Tim Stevenson's Sochi trip funding may be conflict of interest

If private donations pay for Vancouver city councillor Tim Stevenson's trip to Sochi to lobby the IOC for LGBT rights, the city is in a conflict of interest, say critics.

Large donation to Stevenson mission from developer Bob Rennie may be a conflict of interest

Who should pay for Coun. Tim Stevenson's Olympic trip? 2:05

The City of Vancouver is taking on homophobia  — and the International Olympic Committee — by voting to send an openly gay deputy mayor to the winter games in Sochi.

However, concern over who would pay for Vancouver City Councillor Tim Stevenson's trip to Russia next February may be detracting from the human rights message.

If council passes the motion next week, Stevenson will replace Vancouver Mayor Gregor Robertson as the city's ambassador.

The motion includes a mandate for Stevenson to lobby the IOC to include gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender rights in the Olympic charter and ensure host cities have a pride house.

"As a former Olympic host city, it's important to speak up for gay rights, particular[ly] when Russia is trampling those rights with recent legislation," said Stevenson.

Under Russia's anti-gay legislation, support and so-called propaganda of non-traditional relationships is illegal.

"It's important for the athletes to have a safe house, a safe place to go when they are part of the Olympics," Stevenson said.

Openly gay city councillor Tim Stevenson will represent Vancouver at the Winter Olympics in Sochi (CBC News)

Funding for the trip is expected to come from private donations, including $50,000 that has already been donated by condo marketer Bob Rennie and hotelier Peter Wall, two major players in Vancouver.

Critics have raised concerns the donations could influence future development decisions at city hall, but Mayor Robertson disagrees.

"The key thing [is] if people are willing to put money forward for initiatives, that's fantastic," said Robertson. "If it takes the burden away from taxpayers then that's good for all of us."

But Maxwell Cameron, director of the University of British Columbia's Centre for the Study of Democratic Institutions, disagrees.

"If Rennie and Wall want someone to represent the case for LGBT rights, perhaps they should find someone who is not in a conflict of interest," said Cameron.

NPA Councillor George Affleck also thinks taxpayers should pay for Stevenson's human rights mission and says he plans to introduce an amendment to the motion next week.

"I think this is an issue that the City of Vancouver and the people of Vancouver would absolutely support and fund," he said.

'If Rennie and Wall want someone to represent the case for LGBT rights, perhaps they should find someone who is not in a conflict of interest' - Cameron Maxwell, Centre for the Study of Democratic Institutions

Canadian Taxpayers Federation director for British Columbia Jordan Bateman said it's a good cause, but a bad plan.

"When you pay your property taxes in the city of Vancouver, you are not expected to send councillors all around the world on issues like this. You're talking about things like sewer, water, garbage pickup: the nuts and bolts that are important to Vancouver," he said.

No kickbacks for developers

Investor and hotelier Peter Wall, who is no longer tied to his namesake company Wall Financial, has contributed $25,000.

Wall told the CBC he wrote a cheque for Stevenson and gave it to Rennie because the Russian regime imprisoned his father when the Wall family lived in Ukraine.

"People have the right to live [the] way they want as long as they don't harm anyone," Wall said.

However, Wall said, from experience, donations to the city don't mean any influence or breaks for investors on influencing policy decisions.

Wall said he has given millions of dollars to the Orpheum, for extra density for Capital Residences, and millions more for the York Theatre in East Vancouver, but he still wasn't permitted by the city to install dark windows at one of his developments, One Wall Centre, when he first built it.


  • Statements in an earlier version of this story were incorrectly attributed to Jordan Bateman.
    Dec 13, 2013 12:43 PM PT

with files from the CBC's Kirk Williams


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.