Justice system failed Frank Paul, left to die of hypothermia: report
Last Updated: Thursday, March 12, 2009 | 11:41 AM PT
CBC News
Related
Internal Links
External Links
(Note: CBC does not endorse and is not responsible for the content of external sites - links will open in new window)
Police video footage captured Frank Paul being dragged through the Vancouver lockup the night he died. (CBC) A public inquiry has concluded the justice system failed Frank Paul, the aboriginal man who died of hypothermia after police left him in an alley in Vancouver more than 10 years ago.
Paul, a New Brunswick Mi'kmaq, died alone in a back alley in December 1998 after he had been picked up by police for being drunk in a public place, according to the interim report released Thursday by retired judge William Davies.
After Paul's arrest, a sergeant at the city drunk tank refused to take him in, and Paul was dragged to a police wagon and then dumped in the alley, where he died of hypothermia, the report said.
That sergeant was singled out in the report, which concluded his explanations for not admitting Paul must be rejected in their entirety.
Following the release of the contents of the inquiry, condemnation of police actions have poured in.
Vancouver Police Chief Jim Chu issued a news release apologizing to Paul's family and the community.
"We deeply regret the loss of life caused by the mistakes our officers made, who had a duty of care for Mr. Paul," said Chu. "Since that tragic event, we have strengthened and modified certain policies, our procedures and training have been reinforced, and we continue to work closely with our public health partners to further safeguard the lives and well being of those in our care."
Grand Chief Ed John of the First Nations Summit of B.C. said he hopes the report will prompt a dialogue in the community.
"We need to talk to the Vancouver city mayor and council about it. We need to talk to the provincial government about it. We need to talk to our own community about it because this situation has happened far too often in our community."
B.C.'s solicitor general, however, believes Paul's death may not have been in vain.
"Well I'm hopeful that the family and First Nations people generally can take comfort from the fact that his life will be remembered as a catalyst for change, a catalyst for change not only in the need for independent oversight of police conduct, but also as catalyst for change in providing services to first nations people in particular."
Frank Paul died of hypothermia after being left by police in a Vancouver alley on a cold winter night in December 1998. (CBC) The judge concluded Paul was in need of care and could not safely be discharged to the winter streets of Vancouver.
He also concluded the Vancouver Police Department failed to carry out an adequate investigation into the death, noting the investigating officer did not locate or interview several relevant witnesses.
He also criticized the BC Coroners Service for failing to notify Paul's family of his death in a timely and accurate manner and failing to maintain adequate records.
The report notes Paul's sister was told he died in a hit-and-run accident, and she did not learn the truth of her brother's death until three years later.
Share Tools
Latest British Columbia News Headlines
- Pickton investigators defended by man who warned of killer
- A man who warned investigators about serial killer Robert Pickton is supporting testimony from the first two officers who identified Pickton as a suspect. more »
- Iginla plays shootout hero as Flames edge Canucks
- Jarome Iginla scored the shootout winner Saturday night as the Calgary Flames earned an important two points with a 3-2 win over the Vancouver Canucks. more »
- Adults-only trade show cancelled in B.C. Bible belt
- Organizers of an adults-only trade show say they're cancelling a three-day event that was scheduled to take place in British Columbia's Bible belt. more »
- Allergy alert issued for Sweets From The Earth
- People with milk allergies are being warned not to consume certain Sweets From The Earth products because they contain milk which isn't declared on the labels. more »
Top News Headlines
- Greek parliament set for crucial bailout vote
- Greek lawmakers are poised to begin debate on legislation introducing the severe austerity measures necessary for the country to secure a €130 billion bailout and stave off bankruptcy. more »
- Head of Arab League's Syria observer mission quits
- The Sudanese head of the Arab League's observer mission to Syria has resigned, as the group was to consider a proposal to revive its suspended mission, officials said. more »
- Manitoba trailer fire kills 4
- Four people are dead after an early-morning fire quickly engulfed a residential trailer in Selkirk, Man. more »
- Quebec man charged with killing mother, 2 nieces
- A 35-year-old man has been charged with three counts of first-degree murder in connection with the deaths of his mother and two young nieces in Quebec's Eastern Townships. more »
- Adults-only trade show cancelled in B.C. Bible belt
- Langley man struck, killed by train
- Crane drops section of Port Mann bridge into B.C. river
- Pickton investigators defended by man who warned of killer
- Emailed rave rape pictures earn teen probation
- RCMP request retraction over 'slanderous' article
- Cause of fatal B.C. crash may never be known
- Allergy alert issued for Sweets From The Earth
- Distraught workers from ruined B.C. mill await decision

