Alberta health-care cuts unacceptable: poll
Last Updated: Tuesday, October 6, 2009 | 2:28 PM MT
CBC News
In depth: Alberta health-care cuts
CBC health-care poll
- Main page
- A poll commissioned by CBC in September 2009 asked 804 Albertans for their views on health care
- Health minister accepts failing grade
- Oct. 9, 2009
- CHAT: Replay of a healthcare conversation with Bruce Cameron, Keith Brownsey and Erin Collins
- Oct. 9, 2009
- Bring back health-care premiums, Albertans say
- Oct. 8, 2009
- Albertans divided on private-public health care: CBC poll
- Oct. 7, 2009
- Alberta health-care cuts unacceptable, poll suggests
- October 6, 2009
- Health care No. 1 issue for Albertans: CBC poll
- October 5, 2009
Feature
- Stressed Out: A health-care checkup
- CBC Edmonton looks at the stress of living in Alberta's boom-bust economy, its toll on Albertans and their health-care system
Audio
- Interview: CBC Radio's Ron Wilson speaks Health Minister Ron Liepert
- Oct. 9, 2009
- Ann Sullivan reports: Privatization of long-term care (Runs 5:54)
- Oct. 9, 2009
- Erin Collins reports: Shortage of doctors in Alberta (Runs 5:35)
- Oct. 8, 2009
- Erin Collins reports: Private vs. public health care (Runs 6:28)
- Oct. 7, 2009
- Ann Sullivan reports: One family's fears about bed closures at Alberta Hospital (Runs 5:45)
- Oct. 6, 2009
Stories
- Health minister accepts failing grade
- Oct. 9, 2009
- Alberta hires cheaper nurses to tackle shortage
- Oct. 7, 2009
- Thousands of long-term care beds to close, Alberta NDP charges
- Sept. 22, 2009
- Alberta Hospital closure worries police commission
- Sept. 18, 2009
- Hundreds of Alberta hospital beds to close
- Sept. 16, 2009
- 350 acute-care beds closing, union leader says
- Sept. 15, 2009
- Alberta health-care cuts to include voluntary retirements
- Aug. 26, 2009
- Alberta nurses grieve code of conduct
- July 13, 2009
- Alberta Health faces $1.1B budget shortfall
- June 30, 2009
- Friends of Medicare launch campaign against Alberta health cuts
- June 11, 2009
- Overworked nurses accuse Alberta Health Services of hiring freeze
- June 5, 2009
Cuts to the health-care system are unacceptable to most Albertans, a new poll commissioned by the CBC suggests.
Of 804 people from across Alberta contacted by telephone in the poll done by NRG Research Group, 61 per cent said it was unacceptable to make cuts to the health-care system.
As well, 70 per cent of respondents aren't confident the government can make cuts and retain quality in the system, Bruce Cameron of NRG Research Group said Tuesday.
Alberta Health Services announced in August it will close 250 beds at Alberta Hospital Edmonton. (CBC) Alberta Health Services announced in August that it will close 250 beds at Alberta Hospital Edmonton, the province's largest psychiatric hospital, and move patients to beds in community facilities.
Doreen Roberts of St Albert, northwest of Edmonton, is campaigning to keep those beds open. Roberts has a grown son with schizophrenia who has his own apartment and owns a seasonal business.
"During those times when there's no income, he makes choices like, okay, what can I afford and what can I not afford, and unfortunately he'll choose the medicine, because it is so expensive," Roberts said.
The medicine costs about $600 a month. Without the medicine, Roberts said her son crashes and ends up in hospital.
"A couple of the hospitals that we've been involved with … you're treated like a weirdo, you're not much more than a criminal."—Doreen Roberts, mother of a man with schizophrenia
She's among the Albertans who doesn't believe the government can make cuts to health care and retain quality.
"In the Alberta hospital, you get your treatment, you get your coaching, you get your counselling, you have recovery time and you're prepared to go back home," she said. "At a regular hospital … you go in, you're there to get well and to get out."
"A couple of the hospitals that we've been involved with … you're treated like a weirdo, you're not much more than a criminal," Roberts added.
Mistakes made in the 1990s
Dr. Alberto Choy, president of the medical staff association at Alberta Hospital Edmonton, doesn't want to revisit the mistakes made in the 1990s.
"There were massive bed closures, a promise to move resources to take care of people in the community where arguably they will do better … but that didn't materialize," Choy said.
Having mentally ill patients in the community without proper supports leads to all kinds of problems, including homelessness and crime, he said.
Patients will not simply be pushed out of Alberta Hospital, according to Stephen Duckett president and CEO of Alberta Health Services.
Stephen Duckett, president and CEO of Alberta Health Services, talks to reporters on Sept. 16. (CBC) "There'll be no patients moved from Alberta Hospital Edmonton until there's somewhere for them to go, that's a commitment I've made, it's a rock solid commitment," Duckett said.
"We can assure the patients there, we can assure their families that the life they will have after this will be better than the life they've got now," he said.
Still, Doreen Roberts isn't convinced, and she's worried about what will happen when Alberta Hospital stops taking patients like her son.
"Since my son became ill with this, all I've wanted is for him to stay alive and be safe and that he wants to stay alive," Roberts said. "So that is my biggest fear, that his own hope will diminish and that he'll give up."
Results from the poll, conducted in mid-September, are being released as part of series of stories on health care being done by the CBC. The poll is considered accurate within 3.5 percentage points, 95 per cent of the time.
Share Tools
Latest Edmonton News Headlines
- Police chief apologizes to former employee over racism
- Edmonton's chief of police has apologized to one of the department's former employees who says the racist behaviour of her boss and colleagues forced her to leave her job. more »
- Edmonton trustees named marshals of gay pride parade

- Trustees from the Edmonton Public School Board will be the honorary marshals at this year's gay pride parade. more »
- ATV collision kills teen near Hinton
- An 18-year-old male died Thursday after he was thrown from his all-terrain vehicle near Hinton. more »
- Alberta readies 60 new ambulances for service
- Around 60 new ambulances will soon be whizzing across the province thanks to a large purchase by Alberta Health Services. more »
Top News Headlines
- Dozens of children die in Syria massacre, activists say
- More than 90 people have been killed by regime forces in a district of central Syria, activists say, and as many as half the victims may have been children. more »
- Aylmer triple stabbing leads to first-degree murder charges

- The estranged partner of a young mother who was stabbed to death along with her parents at their home in Aylmer, Que., has been charged with first-degree murder Friday. more »
- Severe storm in Quebec leaves damage in its wake
- Trees were uprooted, roofs damaged and windows shattered as severe thunderstorms, and possibly a tornado, rattled through southwestern Quebec Friday night. more »
- The risks and responsibilities of taking on Mt. Everest

- The deaths of five climbers last weekend on Mt. Everest, with more summits underway this weekend, fuels the debate about the risks and responsibilities of high altitude climbing. more »
- Former MLA questions need for Alberta Party
- Police chief apologizes to former employee over racism
- ATV collision kills teen near Hinton
- Edmonton trustees named marshals of gay pride parade
- Oil spill clean-up underway in northern Alberta
- Alberta readies 60 new ambulances for service
- Edmonton toddler killed by SUV in parking lot
- Hobbema youth dispel stereotypes with photography
- Garlic mustard spreading in Mill Creek Ravine

