Starved girl can be taken off life-support
Alberta judges refuse parents time to appeal to Supreme Court of Canada
CBC News
Posted: Sep 19, 2012 9:06 AM MT
Last Updated: Sep 19, 2012 9:48 PM MT
The Alberta Court of Appeal upheld a ruling Wednesday to remove a child from life-support over the objections of her parents who are accused of beating and starving her.
The three judges also rejected a request to stay their decision to give the parents time to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada.
Justice Frans Slatter, who read the unanimous decision, said the sanctity of life is a core value in society, "but human life must end."
The child could be taken off life-support in the next couple of days, giving enough time for the parents to visit her.
Each parent will get a chance to visit the girl at her hospital bed for 20 minutes within the next 24 hours.
The visits must be done separately and under police guard.
Kept alive by ventilator, feeding tube
The two-year-old, who can only be identified by her first initial, "M," is being kept alive by a ventilator and a feeding tube.
"For those who say the merciful thing is to let 'M' die, I would like to remind everyone that we don't condone euthanasia in Canada," Lydia Bubel, the lawyer for the child's father, argued before the court earlier in the morning.
She argued that giving the courts the power to decide over the child's life would "take sanctity of life away from families and … put it in the court's hands."
"This case is horrible," she told Justices Keith Ritter, Frans Slatter and Myra Bielby. "It's horrible any way that you look at it."
Parents charged with assault, negligence
Since the child's parents were arrested in May, they have been in jail on charges of aggravated assault, criminal negligence causing bodily harm and failing to provide the necessities of life.
They have been barred from speaking with each other or visiting the hospital, and they argue that has limited their ability to discuss their daughter's care.
Last week, a Court of Queen's Bench judge ruled the parents' desire to keep M alive out of love or religious beliefs is not necessarily in the child's best interest.
The judge also noted that if the child is removed from life-support and dies, the couple could be charged with her death.
Justice June Ross sided with doctors, who told the court that the girl's brain damage is so severe that she will never regain consciousness.
Case could have wide-ranging effects
Tim Caulfield, an expert in health-care law with the University of Alberta, says he wasn’t surprised that the ruling was upheld.
“I think the court of appeal came to a logical conclusion to this sad tale,” he said.
Caulfield says the case could have wide-ranging effects on future cases. It shows that the court has jurisdiction to step into similar matters, and sets the precedent that taking someone off life-support can be in their best interest.
He also thinks the case could clarify the law when religious beliefs conflict with medical advice.
The parents had previously argued that taking the girl off life-support was against their religious beliefs.
“I think the judge handled the religious aspect carefully, noting that it can be a factor and something that should be considered,” Caulfield said.
“But not in a case like this when you’re talking about an infant that hasn’t adopted a religion yet and hasn’t adopted a culture.”
Share Tools
Latest Edmonton News Headlines
- Man charged in stabbings near Kingsway transit station
- A man was taken into custody Saturday after three people were stabbed near the Kingsway Transit Station Saturday evening. more »
- Jeep driver apologizes after stunt kills Edmonton woman
- A man claiming to be the driver of a Jeep that struck and killed a spectator at a charity event in Edmonton says he is sorry for what happened. more »
- Pigeon Lake businesses look forward to full season of camping
- Business owners in Pigeon Lake are looking forward to this year's season after most of the provincial campground closed early last year for renovations more »
- Six campers rescued after getting lost in Kananaskis Country
- A group of six campers was rescued Sunday morning after becoming lost when they wandered away from their campsite near Gorge Creek Trail. more »
Must Watch
Top News Headlines
- Unknown remains found on Dellen Millard's farm
- Police searching the farm of Dellen Millard, the 27-year-old charged with first-degree murder after the remains of Ancaster, Ont., man Tim Bosma were discovered, have found other remains on the property, but it's unclear if they are human or animal. more »
- Canadian on EI shut out amid foreign worker influx
- A jobless Canadian IT professional who is collecting employment insurance is upset because he now suspects several recent jobs he applied for went to temporary foreign workers. more »
- Can the Senate fire a senator?
- An expert on parliamentary rules says the Senate has the power to turf a senator from the chamber, as long as a majority approves the expulsion, and as long as there is cause. more »
- Nahlah Ayed: Vote-wary Iranians mull Ahmadinejad's successor
- Iranians go to the polls in less than four weeks to choose a new president. The reform movement is still smarting from its bitter defeat four years ago, but the jockeying for power is no less intense, Nahlah Ayed reports. more »
- Edmonton boy, 2, killed after car hits patio
- A two-year-old boy is dead after a car smashed into a patio at a south Edmonton restaurant Sunday night. more »
- Jeep driver apologizes after stunt kills Edmonton woman
- Man charged in stabbings near Kingsway transit station
- 1 dead, 6 injured in Edson crash
- Spectator killed at Edmonton Jeep event
- Abducted woman found
- Six campers rescued after getting lost in Kananaskis Country
- Pigeon Lake businesses look forward to full season of camping
- Seniors targeted by Edmonton jewellery thieves
- Loft residents start petition against proposed strip club

