Orphaned South African girl stuck in Canadian citizenship limbo in B.C.

A B.C. family says Canadian immigration officials are ruining their adoptive daughter's life, after their failure to resolve her visa status left her living on her own in South Africa.

Erica Dipuo Barnes, brought to Canada by adoptive family, ended up stranded in South Africa for years

Erica Dipuo Barnes ended up stranded in South Africa for years 2:46

A B.C. family says Canadian immigration officials are ruining their adoptive daughter's life, after their failure to resolve her visa status left her living on her own in South Africa.

Erica Dipuo Barnes, now 19, was born in South Africa, but was orphaned at aged seven after her father was murdered in a robbery. She was adopted by family friends, Canadian Vince Barnes and his British wife Ann.

Erica Dipuo Barnes was seven years old when her father was killed in South Africa during a robbery. (CBC)

The couple brought Barnes back to Canada to live in Surrey, B.C., and applied to have her granted permanent residency status. When she was 13, she wanted to visit her grandmother back in South Africa.

Barnes' adoptive mother Ann said she called Canada Immigration to see if her daughter could travel and was told it wouldn't be a problem.

But when Barnes' permanent residency card came through while she was away, "they said that because she wasn't in the country to collect her papers, she displayed no interest in becoming a Canadian," said Barnes' mother.

Barnes' adoptive mother Ann says she explained the situation but officials told her they would not grant her daughter residency status and there was no appeal process.

When she was 13, Erica Dipuo Barnes wanted to visit her grandmother in South Africa. CIC told the family it wouldn't be a problem. (CBC)

That meant she was barred from returning to Canada.

Barnes' adoptive father Vince says the whole family was shocked.

"It's my little girl, she's 13 years old, I mean...what is it for them to tell her she can't have a life?" he said. "They see paper, they don't see people — it ripped our family apart."

Five years in exile

Erica Dipuo Barnes says she was stuck for five hellish years in South Africa, couch surfing from family to friends, at times going hungry and on the street, instead of at home in Canada with her family.

"[When I came to Canada] I didn't feel like I was walking into a new family, it just felt natural...I just knew that wherever they were, that's where I wanted to be," she said.

"If I knew going back to South Africa would have delayed things so much...It's just one of those things we had to find out the hard way."

"I couldn't even go to school because they didn't recognize me as a South African citizen either...I was sad because [in Canada] my friends are going to school with their parents and I'm stranded."

Erica Dipuo Barnes is comforted by her adoptive father Vince after breaking down while talking about her situation to CBC News. (CBC)

Two years ago, Barnes' adoptive mother called a Canadian embassy and spoke to another official, who informed her being adopted by a Canadian actually entitled her daughter to citizenship. 

The couple applied immediately and last August, Barnes got a one-time visa and was on the next flight home back to Canada.

Barnes' parents also received a letter from the Canadian High Commission in South Africa saying their daughter has been granted Canadian citizenship.

'Why are we still waiting?'

But, Vince Barnes says, a year later, no citizenship papers have arrived.

"Why are we still waiting? Why does she sit here every day when she could be out there working?" he said.

His wife believes the problem is due to a lack of communication.

Erica Dipuo Barnes with her biological father before he was murdered in South Africa. (CBC)

"The Canadian High Commission in one country doesn't speak to another country. Her file isn't together as such — there's a file in South Africa and a file in Canada and ne'er the twain shall meet."

When CBC News asked about the case, Canadian immigration officials in Ottawa said they needed more time to respond and more time to talk to Canadian officials in South Africa.

Ann Barnes says her family will never give up and want to keep their promise to Barnes' biological father.

"We'd always promised if anything happened to him, we'd look after his children. Always, always, always."

On mobile? Click here to see the letter sent to Erica Dipuo Barnes, granting her citizenship last year, from the Canadian High Commission


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.