Teen, mother launch complaint against abstinence-based sex ed

An Edmonton teem and her mother have filed a complaint with the Alberta Human Rights Commission over a high school sex education class delivered by a religious-based group.
Complaint lodged with the Alberta Human Rights Commission over class delivered by a religious-based group 2:10

An Edmonton teen and her mother have filed a complaint with the Human Rights Commission over a high school sex education class delivered by a religious-based group.

Last year, Emily Dawson, 18,  took part in a two-day class delivered as part of the Career and Life Management course at McNally High School.

The teenager says she was shocked by what she heard.

Trustee Michael Janz said board officials investigated the course and found it met the standards set by Alberta Education. (CBC)

“Basically shaming the girls and making them gatekeepers and meanwhile making it sound like the boys had no impulse control,” she said.  

The Edmonton Public School Board used the Pregnancy Care Centre to conduct the course.  The centre is affiliated with Care-Net, an American based anti-abortion movement. Both groups focus on advocating abstinence from sex.

“I have a friend that is a lesbian and she was asking what would happen if she didn't want to stay abstinent and then the educator said, ‘We're not here to talk about that,’” Dawson said.

Course meets provincial standards 

Kathy Dawson says she tried to pull her daughter Emily out of the class for the second day. But she says the school informed her that Emily had to take the class in order to pass her course.  

So she joined her daughter in the classroom. A single mother, Dawson said she was shocked what students were told about families like hers.

“Well, that our children are prone to depression, suicide, juvenile delinquency,” she said.

The remarks also surprised her daughter.

“It’s not something that you hear every day where you’re getting bashed for being in a single-parent home.”

Kathy Dawson was also upset the class appeared to focus on values instead of science. 

"I don't want them in the secular school," she said. "They may have a spot in the Catholic school ... because they are faith-based.

"My issue isn't with them ... because it's such a wide variety of families going to these (public) schools, let's leave the science to the school and the values to the parents."

Dawson started a petition and complained to the school board. Board officials investigated and found the course met the standards set by Alberta Education.  

“Our administration have looked into this in the district and they're confident that students in Edmonton public schools are receiving the sex education set by Alberta Education,” said Michael Janz, a trustee and deputy chairman of the board.

“So in the absence of new information, I remain supportive.”

The Alberta Human Rights Commission has now accepted the Dawsons' complaint. 

“I'm training up my kids to respect science and demand science in their education,” Kathy Dawson said. “So this is a long haul, and I'm fully prepared to take it all the way."

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.