Hydro employees intimidated: whistleblower
Former consultant alleges some workers being threatened over mismanagement claims.
Last Updated: Tuesday, November 10, 2009 | 6:43 PM CT
CBC News
Manitoba Hydro's head office is based in a recently-constructed downtown Winnipeg building. (CBC)A Manitoba Hydro whistleblower said Tuesday that employees at the publicly owned utility are being threatened to stay quiet about allegations of mismanagement and that she fears an investigation into her claims is being swept under the rug.
The whistleblower is a former Hydro consultant who works for a New York-based risk-management firm. She came forward nearly a year ago to allege that the Crown corporation is miscalculating how much power it can generate and sell and that the province could face significant blackouts in the future.
A complaint filed with the Manitoba Ombudsman's Office under provincial whistleblower legislation in December 2008 accuses the utility of taking too many risks with the province's power supply and alleges mismanagement has cost Hydro more than $1 billion.
The complaint also suggests Hydro CEO Bob Brennan was told that future financial forecasts are incorrect. When he was supplied with evidence of that he ignored it, the complaint alleges.
CBC News has decided not to identify the whistleblower at her request.
Hydro CEO Bob Brennan has denied the consultant's allegations, saying previously that they were "flawed," and that a blackout "just couldn't happen."
In an internal memo dated Oct. 26, Brennan told Hydro staff that the reports of potential blackouts and financial difficulties "are completely misguided and without any substance whatsoever." He also called the allegations of mismanagement "hurtful."
But the whistleblower said in a Tuesday interview with a CBC News investigative team that Brennan is relying on calculations from an archaic computer system to make that statement.
In an open letter obtained by CBC News, the whistleblower said what she uncovered were "'systemic and massive' computer system flaws — with obsolete computers maintaining the calculations.
"Massive system errors and inadequate mathematics were found in the power calculation of 'blackouts' or reliability conditions — which could lead to faulty results in keeping the lights on," the letter said.
She also said she has sources within Hydro that are being told they'll be fired if they continue to talk and that some are already being subjected to internal investigations.
"People should not be in a position of having their livelihoods threatened to participate in an important investigation of serious allegations," she said. "It's a way of trying to prevent the facts from coming out."
She added that she's never been asked by the provincial auditor to produce her evidence.
A Hydro spokesman said Tuesday that no employees have been threatened with dismissal. Neither have any come forward to file allegations similar to the whistleblower's, he said .
Auditor general admits to slow response
On Oct. 21, Manitoba Finance Minister Rosann Wowchuk announced a special audit of Hydro based on the whistleblower's complaint and asked the Office of the Auditor General to make it a priority.
Tuesday Auditor General Carol Bellringer said her office has not yet received all of the documentation needed to complete the probe and admits it should have been tackled more quickly.
In his memo to staff, Brennan also said he's confident the auditor's review "will vindicate Manitoba Hydro and demonstrate that the corporation is managing its risks in the most prudent and responsible manner."
CBC News has made available the consultant's letter and Brennan's internal memo to online readers.
They can be found by clicking the links at the right near the top of this story.
If you have any tips for the CBC News investigative team, call the confidential tip line at 204-788-3744.
Share Tools
Latest Manitoba News Headlines
- Missing boater may have struck reef, police say
- A boater who has been missing since Tuesday may have struck a reef, police say, adding a search for the man is continuing. more »
- Crime spree ends with 46 break-in charges
- Police in Winnipeg think they have caught the person behind a string of early-morning break-ins, where a vehicle was used to smash into businesses. more »
- RCMP to close labs in Halifax, Winnipeg, Regina
- The RCMP is closing forensic laboratories in Halifax, Winnipeg and Regina and consolidating them with three others in a move the force says will lead to faster, more efficient service. more »
- Winnipeg's Union Station to get facelift
- The 100-year-old Union Station in Winnipeg is set to get a $6.5 million facelift. more »
Top News Headlines
- Attack on Syrian villages deadliest yet, activists say
- More than 90 people have been killed by regime forces in a district of central Syria, activists say, and as many as half the victims may have been children. more »
- Aylmer triple stabbing leads to first-degree murder charges

- The estranged partner of a young mother who was stabbed to death along with her parents at their home in Aylmer, Que., has been charged with first-degree murder Friday. more »
- Tornado touchdown confirmed near Montreal
- Trees were uprooted, roofs damaged and windows shattered as severe thunderstorms, and possibly a tornado, rattled through southwestern Quebec Friday night. more »
- The risks and responsibilities of taking on Mt. Everest

- The deaths of six climbers last weekend on Mt. Everest, with more summits underway this weekend, fuels the debate about the risks and responsibilities of high altitude climbing. more »
- Winnipeg WWE wrestler Chris Jericho suspended after flag incident
- Crime spree ends with 46 break-in charges
- Missing boater may have struck reef, police say
- Outhouse bear attack survivor was grabbed from 'throne'
- First-time homebuyers find frustration in Winnipeg
- Winnipeg's Union Station to get facelift
- Kelvin High School celebrates 100 years
- RCMP to close labs in Halifax, Winnipeg, Regina
- MPI asked to cover tab for officers' overtime

