University groups try to stave off offensive costumes pre-Halloween
The student union at Brock University created a list of prohibited costumes
A growing number of institutions are starting to take a more proactive approach to potentially offensive outfits by developing strategies and even explicit policies to prevent people from donning controversial getups.
Costumes depicting specific cultural traditions are the most common focus of such efforts, which are making themselves felt in schools and universities.
The student union at Brock University in St. Catharines, Ont., recently prepared a list of prohibited costumes for its annual Halloween bash. The list features any form of headdress, costumes that mock suicide or rape, those depicting transgender activist Caitlyn Jenner, or outfits featuring a culture's traditional attire.
Such approaches don't always sit right with groups concerned with issues of censorship.
- Teacher turns costume shopping trip into teachable moment about cultural stereotypes
- Winnipeg nightclub blasted for blackface photo
The Canadian Civil Liberties Association says Halloween forces people to walk a particularly fine line as they juggle cultural sensitivity with freedom of expression.
Equality Program Director Noa Mendelsohn Aviv said Halloween is steeped in a long tradition of social activism which would not have been possible if participants were excessively concerned with offending others.
She said the tradition of wearing costumes, for instance, often gave repressed members of the LGBTQ community opportunities to express themselves more fully at a time when such actions were discouraged.
Social censure can be effective
She said protesters should have every right to voice their displeasure, but celebrants should also be allowed to be offensive.
"We have to be very careful not to repress that kind of expression," she said. "It's very important there be room for all kinds of different personal and political and subversive and dissenting expression, and Halloween is a time when that really happens."
Mendelsohn Aviv praised one technique put into practice three years ago at McGill University, whose student union issued colour-coded tags to attendees of its 2014 Halloween party. Green tags meant the costume was considered appropriate, yellow tags were for those whose choice of attire was considered questionable, and red tags were reserved for those believed to have crossed a line into offensive territory.
- Offensive Halloween costumes won't get passing grade at McGill
- Liberal MP Linda Lapointe deletes photos of her 'unacceptable' Halloween costume
Mendelsohn Aviv said social censure, rather than more active punishments, can be an effective way to give everyone a voice while still expressing that certain costumes may be in poor taste.
Student Society vice-president of University Affairs Erin Sobat said the McGill has abandoned the colour-coding system in recent years and is now focused on educating people about appropriate costumes ahead of the 2016 festivities.
Like Brock, McGill frowns upon cultural costumes but has not gone so far as to prepare a prohibited list.
"I think it's worth asking who is doing the subverting and who is benefiting from that or not," he said. "It's easy, as a white person, to dress up as a black person for a day and then go back to being a white person and not having to face the daily discrimination and stereotyping that goes along with that."
Hughes views it somewhat different, arguing people's feelings are valid whether the costume-wearer agrees with them or not.
"It's not for me to say, 'that shouldn't affect you that way,"' he said. "If it does, it does."
The Toronto District School Board said in an email that it doesn't have any policy specifically related to Halloween costumes, but expects any get up to "comply with the board's appropriate dress policy."