Broken toothbrush sparks B.C. lawsuit
Woman acts as own lawyer against corporate giant Colgate-Palmolive
CBC News
Posted: Jan 3, 2012 5:45 PM PT
Last Updated: Jan 3, 2012 6:49 PM PT
A Surrey, B.C., woman is suing corporate giant Colgate-Palmolive Co., claiming one of the company’s toothbrushes broke in her mouth, causing her severe pain and ongoing medical issues.
Saliha Alnoor said the toothbrush broke in two locations while she was brushing her teeth in October 2006, slicing into her gums and injuring her so seriously that she fainted.
“It was a deep cut and as a result, it started bleeding and before I knew it, I hit the ground," said Alnoor.
Her brother, Abe Alnoor, told CBC News outside B.C. Supreme Court in Vancouver Tuesday that he came to his sister’s aid when he heard her fall.
"When I opened the door, she had passed out and she was against the wall," he said.
Saliha Alnoor said she wrote to Colgate-Palmolive about her experience with their toothbrush, adding that she had lost her appetite and developed gingivitis.
In response, the company sent her a $20 coupon, she said.
Alnoor told the company that response wasn’t acceptable and 13 months after the incident, the company offered to settle for $500.
“Basically [they] provoked us into taking legal action against them because they didn't care,” Alnoor said.
None of the allegations in Alnoor's statement of claim have been proven in court.
Engineering study
Alnoor said in her statement of claim that she hired an engineering firm to examine the broken brush and others of the same model and concluded it had a design flaw that caused the brush to break.
She has spent $6,000 on dental work as a result of the incident and has spent thousands more on lawyers, Alnoor said.
She is now representing herself in court, up against a Vancouver law firm representing Colgate-Palmolive.
"It's extremely unfair,” said her brother outside court Tuesday. “It's like David and Goliath."
In its statement of defence, Colgate-Palmolive said its product was safe to use, denies Alnoor suffered any injuries or expenses for which the company is responsible.
The company said if Alnoor was injured, it is because she didn't use the toothbrush in a reasonable or prudent manner.
The trial is scheduled for four days.
With files from the CBC's Kirk WilliamsShare Tools
Latest British Columbia News Headlines
- Canucks target Red Wings' home win streak
- The Vancouver Canucks, owners of the NHL's best road record, will try to halt the Detroit Red Wings' record home winning streak at 23 games at Joe Louis Arena on Thursday night. more »
- Fire at Vancouver restaurant goes to 3 alarms
- A three-alarm fire on Fraser Street in south Vancouver kept firefighjters busy for hours Wednesday night. more »
- Thief grabs $500K in jewelry in Vancouver
- Vancouver police have revealed that jewelry worth about $500,000 was stolen from a parked car in the city last week. more »
- B.C. casinos rapped for not checking patrons' backgrounds
- CBC News has uncovered new information indicating some B.C. casinos failed to adequately check the backgrounds of patrons dealing in large volumes of cash — opening the way for gangsters to launder money. more »
Top News Headlines
- Target dangles designer Jason Wu to lure Canadians
- Target Corporation's move into Canada, premiering with cheap fashions by hot designer Jason Wu, needs to promise and consistently deliver quality fashions at retail prices similar to U.S. rates, analysts say. more »
- Santorum, Romney spar in Republican debate
- Mitt Romney and Rick Santorum swapped accusations about spending and taxes Wednesday night in the 20th and possibly final debate of the roller-coaster race for the Republican presidential nomination. more »
- Qur'an burning riots kill 2 NATO soldiers
- Two NATO soldiers were shot and killed Thursday by a man wearing an Afghan army uniform who had joined protesters objecting to Qur'an burnings that took place at a U.S. base earlier in the week, says Reuters. more »
- Graham James apologizes to sex-abuse victims
- Graham James, the former junior hockey coach and convicted sexual abuser whose victims included ex-NHLers Theoren Fleury and Sheldon Kennedy, has told a courtroom: "For my behaviour, I am deeply sorry.… Parents expected sons to be safe; not all were." more »
- Mountie who had sex with superior fights to keep job
- Fire at Vancouver restaurant goes to 3 alarms
- Alleged B.C. rave rape victim seeks witnesses
- Thief grabs $500K in jewelry in Vancouver
- B.C. casinos rapped for not checking patrons' backgrounds
- Sewage used as fertilizer sparks B.C. blockade
- Garbage truck drivers fired for speaking out about camera
- B.C. police chief reprimanded after loaded gun found in car
- B.C. health-premium hike draws broad criticism

