Edmonton lawyer challenges Alberta jury system
Last Updated: Monday, September 13, 2010 | 2:20 PM MT
CBC News
Edmonton lawyer Tom Engel argued in the Court of Queen's Bench Monday that jury trials in the city consistently violate the rights of aboriginal people by leaving reserves out of the pool of possible jurors. (CBC)An Edmonton lawyer is challenging Alberta's jury selection process, saying it consistently violates the rights of aboriginal people by leaving reserves out of the pool of possible jurors.
Tom Engel who argued his case in the Court of Queen's Bench Monday also says provincial legislation that keeps people charged or convicted of criminal offences from serving on a jury adds to the problem.
Federal law prohibits those who have served long jail sentences from jury duty. Alberta's Jury Act goes further, barring from juries anyone currently charged with a Criminal Code offence.
"When you consider that aboriginals and people from the lower socio-economic groups are far more likely to have a criminal record, or be charged with a criminal offence, it has the effect of excluding a significant segment of our society," Engel said.
"We think these people should be here and have an opportunity to be picked to serve on a jury."
Stemmed from 2008
His case stems from October 2008, when Engel was attending the jury selection for his aboriginal client Rene McCarthy when he noticed none of the prospective jurors were aboriginal.
Rene McCarthy is charged with various offences against a police officer who was trying to arrest him.
(CBC)McCarthy is charged with various offences against a police officer who was trying to arrest him
The case was adjourned so Engel could find out why no aboriginal jurors were present.
During his investigation Engel said he learned that only people living within a 20 kilometre radius of Edmonton's law courts are ever called to jury duty.
Despite the fact the Enoch Reserve falls within that boundary, Engel says no one from the reserve is ever summoned for jury duty.
Engel argues jury trials routinely violate the rights of aboriginal people by leaving reserves out of the pool of possible jurors.
McCarthy told reporters Monday that he would like to see more aboriginals as jury members.
"I want proper representation by my people," McCarthy said.
The case will begin hearing witnesses Tuesday.
Corrections and Clarifications
- An earlier version incorrectly stated that the Alberta Jury Act bars anyone ever charged with a criminal offence from serving on a jury. In fact, the act bars those who are currently charged with an offence under the Criminal Code. Sept. 24, 2010 | 12:50 p.m. MT
Share Tools
Latest Calgary News Headlines
- Alberta radar running again after breakdown
- Predicting severe weather patterns is still presenting a challenge for local weather watchers after four Environment Canada Doppler radars stopped working properly this week. more »
- Inquiry rules on death of troubled Alberta teen
- A fatality inquiry into the death of a mentally troubled Alberta teenager is recommending hospitals tighten rules on all outings for psychiatric patients. more »
- Alberta readies 60 new ambulances for service
- Around 60 new ambulances will soon be whizzing across the province thanks to a large purchase by Alberta Health Services. more »
- Suspicious death in S.E. investigated
- A man was found dead in southeast Calgary early Friday morning in what police are calling suspicious circumstances. more »
Top News Headlines
- Attack on Syrian villages deadliest yet, activists say
- More than 90 people have been killed by regime forces in a district of central Syria, activists say, and as many as half the victims may have been children. more »
- Aylmer triple stabbing leads to first-degree murder charges

- The estranged partner of a young mother who was stabbed to death along with her parents at their home in Aylmer, Que., has been charged with first-degree murder Friday. more »
- Tornado touchdown confirmed near Montreal
- Trees were uprooted, roofs damaged and windows shattered as severe thunderstorms, and possibly a tornado, rattled through southwestern Quebec Friday night. more »
- The risks and responsibilities of taking on Mt. Everest

- The deaths of five climbers last weekend on Mt. Everest, with more summits underway this weekend, fuels the debate about the risks and responsibilities of high altitude climbing. more »
- Former MLA questions need for Alberta Party
- Inquiry rules on death of troubled Alberta teen
- Alberta radar running again after breakdown
- Police couldn’t stop double fatal crash, judge says
- Alberta readies 60 new ambulances for service
- Suspicious death in S.E. investigated
- TEDxYYC brings passionate speakers to Calgary today
- Calgary woman who killed mother gets 5 years
- Beltline attack leaves man critically injured

