Secret Fed transcripts show lax response to financial crisis
2007 documents reveal policymakers failed to grasp severity of coming recession
Posted: Jan 18, 2013 1:40 PM ET
Last Updated: Jan 18, 2013 2:38 PM ET
U.S. officials at the Federal Reserve drastically underestimated the world economy's likelihood to plunge into a financial crisis in 2007, according to newly released transcripts of meetings from that time.
On Friday, the Fed released a series of transcripts of high-level meetings between policymakers through 2007, and the documents paint a picture of an agency that was guarding its language publicly, but expressing serious concern behind closed doors.
"The odds are that the market will stabilize," Fed chair Ben Bernanke told a meeting of his counterparts in August 2007. In hindsight, GDP growth was already beginning to slow. But the full force of the financial crisis had yet to be felt.
'Some cow patties might show up in the punchbowls of some portfolios.'—Fed member Richard Fisher, in October 2007
In the public statement that followed that meeting, the Fed said it was ready to provide funds "as necessary" to ensure American businesses and consumers would have access to enough credit to keep the economy lubricated.
The mortgage market in particular had already turned the corner and moved south, as the first wave of American homeowners to default on their subprime mortgages had already started, although it remained small.
The issue of banks getting their fingers burned by bad mortgages, however, was starting to trickle into the real economy, as businesses and consumers saw lending start to dry up.
"Well-capitalized banks and opportunistic investors will come in and fill the gap, restoring credit flows to non-financial businesses and to the vast majority of households that can service their debts," said Donald Kohn, the Fed's vice-chair at the time.
As for the mortgage market, there are myriad instances of officials failing to see the tidal wave already underway.
At a meeting in October 2007, Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas president Richard Fisher acknowledged the crisis underway in America's housing market, but insisted that perception was not matching up with reality.
"The situation remains real, but we’ve gone beyond suspended reality," he said.
"If you will forgive me, you might say we have gone from the ridiculous to the subprime," he said, which drew groans from the other members.
Not that he dismissed the impact entirely. Indeed, he suggested he expected it to continue to unwind in investors' portfolios for some time to come.
"I am confident, as I have said in previous meetings, that — just to be polite — some cow patties might show up in the punchbowls of some portfolios," he continued.
Other meetings showed a similar downplaying of the crisis that was to come.
"In contrast to the partial recovery in non-prime mortgages … we are expecting a full recovery in jumbo mortgages to occur by early 2009," Federal Reserve economist Dave Stockton told the board in a closed door meeting on Sept. 18, 2007.
Official data now shows the U.S. slowdown in house prices started sometime in 2006 and wouldn't crater until 2009, when the Case-Schiller U.S. home price index was still showing yearly declines of nearly 20 per cent in America's largest housing markets.
"We also assume that there will be some hit to consumer sentiment," he continued. "The restraint imposed by these factors is assumed to fade over the next year."
Beyond America's borders, the documents reveal policymakers' thoughts at the time failed to grasp the enormity of the situation to follow.
"We have no indications from our supervisory counterparts that any major institution in Europe is facing a significant solvency problem now," Timothy Geithner said in August 2007, according to the documents. Geithner later became Treasury secretary but at the time was just one of many Federal Reserve board members.
European banks were able to delay the brunt of their own financial crisis for a time after America's was well underway. But by 2010, the continent's biggest lenders were in the middle of a debt crisis from which they have yet to emerge.
Top News Headlines
- Washington bridge collapse not Alberta trucker's fault, wife says
- The wife of the trucker implicated in Thursday's collapse of a bridge in Washington State that serves tens of thousands of commuters daily says her husband is not responsible for the incident. more »
- London attack victim's widow speaks of 'our future together'
- The family of the young British soldier who was killed in a brutal daytime slaying spoke at a press conference on Friday, including his widow who talked about their plans for the future. more »
- Greg Weston: Senate scandal may be Harper's worst hour
- The widening Senate scandal that the prime minister flippantly tried to dismiss as a 'distraction' just days ago has instead become arguably Stephen Harper's worst hour. more »
- Big hurricane season expected this year
- Canadian forecasters are warning warmer-than-average ocean waters and the lack of an El Nino warming of the central Pacific Ocean will contribute to an "active" hurricane season this year. more »
Latest Business Headlines
- Canada threatens retaliation over U.S. meat-labelling rules
- The federal government is threatening "retaliatory measures" against the United States in a dispute over meat-labelling rules that Ottawa and the World Trade Organization consider discriminatory. more »
- Canada ranks 3rd last in paid vacations
- Canada ranks third last among economically advanced countries in the amount of paid vacation time it guarantees its workers, a new U.S. study indicates. more »
- Manitoba Tel to sell Allstream, put $200M to pension and debt
- Manitoba Telecom Services Inc. has agreed to sell its Allstream business telecommunications arm and use about half of the proceeds to reduce its pension and debt obligations. more »
- New Jersey restaurants caught selling fake alcohol
- Twenty-nine New Jersey bars and restaurants, including 13 TGI Fridays, were accused of substituting cheap booze - or worse - for the good stuff while charging premium prices. more »
Lang & O'Leary Exchange
The data on this site is informational only and may be delayed; it is not intended as trading or investment advice and you should not rely on it as such.
- Rob Ford allies want mayor to address crack use allegations
- Rob Ford fired chief of staff for telling mayor to 'get help'
- Man 'lucky to be alive' after Washington bridge collapse
- Greg Weston: Senate scandal may be Harper's worst hour
- Alleged Ford crack video seller not responding to calls
- Pickup truck backs up over mother, 2 children in tent
- Amanda Bynes arrested for allegedly tossing bong out window
- Canada Post campaigns against 'no flyers' mailbox signs
- 3D printers give rise to 'desktop manufacturing'