B.C. judge shocked at handling of corpse by RCMP
The Canadian Press
Posted: Sep 21, 2012 8:17 PM PT
Last Updated: Sep 21, 2012 8:15 PM PT
The Crown should consider if charges are warranted against the RCMP in Prince George, B.C., after investigators left a dead body overnight at the scene of a killing, a B.C. Supreme Court justice says
"I am quite frankly shocked and astounded," Justice Glen Parrett said, adding he had seen "no evidence whatsoever of a single forensic step being taken the next day with the exception of videotaping the scene."The judge said there was no evident reason for leaving the body at the scene overnight. (RCMP)
Parrett made his comments during closing arguments at the manslaughter trial of Patrick Mathewsie.
The man is accused of the killing of Sylvain Victor Roy, whose body was found in an empty, overgrown lot in central Prince George on July 29, 2010.
"I perfectly understand there are times and some situations where there is forensic necessity for doing things in a particular way," Parrett said.
"I've seen some pretty complex investigations that actually went on for days.
"I [don't see the] faintest evidence that happened here."
Parrett has suggested Crown counsel look at sections of the Criminal Code related to indignities to a human body.
He also added he will assist Crown in raising concerns about why the body was left out overnight in the mid-summer heat when police had more than three hours of daylight to deal with it when they first responded to the call.
"What was the question that required him to be left out overnight in July 29 temperatures?" Parrett said.
The judge also said he had viewed the police videotape recorded in the first hours of the investigation and called the scene depicted on the tape "a disgrace."
Testimony contradicted police
Roy had been found with a rope around his neck and Mathewsie passed out beside him with blood on his hands and forearms and one arm resting on a T-shirt covering Roy's face, court was told.
The Crown alleges Mathewsie strangled the victim, then wandered around the site before returning.
However, witnesses testified the man seen wandering had different clothing and did not have the same colour hair as Mathewsie, who was described as a friend of Roy.
Court was told the two men shared a tent while camping in the lot and collected pop bottles together.
There was also testimony that a larger, younger man, who had been acting aggressively, had been seen in the area over the days previous to Roy's death.
Defence lawyer Rob Climie questioned forensic evidence, saying no DNA evidence from Mathewsie was found on the rope or on Roy's knuckles or fingernails.
Parrett also criticized evidence given by an RCMP officer who testified Mathewsie was pretending to be asleep when he was found next to the body.
The judge noted the testimony contradicted details from other officers and ambulance personnel, and ignored the blood alcohol levels of both men, which were in the nearly lethal .350 range.
"The [officer's] evidence is patently wrong in my view and I have looked at that evidence very carefully," Parrett said.
Parrett is scheduled to deliver a verdict on Tuesday morning.
Latest British Columbia News Headlines
- 750 homes sliding away in Quesnel, B.C.
- Officials in Quesnel, B.C., are trying to save 750 homes and an elementary school from shifting, as an ancient landslide causes land in the area to gradually slip every year. more »
- Mounties hunt for sex assault suspect in Port Alberni
- Mounties in Port Alberni, on Vancouver Island, are looking for a suspect after a 16-year-old girl reported being sexually assaulted. more »
- B.C. teen saves pet dog in 'terrifying' cougar attack
- A teenager who says he heard a horrible "scream" from his beloved black labrador outside the family home in Belcarra, B.C., looked out his window and then went into action to save the dog from a vicious cougar. more »
- Canucks fire coach Alain Vigneault
- The Vancouver Canucks fired head coach Alain Vigneault on Wednesday, less than two years after he guided the club to the seventh game of the Stanley Cup final. more »
Top News Headlines
- Mike Duffy's primary home not P.E.I., unedited Senate report says
- A copy of the original report by an internal Senate committee on Senator Mike Duffy's expense claims, obtained by CBC News, makes it clear the committee believes Duffy's primary residence is in Ottawa, and not in P.E.I. more »
- Neil Macdonald: Harper no Obama when it comes to dealing with scandals
- Beset by three so-called scandals at the moment, Barack Obama has been meeting his accusers and the press head on, Neil Macdonald writes. The same cannot be said for how Stephen Harper operates. more »
- Needed: New approaches to defuse 'suicide contagion' among teens
- Mental health experts say we need to find new ways to refer to and discuss suicide, particularly now that a large medical study has confirmed that teens are more susceptible to the idea if they know a schoolmate who died that way. more »
- 2nd suspect in Tim Bosma case now in court for murder charge
- A second man arrested in the death of Tim Bosma, a Hamilton husband and father who disappeared after taking two men on a test drive of his pickup truck, has arrived in court to face a charge of first-degree murder. more »
- B.C. teen's heroics save pet dog in 'terrifying' cougar attack
- Plumber's car explodes near Vancouver apartments
- Man stabbed in Vancouver
- Adrian Dix to stay on as B.C. NDP leader despite election loss
- 2 men found in Kalamalka Lake near Vernon, B.C.
- End solitary confinement, says former female inmate
- Greyhound bus caught going twice the speed limit in B.C.
- Wait time and primary care reforms stalled
- Former B.C. MLA Harold Long killed in plane crash