B.C. tribunal hears complaint against Maclean's article
Last Updated: Monday, June 2, 2008 | 7:31 PM PT
CBC News
Related
Internal Links
Video
- Terry Milewski reports for CBC-TV (Runs: 2:37)
- Play: QuickTime »
- Play: Real Media »
External Links
(Note: CBC does not endorse and is not responsible for the content of external sites - links will open in new window)
A small group of Steyn supporters wave signs and placards outside a human rights tribunal in downtown Vancouver on Monday. (CBC) A hearing into a human rights complaint alleging a Maclean's magazine article spread hatred against Muslims began in Vancouver on Monday.
Mohamed Elmasry and Naiyer Habib of the Canadian Islamic Congress complained to the Canadian, Ontario and B.C. human rights authorities after the Toronto-based magazine published the article, titled The future belongs to Islam, in October of 2006.
The article, an excerpt of a book authored by Mark Steyn, talks about Islam being a threat to North American institutions and values. It used statistics to show higher birth rates plus immigration mean Muslims will outnumber followers of other religions in Western Europe.
Habib claimed the article violated the B.C. Human Rights Code by subjecting him to discrimination based on his religion and exposing him to hatred.
Faisal Joseph, a lawyer for the complainants, claims Mark Steyn's article, The future belongs to Islam, crosses the line with respect to Section 7-1 of the B.C. Human Rights Code. (CBC) "We know under the Supreme Court of Canada [and] under tribunals of this country that there are reasonable limits [to the freedom of expression]," Faisal Joseph, Habib's lawyer, said on Monday.
"There is nothing wrong with Mr. Steyn expressing his view as long as he does not cross the line with respect to Section 7-1 of the British Columbia Act."
Section 7-1 deals with discriminatory publication. It stipulates that a person must not publish or cause to be published anything that discriminates against a person or group, or exposes them to hatred or contempt.
"We're prepared to deal with those articles piece by piece, paragraph by paragraph, and those things that we find objectionable," Joseph said.
Lawyers for Maclean's plan to argue that publication of the article is part of free speech and open debate.
"It does not meet the standard of hatred or contempt, and that's what we'll argue later in the week," said Julian Porter, one of the lawyers for Maclean's.
Tribunal hearing an 'attack of free speech'
Several Steyn supporters waved signs and placards outside the building where the hearing was held in downtown Vancouver on Monday.
They said the hearing shouldn't be happening at all.
"We're of the view in the first place that the human rights tribunal doesn't have any business deciding what appropriate expression in Canada might be," said Jason Gratl, a lawyer for the Canadian Association of Journalists and the B.C. Civil Liberties Association.
"Its activities and jurisdictions undermine the ability of journalists and members of the public to discuss important public issues such as race and religion," Gratl said.
The fact that the hearing is even taking place is an attack on free speech, said Ezra Levant, publisher of the now defunct, Alberta-based Western Standard magazine.
"I think this strikes at press freedom and even the freedom of thought of all Canadians. I think it's really an embarrassment that this is happening," Levant said.
The hearing is expected to last all week.
Share Tools
Latest British Columbia News Headlines
- Pickton investigators defended by man who warned of killer
- A man who warned investigators about serial killer Robert Pickton is supporting testimony from the first two officers who identified Pickton as a suspect. more »
- Iginla plays shootout hero as Flames edge Canucks
- Jarome Iginla scored the shootout winner Saturday night as the Calgary Flames earned an important two points with a 3-2 win over the Vancouver Canucks. more »
- Adults-only trade show cancelled in B.C. Bible belt
- Organizers of an adults-only trade show say they're cancelling a three-day event that was scheduled to take place in British Columbia's Bible belt. more »
- Allergy alert issued for Sweets From The Earth
- People with milk allergies are being warned not to consume certain Sweets From The Earth products because they contain milk which isn't declared on the labels. more »
Top News Headlines
- Greek parliament set for crucial bailout vote
- Greek lawmakers are poised to begin debate on legislation introducing the severe austerity measures necessary for the country to secure a €130 billion bailout and stave off bankruptcy. more »
- Head of Arab League's Syria observer mission quits
- The Sudanese head of the Arab League's observer mission to Syria has resigned, as the group was to consider a proposal to revive its suspended mission, officials said. more »
- Manitoba trailer fire kills 4
- Four people are dead after an early-morning fire quickly engulfed a residential trailer in Selkirk, Man. more »
- Quebec man charged with killing mother, 2 nieces
- A 35-year-old man has been charged with three counts of first-degree murder in connection with the deaths of his mother and two young nieces in Quebec's Eastern Townships. more »
- Adults-only trade show cancelled in B.C. Bible belt
- Pickton investigators defended by man who warned of killer
- Langley man struck, killed by train
- Crane drops section of Port Mann bridge into B.C. river
- Emailed rave rape pictures earn teen probation
- RCMP request retraction over 'slanderous' article
- Cause of fatal B.C. crash may never be known
- Distraught workers from ruined B.C. mill await decision
- Allergy alert issued for Sweets From The Earth

