'Hideous' house in Vancouver's Point Grey neighbourhood compared to WW II bunker

A house on Point Grey Road is turning neighbours' heads and raising eyebrows among architects in Vancouver. The steel-cube home that sits on top of a glass box is still under construction but is already the talk of the town.

Bloggers jeer against 'ugly' box design that architect says challenges 'preconception about what a house is'

This home is stirring up controversy in the Point Grey neighbourhood of Vancouver. Some of the neighbours have compared it to a penitentiary.

A house on Point Grey Road is turning neighbours' heads and raising eyebrows among architects in Vancouver.

The steel-cube home that sits on top of a glass box is still under construction, but is already the talk of the town.

It was even called "Vancouver's Most Hideous Urban Design" on one local blog.

The house on Point Grey Road is for sale. The architect says he thinks it will sell for $8 million or $9 million.

Former city councilor and city planner Gordon Price says it's been a polarizing work of art.

"You love it or you hate it. There's nothing in between," Price said.

"Initially, it has the shock of the new, but when you look at the houses next door, it's a variation on a very simple modernist box idea."

Unneighbourly

Although the street is lined with character homes, over the years, more modern, boxy structures have sprung up.

But the black steel box house has created more reaction than the others. 

On Price's local architecture blog, commentators compare the house to a Second World War bunker and call it "hideous" and "ugly." 

Michael Kluckner is a local historian who feels the cube house is indicative of a new era of homeowners who want ultimate privacy.

Historian Michael Kluckner just calls it simply unneighbourly.

"It turns its back on the street ... it's the ultimate expression of a courtyard culture and the evolution we have gone through over a century from being a front-porch culture," Kluckner said.

An outside-the-box box

But the architect of the "cube," as it's being called, says he was thinking outside the box. 

"It's outside the box in terms of people's preconceptions about what a house is," said Tony Robins.

"For me it's a sculptural building. It's part of the world stage of architecture, but the people I am really concerned about are the neighbours, so if they are upset, I am sorry," he said. 

Architect Tony Robins says his cube design is a modern work of art and promises the landscaping will change the current aesthetic of the building.

Robins says that there will be Japanese maple trees and other shrubbery that will soften the building up.

He estimates the building, which hasn't sold yet, will go for about $8 million or $9 million. It has a glass elevator, a four-car garage, and a fully glassed-in kitchen and living room. It also has a rooftop with a view of the mountains and ocean. 

The new house replaced a 1935 character home purchased in the fall of 2014 for $3.5 million.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.