Canadians carrying debt into retirement
Experts suggest ways to help retirees manage debt
By Tom McFeat, CBC News
Posted: Jan 4, 2013 5:03 PM ET
Last Updated: Jan 23, 2013 8:12 PM ET
Figures show that one-third of Canadian retirees have debt and one-sixth of them owe more than $100,000. (iStock)
Related
Related Stories
- Seniors not factoring failing health into retirement plans
- Cooling house market could undercut retirement plans
- Retirement savings in Canada — by the numbers
- RRSP Season 2013
- Ottawa woman's debt delays retirement
- Canadians with big debts worry about interest rate
- Debt becomes us
- IMF warns about Canadian housing market, debt levels
RRSP Season
- RRSP Season main page
- A user's guide to RRSPs
- Forget RRSPs - pay down mortgage instead
- 6 top reasons people raid their RRSPs
Pensions
- Canadian Pension Plan's investments see 'explosive' growth
- CPP reform essential in light of sagging savings
Saving and Investing
- 7 popular (and free) personal finance apps
- 5 investment tips that challenge conventional wisdom
- No magic bullet for smart RRSP investing in 2013
- TFSAs are a flexible way to save
- Retirement savings in Canada — by the numbers
Planning
- Seniors unprepared for bigger picture of retirement
- Cooling house market could undercut retirement plans
- Rising retirement age can be good for your finances
- 10 must-reads for tough economic times
- Longer life expectancies straining retirees' budgets
Debt
We've all heard the warning. Don't retire with debt. It's a four-letter word — especially for those who've left the workforce.
But many of us aren't listening, it seems.
Statistics Canada says it's found that about one-third of retirees have debt. Among those 55 and over who are not yet retired, two-thirds are in debt. While half of retirees with debt owe less than $25,000, about one-sixth of them say they're in hock to the tune of more than $100,000.
A 2012 study by BMO found that more than half of Canadian homeowners expect they'll have a mortgage in retirement. And a recent CIBC poll found that 59 per cent of retired Canadians were carrying some kind of debt.
Personal finance author Gordon Pape labels that scenario "pretty scary."
"I have always maintained that one of the things that people should be aiming for when they go into retirement is to be debt-free," he told CBC Radio.
But what if you've already pulled the plug on that 9-to-5 job and still owe money?
Restructuring debt can help. Consolidating all one's debts can succeed in lowering the overall monthly payment and can see that 19.5 per cent credit card debt folded into something more manageable. But consolidation won't cut the total amount owed and it may stretch out the payback period.
There's also the option of refinancing one's current higher-rate mortgage. At today's low rates — a fixed-rate 10-year mortgage can now be had for slightly less than four per cent — the savings can be huge. A decade of stable, low payments can be a real stress-reducer for someone on a fixed income.
Reverse mortgages may be appropriate for some low-income retirees who want to stay in their homes for a few more years. But by deferring repayment of the money borrowed — sometimes for decades — the remaining equity in the home can be entirely eaten away.
We asked several financial experts for some other strategies to deal with debt in retirement.
- Have a realistic financial plan. All of our experts agreed on this. "People need to have a budget built out for retirement, not so much for today, but for the next 20 years," says Jason Heath, a certified financial planner at Objective Financial Partners Inc. in Toronto. "If things are tight right now, things are only going to get worse once interest rates rise." Retirees also need to account for replacing their car or getting a new roof and new appliances for the house. "People have to be realistic about what the future holds."
- Don't be lulled by interest-only debt payments. Home equity lines of credit typically require borrowers to pay only the interest. At four per cent, a $100,000 debt can be serviced for less than $350 a month. But you'll never pay it off. That may be fine for some people. But Marc Lamontagne, a certified financial planner at Ryan Lamontagne in Ottawa, suggests you take advantage of today's low-rate environment to pay down that debt. "If you have a four per cent line of credit and can still handle payments at seven per cent, structure the payment as though [the interest charged] was seven per cent,' he advises. That way, when interest rates eventually do rise, the debt will be smaller.
- Consider renting. "It's psychologically difficult for some people not to be homeowners, but sometimes it makes more financial sense to rent rather than own," says Lamontagne. "If they were to sell their home, they could have a big pool of money to generate income." Downsizing to a smaller home is also an option, although Lamontagne warns that forecast savings are often nibbled away by transaction costs and spending on the new home. Moving to a cheaper city or town may also make sense, but any benefit must be weighed against the loss of a familiar neighbourhood and more distant friends and family.
- Convert non-deductible debt to deductible debt. "Tax deductible debt is not as great a problem as non-deductible debt," says Warren MacKenzie, founder of Weigh House Investor Services in Toronto. "In some situations, non-deductible debt can be transformed into tax-deductible debt." He points out that if someone has a mortgage as well as a portfolio of non-registered investments, it can sometimes make good sense to sell the investments, pay off the mortgage, then buy back similar investments using a line of credit. That way, the interest on the line of credit would become a tax deductible expense.
Laurie Campbell, CEO of Credit Canada Debt Solutions, a Toronto-based, not-for-profit financial counselling organization, regularly sees retirees who've run into debt trouble. Sometimes, it's a result of bad planning. Sometimes, it's because unplanned expenses have come up, and there's no emergency fund in place.
Adult children might need financial help or health problems might make it impossible to continue working part-time in retirement.
"Unexpected expenses due to health are huge issues for people," she said. "There's no guarantee that you can keep your job or that your health will allow you to."
Campbell also worries about the dramatic rise in debt through home equity lines of credit.
"It's so easy to dip into that," she said. "This is going to be very problematic when interest rates rise."
Keep working
Campbell also warns that carrying debt into retirement on the assumption that it will be easy to get part-time work is "dangerous." There are no assurances that someone's health will stay good or that it will be easy for them to re-enter the job market, she says. "It's very hard for someone in their 60s to get back into the workplace."
That's another reason why many experts say the seriously indebted are often well advised to hang on to their job.
"A high level of debt can ruin an otherwise good retirement," said MacKenzie.
"So, as a general rule, if you can work a few years longer, during which time you could significantly reduce the debt, retirement should be delayed."
Low mortgage rates have allowed Canadians to take out increasingly large mortgages, and soaring house values in many cities have allowed people to use their homes as bank machines. And those credit cards that require minimum monthly payments of just one per cent of the balance have proven to be irresistible.
The figures show that, as a nation, we've already borrowed our way to record levels of debt. Many of us are comfortable with that.
But once retired, with incomes fixed and with interest rates poised to rise, the wiggle room begins to narrow.
Share Tools
Top News Headlines
- Cardinals begin pre-conclave meetings amid scandal
- Cardinals from around the world gathered inside the Vatican for their first round of meetings before the conclave to elect the next pope, amid scandals inside and out of the Vatican and the continued reverberations of Benedict XVI's decision to retire. more »
- Dad gets $22,000 data roaming 'shock' from Fido
- A B.C. dad is accusing Rogers of price gouging, after his 11-year-old mistakenly racked up $22,000 worth of data charges on his father's phone, during a family trip to Mexico. more »
- Queen remains in hospital after overnight stay
- Queen Elizabeth remains in a London hospital for a second day because of an apparent stomach infection. more »
- Egypt's politician skewer, testing the limits of post-revolution satire
- Meet Egypt's Jon Stewart, a former heart surgeon turned late-night TV host whose biting satire has not endeared him to the country's political class. But, as Nahlah Ayed reports, comedian Bassem Youssef may be the revolution's real star. more »
- Quebec papal contender 'ready' but wary of media spotlight
- Quebec Cardinal Marc Ouellet, who is considered by some to be a leading contender for the Vatican's top post, tells CBC's Peter Mansbridge in an exclusive interview he knows he must be ready to become the next pope as cardinals prepare to select Benedict's successor. more »
Latest Business Headlines
- Tax season 2013 tips and tricks
- RRSP has season barely ended, and it's already time to start hunting around for those T4 slips and mislaid tax receipts. Starting today and continuing to the April 30 tax filing deadline, CBC News brings you a series of articles that will help you maximize tax breaks and avoid common missteps that could cost you money. more »
- Keystone XL won't boost oilsands growth, U.S. report says
- The U.S. State Department says building the northern leg of TransCanada's controversial Keystone XL pipeline won't have a major impact on Alberta's oilsands development —a finding that might make it easier for the White House to approve the controversial project. more »
- Big U.S. businesses urge Supreme Court to OK gay marriage
- A group of 200 large American corporations is urging the country's top court to strike down a law that restricts marriage to heterosexual unions, arguing it creates expensive human resources headaches with regards to employee benefits. more »
- Detroit in 'financial emergency,' Gov. Snyder declares
- Michigan Gov. Rick Snyder said Friday he has declared a financial emergency in Detroit, a determination that could lead to the appointment of an emergency manager over the city's finances. more »
Markets
| Index | Last Trade | Change |
|---|---|---|
| TSX COMPOSITE | 12773.12 | 0 |
| DOW | 14089.66 | 0 |
| NASDAQ | 3169.74 | 0 |
| SP 500 | 1518.2 | 0 |
| TSX-VENTURE | 1120.09 | 0 |
The data on this site is informational only and may be delayed; it is not intended as trading or investment advice and you should not rely on it as such.

