Starved Alberta tot's parents appeal life-support ruling
CBC News
Posted: Sep 14, 2012 7:38 AM MT
Last Updated: Sep 14, 2012 8:29 PM MT
Related
External Links
(Note:CBC does not endorse and is not responsible for the content of external links.)
An Alberta Court of Appeal judge has allowed the parents of a two-year-old girl — allegedly starved and neglected from birth — to appeal a ruling the child be removed from life support machines.
The girl, who can't be identified, will be kept on life support until the appeal is heard, which could be as soon as next Wednesday or Thursday.
"It is a difficult situation and there is no ideal solution to it," said Justice Jean Cote.
Cote told the lawyers in the case to clear off their calendars to accommodate the hearing.
"If there's something else, you can tell them it is a life and death matter," he said.
Just hours earlier, Court of Queen's Bench Justice June Ross ruled the child be removed from life support.
The ruling was brief as the parents asked the reasons not be read out, but rather given to them later in private.
Parents hang heads
As the judge read her conclusion, both parents, sitting about three metres apart, hung their heads.
Neither the father nor the mother made eye contact with each other.
In her 15-page decision, Ross sifted through two days of testimony from the child's doctors and legal precedents.
"In considering this submission, I keep in mind that my role is to consider only the best interests of [the child], not those of her parents or any other person," she wrote.
"[The parents'] position as stated indicates that their decision will not and cannot change: they state that as devout Muslims and loving parents, they find it 'unthinkable to agree to limit or withdraw medical treatment' and they ask that the court honour [their] beliefs," Ross wrote.
"The court cannot do so where their beliefs come into a fundamental conflict with [the child's] best interests."
Ross said it is society's general understanding, "a life without awareness and totally supported by machines is not in accord with the best interests of any patient."
Child's interest to stop treatment
She went on to write that in that context "it is in [the child's] best interests that life-sustaining treatment be stopped is clear and uncontradicted."
The girl was taken to hospital on May 25, after paramedics found her in her parents' home in cardiac arrest and in a state of starvation.
The girl suffered a profound and irreversible brain injury and remains deeply comatose relying on a ventilator and feeding tube to survive.
Doctors don't believe the girl's condition will ever improve.
Two other children were also removed from the home, the girl's twin sister — also found starving, but now recovering — and an older boy, who was unharmed and now in foster care.
A lawyer for Alberta Children and Youth Services, which did not take a stance on whether the girl should be kept alive, asked Ross to make a ruling.
The agency said the choice should not be left up to the girl's parents, who are in custody on charges of aggravated assault, criminal negligence causing bodily harm and failing to provide the necessities of life.
The parents are barred from communicating with one another.
The parents are scheduled to have a bail hearing on Sept. 21.
Share Tools
Latest Edmonton News Headlines
- Oklahoma tornado brings back memories of Black Friday
- Following the devastating tornado that swept through Oklahoma on Monday, many Albertans are thinking back to July 31, 1987. more »
- Woman diagnosed with ALS helps fundraise for a cure
- Distance hasn't been the only difficulty Susann and Hajime Sakaguchi have had to overcome in the course of their love story. more »
- Children driven around too much, Canadian report suggests
- Fewer Canadian kids are commuting by walking or biking as a new report reveals a marked decline among young people using active modes of transportation. more »
- Dozens tricked by fools gold scam
- A scam of fools gold appears to be afoot in Edmonton. more »
Must Watch
Top News Headlines
- Video forensics: How easy would it be to fake a Rob Ford video?
- Two media outlets reported last week that they had seen a cellphone video of Mayor Rob Ford allegedly smoking crack, a claim that has gone global. If a video does surface, how easy would it be to determine its authenticity? CBC News asked video forensic analyst David McKay. more »
- Oklahoma residents begin to return home after deadly tornado
- Rescue workers raced to complete the search for survivors and the dead in the Oklahoma City suburb where a mammoth tornado destroyed countless homes, cleared lots down to bare red earth and claimed 24 lives, including those of nine children. more »
- Xbox One: A closer look
- The design, performance, Kinect camera, controller, requirements and limitations of Microsoft's Xbox One get a critical look. more »
- Over 1 million Montrealers face boil water advisory
- A boil water advisory is in effect for at least 24 hours across much of Montreal. more »
- Driver too drunk to stand, says mom of toddler killed on patio
- Dozens tricked by fools gold scam
- Edmonton driver, 62, charged in boy's patio death
- Oklahoma tornado brings back memories of Black Friday
- Wildfires in Strathcona County and Spruce Grove
- Edmonton's Mayor Stephen Mandel bows out
- Children driven around too much, Canadian report suggests
- Fire ban announced for Edmonton
- Woman diagnosed with ALS helps fundraise for a cure

