Neil Snelson's conviction has been set aside by the B.C. Court of Appeal because of an error made by the trial judge.
Jennifer Cusworth was found beaten and strangled after a Kelowna house party in 1993. It wasn't until 2011 that Snelson was convicted and sentenced to 15 years in prison.
At the trial, the Crown's argument hinged on statements Snelson made while he was being interrogated by RCMP investigators. The Crown argued Snelson implicated himself when he told police he had not yet decided whether or not he would plead guilty in Jennifer Cusworth's death.
The Crown urged the jury to come to the same conclusion. Lawyers argued an innocent man would have unequivocally said he was planning to plead innocent.
"Clearly the prejudicial impact of that was overwhelming," said Snelson's defence lawyer, Wade Jenson, who filed the appeal. Snelson, a father of four, pleaded innocent in the original 2011 trial.
Cusworth's childhood friend Jennifer Watson is devastated by the appeal. Only after years of the Cusworth family's persistence did the case go to trial.
"That's just one small detail, and it breaks my heart that they would pick on that one detail when there was so many other things, I felt, that were against him that caused him to be convicted," she said.
"I'm heartbroken and I can't imagine what the Cusworths are going through.
"It makes you angry. It makes you sad. It makes you have very little faith in our legal system," she said.
The Court of Appeal's unanimous decision to grant a new trial was released Wednesday.
Justice Elizabeth Bennett has ordered a new trial on the charge of manslaughter, for which no date has been set.