kematch regained custody of her in 2004.
The public inquiry had previously been delayed by unsuccessful appeals by Kematch and McKay.
Last year, commission counsel said more time was needed to wade through piles of child welfare documents, all of which require court permission before they can be made public.
As for the MGEU's motion, Gindin said the public-sector union should have filed it months ago, when planning for the inquiry was in its earlier stages.
"From a strictly logical point of view, you would think someone who had a problem with the inquiry even taking place would maybe deal with that first and early on," he said. "I'm sure that someone's going to say that, and essentially that was the commissioner's response. We've been working hard at this for 11 months, and we're not going to just stop easily."
Neither officials nor lawyers for the MGEU responded to requests from CBC News for comment on Sunday.
The Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs and the Southern Chiefs Organization are holding a news conference on Monday to talk about the union's action, which both aboriginal groups say is "unnecessarily stalling" the inquiry.
Share Tools
Latest Manitoba News Headlines
- RCMP commissioner pledges to rid force of 'bad apples'
- The RCMP's disciplinary process is so bureaucratic and out of date that "bad apples" end up staying on the force long after they should be thrown out, RCMP Commissioner Bob Paulson says in a remarkably frank open letter to Canadians. more »
- Safety of photo radar cameras questioned
- Critics of photo radar in Winnipeg say there have been more vehicle crashes at intersections where red-light cameras were installed. more »
- Police officers on trial for obstructing justice
- Two Winnipeg police officers are on trial on charges of obstructing justice, accused of falsifying notes in a drug case from 2008. more »
- Truck traffic worries Lord Roberts residents
- Residents in Winnipeg's Lord Roberts neighbourhood are worried about the safety of their kids as construction projects send big trucks down their streets. more »
Top News Headlines
- New Italian earthquake death toll rises to 9
- At least nine people are reported dead in a magnitude 5.8 earthquake that struck the same area of northern Italy stricken by another fatal tremor on May 20. more »
- B.C. police shooting video sparks calls for new probe
- Amateur video of the shooting of a mentally ill Vancouver man five years ago has prompted calls for B.C.'s police complaint commissioner and Crown prosecutors to take another look at the case. more »
- 'Engine shutdown' forced Air Canada jet to land
- A Japan-bound Air Canada Boeing 777 made an emergency landing at Toronto's Pearson airport on Monday, after one of its engines failed. more »
- CP Rail union, Tories battle over collective bargaining
- The federal Conservatives are defending their plan to force striking Canadian Pacific Railway employees back to work as a way to keep the economy on track, while the union representing 4,800 workers says their collective bargaining rights are under attack. more »
- Missing Winnipeg kids found in Mexico are back with mom
- Police officers on trial for obstructing justice
- Safety of photo radar cameras questioned
- Effects of CP Rail strike could linger past legislated end
- Outhouse bear attack survivor was grabbed from 'throne'
- RCMP commissioner pledges to rid force of 'bad apples'
- Teachers oppose letting parents opt kids from classes
- Neighbour may have helped find missing kids in Mexico
- Rail strikers not surprised by back-to-work legislation

