Government tries to block MP's questions at pipeline review
Nathan Cullen wants answers from federal officials at Northern Gateway hearings
By Max Paris, Environment Unit, CBC News
Posted: Aug 29, 2012 12:40 PM PT
Last Updated: Aug 30, 2012 7:26 AM PT
NDP MP Nathan Cullen speaks to reporters at the site of the proposed Enbridge bitumen terminal on Douglas Channel, south of Kitimat, B.C., during the NDP's tour of resource development sites in northwestern B.C. in June. (Robin Rowland/Canadian Press)The NDP's House leader claims the government is trying to shut him up when it comes to questioning federal bureaucrats at the joint review panel looking into Enbridge's Northern Gateway pipeline proposal.
Nathan Cullen's request to cross-examine officials from the departments of the environment, natural resources, transport and fisheries and oceans was met by a letter from the Department of Justice asking the panel to deny his appeal.
"It's a bit of an intimidation tactic," says Cullen. "All along, if you've been opposed or raised concerns about this pipeline, Mr. Harper's government has called you a radical or an enemy of the state. These are all tactics to say 'you're just going to have to accept what we tell you to accept.'"
Natural Resources Minister Joe Oliver, in an email to CBC News on Wednesday afternoon said, "Cullen is seeking to politicize the work of the panel instead of waiting to hear the independent experts report."
Cullen is an intervener at the review. As such, he is allowed to question government and Enbridge witnesses at the hearings.
The Department of Justice does not argue that right. In the letter to the panel, Kirk Lambrecht, the general counsel for the Prairie Region, raises concern about the subject matter of the questions Cullen wants to ask.
He said Cullen's questions don't deal with "evidence that has been submitted by other parties during the joint review process." And that contravenes the panel's hearing order, or rules of play.
Questions for 4 different departments
Cullen wants to ask Environment Canada about its new, versus old, environmental assessment criteria. The Canadian Environmental Assessment Act was completely overhauled in the spring.
His line of questioning for Transport Canada would deal with the independence of the review process and regulations on diluted bitumen (oilsands oil) compared to conventional oil.
From Natural Resources Canada he is looking for answers on overseas project promotion and carbon pricing. Finally, Fisheries and Oceans would field his questions about the Fisheries Act, habitat protection and water crossings along the pipeline.
"To allow such questions would undermine fairness to the witnesses, delay the proceedings and would not assist the panel in its assessment of the application," wrote Lambrecht.
Cullen has a different interpretation of the review's guiding principles. He thinks that any evidence that was submitted or needs to be talked about is open for discussion.
"If what the government is going to do and what the panel's going to do is say, 'If the word doesn't appear you can't ask a question about it,' it would narrow the conversation so much as to make the whole thing ridiculous," says Cullen.
Oliver said "the joint review panel independently makes all decisions respecting its proceedings. Our officials will answer any questions that the independent panel deems relevant."
The MP for Skeena-Bulkley Valley expects to do his questioning at the hearings in Prince Rupert sometime in the next few weeks. The panel doesn't have a timeframe for making a decision on the Department of Justice's letter.
Corrections and Clarifications
- This story has been edited from an earlier version that incorrectly stated that Nathan Cullen is the NDP's natural resources critic. In fact, he is the Opposition House leader. Aug. 30, 2012 | 12:59 PM ET
Share Tools
Latest British Columbia News Headlines
- Northern Gateway in Canadians' interest, Enbridge tells review board

- Canada will be vulnerable to economic disaster should the Northern Gateway pipeline be rejected, the proponent told a federal review panel Monday as the final phase of public hearings got underway. more »
- Police slashed homeless tents, say advocates in Abbotsford, B.C.
- The Abbotsford, B.C., police chief has ordered an investigation into allegations the city's officers destroyed tents belonging to homeless people, in a second controversy over how the city treats its homeless. more »
- Death of boy in B.C. cancer ride 'heartbreaking'
- Family and friends are mourning the death of Xavier Pelletier, the Grade 10 student from Pacific Christian School in Victoria who was stuck and killed while participating in B.C.'s Ride to Conquer Cancer on Sunday. more »
- H.R MacMillan Space Centre's star projector Harold to retire
- After 45 years of service with Vancouver's H.R MacMillan Space Centre, Harold, the centre's star projector is set to retire. more »
Must Watch
Top News Headlines
- Quebec premier says Montreal mayor should resign
- Quebec Premier Pauline Marois says Montreal Mayor Michael Applebaum should step down following his arrest this morning. more »
- Canadians jailed after Dominican post-wedding fight released
- Two Canadian men imprisoned in the Dominican Republic following a post-wedding brawl last month have been released and will be returning to Canada, a family member says. more »
- Northern Gateway in Canadians' interest, Enbridge tells review board

- Canada will be vulnerable to economic disaster should the Northern Gateway pipeline be rejected, the proponent told a federal review panel Monday as the final phase of public hearings got underway. more »
- MPs weigh in on Justin Trudeau charging speaking fees
- The New Brunswick charity that asked Liberal leader Justin Trudeau to return a speaking fee eight months after he appeared at a fundraiser has sparked a debate among MPs about the propriety of accepting money for what some say MPs should do for free. more »
- Parents of son 'brutally beaten' playing hockey want charges
- The class photo that made a father cry
- B.C. teen dies on 200-km bike ride for charity
- Cigarette butt deposits proposed for B.C.
- Private schools top Fraser Institute rankings
- Investigators probe fire at house of charter bus fall victim
- 5 Vancouver street festivals you don't want to miss!
- Elderly woman dies boarding Vancouver charter bus
- Killer whales spotted near Vancouver's Stanley Park

