Charlie Hebdo cartoon part of freedom of speech, rights groups say

An inflammatory cartoon picturing a drowned Syrian toddler and predicting his future as a sex offender in Germany has drawn criticism and outrage across the world.

'That's way beyond what anyone should do. A dead kid? I mean, come on'

Charlie Hebdo suggested that Alan Kurdi, had he grown up, would have been like the sexual attackers in Cologne, Germany (Twitter)

An inflammatory cartoon picturing drowned Syrian toddler Alan Kurdi and predicting his future as a sex offender in Germany is "remarkably offensive" but part of a society that values freedom of expression, say civil liberties associations.

The cartoon asks in French what would have become of the boy had he grown up. It shows two men running after screaming women with their tongues hanging out and hands outstretched above a caption that reads, also in French, bum grabbers in Germany.

The drawing refers to a series of sex attacks allegedly committed by a large group of migrants in Cologne, Germany, on New Year's Eve.

A photo of Alan Kurdi's little body lying face down on a Turkish beach made the front page of newspapers across the world and stoked global outrage over the Syrian refugee crisis.

Long-time British Columbian political cartoonist Adrian Raeside said he believes the newspaper's use of Alan's image was unnecessary and denigrates the work of editorial cartoonists.

"To be honest, that's way beyond what anyone should do. A dead kid? I mean, come on," Raeside said, emphasizing this was his personal opinion.

"I hope that this doesn't give editorial cartoonists a bad name."

Raeside spoke about his own policy of showcasing only people who willingly enter the public domain, leaving out those connected unintentionally.

"I don't draw cartoons about some politician's wife. That's not her fault that her husband's in politics," he said.

"Some politician's kids? That's not their fault that their father is the prime minister."

The right to be offended

The cartoon comes about a year after gunmen stormed Charlie Hebdo's offices in Paris and killed 12 people over the newspaper's incendiary depictions of the Muslim prophet Muhammad.

France this week commemorates the victims of last year's Islamist militant attacks on satirical weekly Charlie Hebdo and a Jewish supermarket with eulogies, memorial plaques and another cartoon lampooning religion. (Charles Platiau/Reuters)

While the publication stirred controversy and sparked acrimony online, Micheal Vonn of the B.C. Civil Liberties Association said that this anger is an unfortunate but natural result of the importance and protection our society places on freedom of expression.

"People will inevitably be offended," Vonn said. "(But) just because they're offended doesn't mean that they don't have a perfect right to be."

Charlie Hebdo is exercising its legal right to expression, and at the same time those decrying the publication are exercising that same right, Vonn said.

Cara Zwibel of the Canadian Civil Liberties Association added that a society that values freedom of expression has to take the good with the bad.

"This cartoon is remarkably offensive on a whole number of levels — at a grand societal level and also at the very personal level for people actually involved in this tragedy," she said, adding that there's something in the drawing to offend almost everyone.

She predicted the cartoon would not qualify for sanction under Canada's hate-crime laws, which she described as having a very high threshold.

Zwibel also observed the speed of social media today means counter-speech and contrary perspectives are able to mobilize quickly.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.