Hamilton landlords say they warned police about anti-gentrification activists months ago

Barton Street businesses and landlords say police and the city have been ignoring their warnings about an escalating number of anti-gentrification vandalism incidents on the lower city strip dating back months.

'I'm just sad that it took this much destruction' to grab city's attention, restaurateur says

Hamilton police say they are still investigating after a group of masked protestors threw rocks at windows on Locke Street in Hamilton on Saturday night. (Ryan McGreal/Raise the Hammer)

Businesses and landlords on Hamilton's Barton Street say police and the city have been ignoring their warnings about an escalating number of anti-gentrification vandalism incidents on the lower city strip dating back months.

Now, with a spotlight firmly on the issue after a highly visible $100,000 property damage spree on Locke Street — one of Hamilton's most affluent and popular neighbourhoods — those same people are hoping authorities will finally take their concerns seriously. Some say it appears as long as these incidents were happening downtown or along Barton Street, there was no alarm. 

"I'm happy that the city is finally taking notice, but I'm pissed that it took this incident for that to happen," said Matt Cowan, chef and co-owner of the restaurant The Heather on Barton Street East.

"I'm just sad that it took this much destruction."

At around 10 p.m. ET Saturday, police said, about 30 people dressed in black with their faces covered walked through the streets of Hamilton carrying a banner that said, "We Are The Ungovernables."

Police say they set off fireworks in the Kirkendall neighbourhood in the city's southwest, damaging vehicles and throwing rocks at store windows. Several businesses on Locke Street were targeted.

Hamilton police give the latest on the investigation into a destructive vandalism spree that targeted one of Hamilton's neighbourhoods over the weekend 10:45

Cowan says when he heard about the incident, his thoughts immediately went out to the businesses that were affected — because he knew what they were feeling.

He says anti-gentrification activists have been targeting his restaurant since it opened a year ago. The Heather offers high-concept dining, which is not a staple on Barton Street, one of the more run-down sections of the city. However, it's a strip that some in the city feel will follow areas like Locke Street and James Street North in resurgence.

By contrast, anti-gentrification advocates worry that rising rents mean that lower-income people will get pushed out of their homes.

'This has been going on for years'

Cowan says a group of people smashed his restaurant window last April. Then, during the May Day March on May 1, a group targeted the restaurant again.

"They stood outside the building screaming threats at us and spitting on our windows," he said. "We've been to police and city hall, and nothing has happened.

"The mayor makes this seem like [Locke Street] is the first attack, but it's not. This has been going on for years."

At around 10 p.m. ET Saturday, some 30 individuals dressed in black clothing with their faces covered walked through the streets carrying a banner that said, 'We Are The Ungovernables,' according to police. (@OliverioCarmela/Twitter)

Krysta Boyer, a real estate agent and founder of Try Hamilton — which runs real estate tours — says she first encountered anti-gentrification activists in the summer of 2016. She was running a tour on Barton when about 20 masked protesters attacked the group, shooting sour milk from water guns and carrying signs with slogans like, "Developers + Investors = Predators. Defend Hamilton."

She says she and other stakeholders on Barton took their concerns to police and city representatives at a meeting last September.

"We felt like our concerns fell on deaf ears," she said.

At a press conference at Hamilton police headquarters Monday, Insp. Paul Hamilton said that he couldn't comment on if there was any connection between the incidents on Barton and what happened on Locke, but said police are "looking at all aspects" for the investigation.

Matt Cowan, left, and his wife Meg run The Heather on Barton Street. They say their business has been repeatedly targeted by anti-gentrification activists in recent months. (The Heather/Facebook)

"We know this is not a spontaneous act … this was very well planned and well executed," he said. The people involved in the protest wore multiple layers of clothing, he said, and once they discarded them, it was easy for them to blend into a crowd and get away.

"They turn down one street, take off some clothing, and then they look like any member of the community," he said.

Ongoing vandalism concerns

Architect and landlord Bill Curran, who owns property on Barton Street, has written a letter to Mayor Fred Eisenberger and Police Chief Eric Girt, saying the Locke Street incident could have been foreseen.

"It is sad to see what happened on Locke Street on Saturday, but we have been predicting this for months," he wrote.

"Police inaction over the roughly dozen incidents to date have emboldened these people, and this escalation is the expected outcome."

This user-submitted video shows fireworks being set off on Hamilton's Locke Street as a large mob walks by. 0:28

His letter itemizes eight incidents of anti-gentrification vandalism targeting businesses in recent months.

"Our concerns as business owners repeatedly targeted by the same group have been ignored by police and by city hall leadership."

CBC News has requested to speak with Girt and Eisenberger about those criticisms, but did not immediately receive a response.

Curran, Cowan and Boyer say they believe The Tower — an anarchist collective on Cannon Street — is responsible for the actions against their properties.

Insp. Paul Hamilton took questions from reporters about last weekend's incident on Locke Street in front of Hamilton police headquarters Monday afternoon. (Adam Carter/CBC)

No one from the Tower responded to messages from a reporter on Monday.

Hamilton would not say if investigators have spoken with anyone from the group.

"We haven't identified anybody yet. We do know there was the anarchist book fair taking place in the city on the weekend. I'm not connecting this to the book fair specifically, but like-minded people attended that event from right across the province," he said.

"We are investigating the possibility that there are people from outside this community that committed these acts."

adam.carter@cbc.ca

About the Author

Adam Carter

Reporter, CBC Hamilton

Adam Carter is a Newfoundlander who now calls Hamilton home. He enjoys a good story and playing loud music in dank bars. You can follow him on Twitter @AdamCarterCBC or drop him an email at adam.carter@cbc.ca.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.