Mosquito repellents: Test-driving brands and natural spray
Manitobans may be in for a slap-happy summer — also known as mosquito season — so we put four bug repellents to the test, including an all-natural product made near Winnipeg.
So the CBC's Katie Nicholson asked the Riverview boys' under-12 soccer team, and the players' parents and grandparents, to test-drive four products:
- Muskol, the top-selling repellent at Mountain Equipment Co-op in Winnipeg.
- Off! Family Care spray, a top household seller.
- Off! Clip-On, which consists of a repellent cartridge and a fan in a small clip-on case.
- Manitoba Mist, a natural product made in St. Norbert, Man.
The non-scientific, anecdotal test took place at a soccer practice this past weekend at the Riverview Community Centre.
The products were tested not only on players, but also on spectators sitting — and swatting mosquitoes — on the sidelines.
"If you're sitting, they're a little bit more problematic," said Stephen Segal, a parent who tried the Off! Family Care spray.
"Sometimes they can get onto you and bug you. You'd have to sort of get up and get around, move around."
After an hour on the field, the results were mostly positive for all four products.
"It just poisons the mosquitoes," Nico Distasio said of the Muskol spray, which contains a 30 per cent concentration of the chemical DEET.
Staff at Mountain Equipment Co-Op say customers are generally looking for insect repellents that are effective and long-lasting.
"DEET's really effective and it works for keeping mosquitoes away and preventing things like West Nile," said Cory Funk, a product expert at MEC.
- IN DEPTH | West Nile virus: What you need to know
"A lot of people do go towards DEET because it is the one thing that's known and proven to work well to repel mosquitoes."
Off! Family Care and Clip-On
The Off! Family Care spray worked for Sam Segal, who reported "no bites" after practice, but it didn't work as well as father Stephen had hoped.
"They were kind of sitting on me and they were about to bite," Segal said. "I might go for something stronger."
"I think it's better than the spray-ons," said team player Brennan Elphick. "I don't like the feeling [of repellent spray] on my skin, while I could just wear this."
Carol Polonski, a grandmother who also tried the clip-on repellent, said she liked it even though it costs a little more than sprays.
"I don't think price is an issue if it works," she said.
Polonski said the only concern she had was whether the repellent would keep mosquitoes from flying under people's hats, for example.
There were also good reviews of Manitoba Mist, the spray containing citronella and other essential oils.
"I liked it. It was a bit sticky at the start but it went away after a few minutes," said Jakob McKenna.
Parent Danny Descoteau was initially skeptical about the natural spray, but after trying it said he would test it again.
"I'd like to try it when we're sitting around at the lake or something like that and see how it works, but it semed to be good," he said.
Farm owner wanted DEET-free alternative
Manitoba Mist was developed by Louise May of Aurora Farm. She said she wanted a DEET-free mosquito repellent for her family, employees and farm animals.
"I'm just not happy with the DEET-based chemical products and wanted to offer an alternative for people who want to go natural," she said.
When asked why she doesn't want to use DEET-based products, May replied, "Even Health Canada has said that DEET is a neurotoxin for kids under 12, so that should be enough to not be able to use it anymore."
The federal agency allows up to 30 per cent concentration of DEET in insect repellents to be used by adults and children over the age of 12.
Manitoba Mist's label does not indicate that it's a mosquito repellent, and May said there's a good reason for that.
"We and many other companies, small companies, across the country have been complaining about this, trying to make this change. But until then, I don't want to take the chance of having my products pulled."
According to Health Canada, "Pesticides, including personal insect repellents and outdoor insecticides, must be registered in Canada under the Pest Control Products Act."
The agency says it evaluates pesticides before they are registered to make sure they are effective for their intended use and they meet current health and safety standards.
With files from the CBC's Katie Nicholson