5 questions Hamilton's new council will have to ask itself

On Wednesday, Hamilton’s next city council will be sworn in. Here are five tricky questions it will have to confront during its four-year term.
Hamilton's new city council will be sworn in on Dec. 3. (Samantha Craggs/CBC)

On Wednesday, Hamilton’s next city council will be sworn in. It will have four new members and a new mayor in Fred Eisenberger, who was also mayor from 2006 to 2010.

The inaugural meeting on Dec. 3 will be largely ceremonial in nature. Eisenberger will give an inaugural address, and the city's children's choir will perform.

Here are five questions the new city council will have to ask itself in its next term:

1. Do I want Hamilton's housing boom to go up or out?

Hamilton is in the midst of a housing boom, and it will be up to the new council whether that boom happens in the form of sprawl or infilling and condo projects.

This doesn’t happen all at once, but vote by vote, council will shape the future housing market through planning and zoning decisions, rules that encourage certain types of development and how easy it is for developers to build.

The most recent example of housing-related growth is the Stoney Creek Urban Boundary Expansion (SCUBE), which will see Fruitland and Winona grow by a projected 21,000 residents over the next 20 years. Waterdown is also in the midst of a housing boom, with new subdivisions causing traffic snarls around the village. The city fought the Waterdown expansion and lost at the Ontario Municipal Board, and that’s where SCUBE will likely be decided too.

But with each planning meeting, council will influence development in its decisions and philosophy.

2. Do we want light rail transit?

It was discussed ad nauseum during the election, and the $1-billion LRT issue isn’t going away. The proposed line would run 13 kilometres from McMaster University to Eastgate Square and require reconfiguring traffic along Main and King in Hamilton’s downtown.

The province has allocated $15 billion for transit in the Greater Toronto Hamilton Area. LRT advocates hope that means $1 billion for Hamilton. Those against LRT, such as former mayoral candidate Brad Clark, say that money is all but spent on other projects, such as the electrification of GO service.

It will be up to the new council to advocate — or not — for a portion of that money, and to make decisions that are either for or against LRT. Council has voted twice in favour of LRT, but some have expressed wavering support, and there are now four new votes at the table. Eisenberger pledged a citizens’ panel during the election.

3. How should Hamilton present itself at the Pan Am Games?

The 2015 Pan Am Games are in July, and the new council will make decisions related to getting the city ready for the world. Those decisions include aesthetic ones, such as signage and landscaping around the city, as well as how it will handle the tourism and marketing of Hamilton during the games.

4. Should it fight the gasification plant?

The U.S.-based company Leveraged Green Technologies (LGT) wants a 20-year lease for a waste-to-energy gasification plant on Pier 15 on Hamilton’s harbour front. The city’s only direct authority over the project is zoning, which LGT could challenge at the OMB anyway. But the upcoming council will have to decide whether to exert its political and legal influence to fight the project at the provincial level, and to encourage other levels of government to push against it.

It has a waste treatment issue of its own too. The city plans a $111-million sewage sludge treatment plant on Woodward Avenue, and many details for it are still outstanding. Those will have to be OK’d by the new council.

Whether it be with the gasification plant or the sewage sludge treatment plant, the past council stressed that it didn’t want Hamilton taking waste from other areas.

5. How many citizen voices do we need?

One of the first topics coming before the new council will be how citizen voices are heard at city hall.

The city has 68 volunteer advisory committees — more than 20 more than Toronto has. Staff estimate they have cost the city more than $400,000 over the last four years. Refreshments alone have cost $9,200.

But many argue that these committees are important. Staff recommends, for example, merging its Aboriginal advisory group with its advisory groups on the status of women, immigrants, anti-racism and LGBTQ. They would all be merged into a new diversity, race relations and equity advisory committee.

Given that the new council will have Hamilton’s first openly gay councillor and first black councillor, it could be an interesting debate on whether all of these committees are necessary. The new council will also, likely in the next two months, vote on whether to follow the advice of its committee for anti-racism and develop an anti-racism resource centre.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.