Despite letters from other MPPs and MPs, Bob Bratina isn't ready to support LRT

Filomena Tassi supports LRT. So do six other MPs and MPPs. But Bob Bratina says there are too many unanswered questions.

Bratina is a former Hamilton mayor who butted heads with some councillors over LRT

Then-mayor Bob Bratina refers to the city's Rapid Rail plan during an LRT debate in 2013. Now a Liberal MP for Hamilton East-Stoney Creek, Bratina says he won't put his name down as supporting the project because there are too many unanswered questions. (Samantha Craggs/CBC)

Hamilton MPs and MPPs have added their voices to the latest chorus of those in favour of light rail transit (LRT) here. But one name is noticeably absent – Hamilton East-Stoney Creek MP Bob Bratina, a former mayor who says there are too many unanswered questions.

Six federal and provincial reps wrote a bipartisan letter to the city this week saying the planned $1 billion LRT system would be "a great benefit and building it is the right thing to do for our community." The letter is the latest of a number of letters supporting the project.

I did not sign the letter because there are still too many unanswered questions about the project, such as who will receive the fare revenue.- Bob Bratina , Hamilton East-Stoney Creek MP

Ted McMeekin, Liberal MPP for Ancaster-Dundas-Flamborough-Westdale, signed the letter. So did the following:

  • David Christopherson, NDP MP for Hamilton Centre.
  • Scott Duvall, NDP MP for Hamilton Mountain.
  • Andrea Horwath, Hamilton Centre MPP and Ontario NDP leader.
  • Paul Miller, Hamilton East-Stoney Creek NDP MPP.
  • Monique Taylor, NDP MPP for Hamilton Mountain.

Filomena Tassi, Liberal MP for Hamilton West-Ancaster-Dundas, also wrote an open letter in favour of LRT.

"I am very proud to say that I support Hamilton city council's several successful resolutions that choose LRT as a way forward for improved transit infrastructure in our great and thriving city," Tassi wrote.

Filomena Tassi, Hamilton West-Ancaster-Dundas Liberal MP, has written a letter supporting LRT. (Kelly Bennett/CBC)

Bratina's signature was also missing from a letter this month from seven former mayors and regional chairs who support LRT.

Bratina told CBC Hamilton that he didn't sign the recent letter because there are too many unanswered questions, particularly around fare revenue from the B line.

City transit officials say the line from McMaster University to the Queenston traffic circle – the proposed B line LRT route – is the most profitable in the city, and helps pay for transit in the rest of the city.

City councillors have asked question about what happens to that revenue when Metrolinx builds LRT. 

"I did not sign the letter because there are still too many unanswered questions about the project, such as who will receive the fare revenue," Bratina wrote.

Nobody really wants it. They're all scared of it.- Victor Starecky, Hamilton business owner

He said he hasn't been doing any LRT-related work in Ottawa, but has had "informal conversations" with Hamilton businesses about the project.

He also wrote a letter to the Hamilton Spectator saying there shouldn't be a rush to build LRT.

Bratina, then mayor of Hamilton, met with Transportation Minister Steven Del Duca in a closed-door meeting about LRT in 2014. (Samantha Craggs/CBC)

"The notion by others that we need to 'get our act together' is a rush to judgment council is not currently willing to take until important questions are answered," he wrote.

LRT is a hot topic at Hamilton city hall right now, as politicians prepare to debate in October whether to accept the $1 billion system from the province. City council has voted several times in favour of asking for the province for money, but since Premier Kathleen Wynne announced it last June, some have reservations.

Bratina's stance on LRT caused friction when he was mayor from 2010 to 2014. In 2013, he faced off with councillors in a heated debate over whether to state that LRT was Hamilton's transit priority, even having an exchange with city manager Chris Murray that led to an integrity commissioner investigation. (Bratina was found not to have broken the council code of conduct.)

Unless the federal government participates in the project, I just don't weigh into it.- David Sweet, MP, Flamborough-Glanbrook

Bratina argued that LRT wasn't necessary yet since the city hadn't built up adequate ridership. He wanted BRT instead. 

David Sweet, Conservative MP for Flamborough-Glanbrook, didn't sign the recent letter of support for LRT either. He was asked to sign it, he said. But he's leaving it up to council.

"My record has been, in the 10 plus years I've been elected, that unless the federal government participates in the project, I just don't weigh into it."

The design has LRT running in the same lanes as cars on James Street North. (City of Hamilton)

The current plan will see LRT run from McMaster University to the Queenston traffic circle, with the route running on King Street East from Highway 403 to the delta. It will also run down James Street North from King to the West Harbour GO station – or the waterfront, budget permitting.

Terry Whitehead, Ward 8 councillor, plans to bring forward a motion at a future meeting to look at putting it on Main Street for that stretch instead. Staunch LRT advocates say that route has already been studied, and that changing now would add years to the project. Whitehead says that hasn't been studied adequately enough.

Meanwhile, more than 200 businesses have added their logos to a poster of those in favour of LRT, and developers such as Darko Vranich have written in favour.

But there's another movement afoot. Victor Starecky, owner of Weird Stuff at 1363 Main St. E., opposes LRT and plans to help distribute petitions this week to stop it. He says it will mean less vehicle traffic on the route, which his business needs.

He's talked to other business owners about it, he said.

"Nobody really wants it. They're all scared of it."

The goal is to "stop it, stall it or move it to Barton Street," he said.

On mobile? View the open letter from MPPs and MPs here.

On mobile? View the open letter from Filomena Tassi here.

On mobile? View the letter from past mayors and regional chairs here.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.