Concrete truck driver guilty of killing 5 people in Calgary crash
Judge says driver showed reckless disregard for the lives or safety of others
Last Updated: Thursday, May 7, 2009 | 7:06 PM MT
CBC News
IN DEPTH: Daniel Tschetter trial
- Grieving parents face 'life sentence' of pain after crash
- Aug. 5, 2009
- Concrete truck driver guilty of killing 5 people in Calgary crash
- May 7, 2009
- Judge to decide truck driver's fate in May
- March 17, 2009
- Mistakenly drank vodka after deadly Calgary crash, driver testifies
- March 16, 2009
- Defence prepares strategy in trucker's manslaughter trial
- March 13, 2009
- Calgary trucker never drank on the job, court told
- March 11, 2009
- Witness testifies she smelled alcohol on truck driver's breath
- March 10, 2009
- Erratic driving, speeding before deadly Calgary crash, court hears
- March 9, 2009
Daniel Tschetter, right, leaves the Calgary courthouse on Thursday after being convicted of manslaughter in a deadly December 2007 crash. (CBC) A Calgary-area truck driver has been found guilty of manslaughter in the deaths of two adults and three children in a rear-end collision.
Daniel Tschetter, 51, was convicted Thursday afternoon of five counts of manslaughter and one count of obstruction of justice in the deadly December 2007 crash. Provincial court Judge Bruce Fraser stayed the five counts of criminal negligence, because that charge is similar to manslaughter.
During the trial, provincial court heard that Tschetter was speeding in his concrete-mixer truck, passing on the shoulder of Highway 2 and driving erratically before the crash.
Witnesses testified that they saw no brake lights when the truck plowed into the back of a car waiting at a red light at the intersection of 194th Avenue and Macleod Trail S.E., dragging it about 275 metres. The car ended up lodged under the bigger vehicle.
Kiarra Gautreau, 6, and Alexia Gautreau, 9, above, and Zachary Morrison, 16 months, below, died in the crash in December 2007. (CBC) The occupants of the car — Chris Gautreau, 41; his daughters, Alexia, 9, and Kiarra, 6; Gautreau's fiancée, Melaina Hovdebo, 33; and her son, Zachary Morrison, 16 months — were killed.
Lee Morrison, Zachary's father, was crying and shaking as the judge described the details of the collision. Fraser said the accused knew he was approaching city limits and an intersection he had driven through "over 100 times," and yet continued to drive the same aggresive and dangerous manner, demonstrating a "wanton and/or reckless disregard for the lives or safety of others."
The judge said he accepted evidence Tschetter could have been driving as fast as 120 km/h at the time of the crash in "no ordinary automobile."
"It is a cement truck. It is 10 times the size and strength and weight of the average vehicle on the road. Most other vehicles are at its mercy if it runs them down," Fraser said in his decision.
Tschetter showed little emotion during the judge's decision, except for occasionally rubbing his eyes. His daughter sobbed in the courtroom when the manslaughter conviction was read out. There is no minimum sentence for manslaughter under the Criminal Code; sentences can range from probation to life in prison.
Driver testified he was distracted
Tschetter, who testified during the trial that he was a recovering alcoholic, said he was in a rush to wash out his truck after a cement delivery. He told the court he was distracted by checking on the vehicle's gauges and was frustrated because his water lines were freezing.
'People often say will it give you closure? No.'—Lee Morrison, victim's father
After the collision, Tschetter said he reached under his seat and took a drink of what he thought was water from a bottle, before realizing it was vodka.
He testified that he threw the bottle of vodka into the drum of his cement truck, because he didn't know what to do if people saw him with the container. Tschetter explained the vodka bottle was in the truck so he could offer drinks to staff at concrete suppliers to get to the front of long lineups."
Fraser said he did not accept Tschetter's explanation that he didn't know what bottle he was drinking from, but the judge was satisfied Tschetter's ability to operate a vehicle was not impaired by alcohol.
Instead, the judge pointed out Tschetter's state of mind "which appears to have affected his driving," and his conduct on the road that increased the risk of bodily harm or death.
Long sentencing hearing expected
Crown prosecutor Jonathan Hak said Thursday he expects the sentencing hearing, set for Aug. 5, to be lengthy, as many family members of the victims will want to give impact statements.
"People often say will it give you closure? No," Morrison told CBC News on Wednesday before the verdict. "I'm hoping that beautiful little face will somehow register with people that we lost our kids over a needless, senseless situation."
Herb Grieder, Zachary's uncle, quit his job to be at the courthouse for every proceeding before and during the judge-only trial.
"Emotionally and physically draining … but it was something I felt I had to do," he said.
Tschetter is free until his sentencing. Defence lawyer Balfour Der told the judge he intends on applying for a conditional sentence.
With files from Tara Fedun and Elizabeth SnaddonShare Tools
Latest Calgary News Headlines
- Alberta radar running again after breakdown
- Predicting severe weather patterns is still presenting a challenge for local weather watchers after four Environment Canada Doppler radars stopped working properly this week. more »
- Inquiry rules on death of troubled Alberta teen
- A fatality inquiry into the death of a mentally troubled Alberta teenager is recommending hospitals tighten rules on all outings for psychiatric patients. more »
- Alberta readies 60 new ambulances for service
- Around 60 new ambulances will soon be whizzing across the province thanks to a large purchase by Alberta Health Services. more »
- Suspicious death in S.E. investigated
- A man was found dead in southeast Calgary early Friday morning in what police are calling suspicious circumstances. more »
Top News Headlines
- Aylmer triple stabbing leads to first-degree murder charges

- The estranged partner of a young mother who was stabbed to death along with her parents at their home in Aylmer, Que., has been charged with first-degree murder Friday. more »
- Severe storm in Quebec leaves damage in its wake
- Trees were uprooted, roofs damaged and windows shattered as severe thunderstorms, and possibly a tornado, rattled through southwestern Quebec Friday night. more »
- The risks and responsibilities of taking on Mt. Everest

- The deaths of five climbers last weekend on Mt. Everest, with more summits underway this weekend, fuels the debate about the risks and responsibilities of high altitude climbing. more »
- Ex-Mubarak PM vows not to recreate old regime
- The last prime minister of ousted Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak is denying claims that he's trying to recreate the old regime. more »
- Former MLA questions need for Alberta Party
- Inquiry rules on death of troubled Alberta teen
- Alberta radar running again after breakdown
- Police couldn’t stop double fatal crash, judge says
- Alberta readies 60 new ambulances for service
- Suspicious death in S.E. investigated
- TEDxYYC brings passionate speakers to Calgary today
- Calgary woman who killed mother gets 5 years
- Beltline attack leaves man critically injured

