B.C. may force homeless indoors in cold snaps
Last Updated: Monday, September 21, 2009 | 11:29 AM PT
CBC News
The B.C. government is considering a new law to force homeless people into emergency shelters during extremely cold weather, according to the B.C. Civil Liberties Association. (CBC)
Internal government documents show the B.C. government is drafting legislation to force homeless people into emergency shelters during extreme winter weather, according to the B.C. Civil Liberties Association.
But legislation would will not likely stand up to a Charter of Rights challenge according to BCCLA executive director David Eby, who obtained the government documents and released them to the media.
The B.C. government has not commented publicly on the notes released by Eby, nor confirmed its planning to introduce such a law.
Eby believes the legislation may be just another tool to get homeless people off the street during the 2010 Winter Olympic Games in Vancouver in February.
"The timing is perfect for the Olympic Games," Eby said Monday. "You want to talk about how extreme weather will be defined? Well, typically its defined as three to five days of rain in a row. Well, that's February in Vancouver.
"It will be a great way to get the homeless — force the homeless — off the streets, and get them out of the view of visitors for the Olympic games."
Assistance to Shelter Act proposed
According to the undated and unsigned documents, the Assistance to Shelter Act could be introduced during this fall's legislative session. The proposal comes after a homeless woman burned to death during last winter's cold snap while trying to keep warm with a candle in her shopping cart shelter.
A homeless woman, 47, burned to death while sleeping in a makeshift shelter last December. (CBC)Under the terms outlined in the documents, once an extreme-weather alert is triggered by officials, outreach workers would distribute written notices to homeless people telling them where to find emergency shelters during the cold snap.
The homeless people would also be warned that they could be forced by authorities to go to a shelter if they don't go voluntarily. If the person refuses, a police officer could obtain an administrative order to transport the person to an emergency shelter.
But what would happen if no shelter is available for a person refusing help remains unclear.
"The individual may be taken to police cells, either voluntarily or involuntary, where they will be held until the extreme weather declaration is no longer in effect," reads one of the notes released by Eby. But a second note reads that "putting them in a cell against their will would violate their charter rights …"
Charter challenge likely
Eby said he agrees with the second note — the government can't force homeless people to sleep indoors.
"The idea the police can turn our homeless shelters into jails, shelter workers into jail guards, and force people to stay there for indeterminate lengths of time, either day or night at their complete discretion simply won't survive a court challenge at all," Eby told CBC News. "We don't understand any way this could stand up in court, if someone brought a charter challenge."
Vancouver Coun. Kerry Jang says while the government has noble intentions, the legislation is problematic.
"Being homeless is not a crime, as far as the last time I checked the criminal code," Jang said. "Forcing folks — you know there are some real practical implications to this approach.
However, he added, the city's heart "is in the right place."
Eby said he feared the law could have the opposite effect of its intentions.
"As soon as the word gets out on the street that this is happening, people are going to hide away in areas where police aren't going to find them, out of view of everybody. And they are going to die there, because the outreach workers aren't going to be able to find them. No one will be able to find them until they freeze to death," Eby said.
Share Tools
Latest British Columbia News Headlines
- One dead as floatplane overturns in Bute Inlet
- At least one person is dead after a plane came down in Bute Inlet on the South Coast of B.C., the Joint Rescue Coordination Centre in Victoria says. more »
- Kamloops man skydives for 90th birthday
- A Kamloops man has crossed another item off his bucket list by jumping out of a plane to mark his 90th birthday. more »
- Aboriginal woman settles lawsuit over 3½ years solitary confinement
- The B.C. Civil Liberties Association says it has resolved a lawsuit against the government of Canada filed on behalf of a 26-year-old aboriginal woman from Saskatchewan who was held in solitary confinement in a federal prison for more than 3½ years. more »
- B.C. teachers win fight over political posters in schools
- British Columbia's teachers are free to express their political opinions through buttons and posters in schools after a B.C. Appeal Court panel sided with the union in a constitutional challenge. more »
Must Watch
Top News Headlines
- Search for Oklahoma tornado survivors nearly complete
- Rescue workers raced to complete the search for survivors and the dead in the Oklahoma City suburb where a mammoth tornado destroyed countless homes, cleared lots down to bare red earth and claimed 24 lives, including those of nine children.
more »
- Senate sends Duffy expense audit for 2nd internal review
- The Senate decided to send Senator Mike Duffy's audit report back to its internal committee for a second review, despite objections from the Liberal Senate leader, who argued the RCMP should be tasked with the job. more »
- Kids from levelled Oklahoma schools recount deadly tornado

- Children from two Oklahoma schools levelled Monday by a powerful tornado are recounting what it was like to survive the "loud" and "scary" twister, while rescuers near the end of their search for any other remaining survivors or bodies. more »
- Only 1 set of human remains found at Millard farm, police say
- Hamilton police have confirmed that they are dealing with only a single set of human remains at the Waterloo region farm of Dellen Millard. more »
- Rob Ford faces more calls to address crack allegations
- Toronto Mayor Rob Ford went back to work after a holiday weekend, but he wasn't talking about an alleged video that two published reports say shows him smoking what appears to be a crack pipe. more »
- Cloverdale Rodeo 'racist attack' investigated
- One dead as floatplane overturns in Bute Inlet
- Aboriginal woman settles lawsuit over 3½ years solitary confinement
- B.C. mine's temporary foreign workers case dismissed
- B.C. girl killed after 11-year-old crashes jeep
- B.C. teachers win fight over political posters in schools
- Illegal tree cutting nets charges for arborist, homeowners
- Kamloops man skydives for 90th birthday
- Motorcyclist dead after head-on crash on Lions Gate Bridge

