How a $1-trillion coin could solve the U.S. debt ceiling crisis
Idea floated by New York Times columnist Paul Krugman
By Mark Gollom, CBC News
Posted: Jan 9, 2013 5:02 AM ET
Last Updated: Jan 9, 2013 2:03 PM ET
As the U.S. heads toward more political conflict over the national debt ceiling, liberal economist and New York Times columnist Paul Krugman believes he has found a simple trillion-dollar solution to stave off yet another potential economic crisis.
Writing on his blog, Krugman, somewhat half-serious, suggests that if the Republicans, who are looking for spending cut pledges to tackle the debt, would be willing to force America into default by refusing to vote to raise the debt ceiling, U.S. President Barack Obama should be willing to take this step.
"He will, after all, be faced with a choice between two alternatives: one that’s silly but benign, the other that’s equally silly but both vile and disastrous. The decision should be obvious," he wrote.
The debt ceiling is the government's borrowing limit that can only be raised through congressional authorization.
Krugman notes that a legal loophole allows the Treasury to mint platinum coins in any denomination it chooses. By minting a $1-trillion coin, then depositing it at the Federal Reserve, "the Treasury could acquire enough cash to sidestep the debt ceiling — while doing no economic harm at all," Krugman wrote.
Inspires Twitter hashtag
And Krugman isn't the only one raising the idea. New York Democratic congressman Jerry Nadler has expressed support for it and a formal White House petition has been started, as has a Twitter hashtag (#Mintthecoin).
But is this a plausible course of action?
"The platinum coin is a silly, but elegant, solution to a silly problem," Mike Moffatt, assistant economics professor at Western University's Richard Ivey School of Business, wrote in an email to CBC News. "The platinum coin proposal gives the Obama administration an alternative if House Republicans are completely intransigent on the debt ceiling issue."
Antony Davies, an economics professor at Pittsburgh's Duquesne University, took a dimmer view. He said minting a trillion-dollar coin is the same as printing money, and is all part of the "money illusion."
"Money illusion is the [false] belief that one is better off when one has more money," he wrote in an email to CBC News. "It certainly sounds reasonable until we distinguish between 'money' and 'purchasing power.'"
For example, he said that if the government announced that everyone was to add a zero to their money, every dollar bill would become a 10, just as $1,000 in a chequing account, would become $10,000.
"Would you be better off? The answer is no. All that would happen is that businesses would add a zero to their prices. A 75 cent hamburger would cost $7.50," Davies said.
Printing money causes inflation
What makes money valuable, he said, is the goods and services money buys.
"Minting a trillion-dollar coin doesn’t change the amount of goods and services. Therefore, all the trillion-dollar coin does is to take the value of existing goods and services and spread it around a larger number of dollars – thereby making each dollar worth less. We call this inflation. Printing more money [or minting more coins] simply causes inflation."
Moffatt agreed that if there was no response from the Federal Reserve, the trillion-dollar coin move would be inflationary. But he said the Fed would almost certainly respond by taking an equal amount of money out of the economy, by selling some of the large inventory of bonds.
This, in technical terms, would "sterilize" the deposit, meaning there would be no impact on inflation, Moffatt said.
"Although there are no direct economic consequences, I cannot see the Obama administration using such an option," Moffatt said. "Such a move would be highly controversial and would not be well understood by the general public."
'Highly controversial' move
In an email to the Washington Post, Philip Diehl, the former director of the U.S. Mint and Treasury chief of staff who helped write the platinum coin law, also said there would be no negative macroeconomic effects.
"The accounting treatment of the coin is identical to the treatment of all other coins. The mint strikes the coin, ships it to the Fed, books $1 trillion, and transfers $1 trillion to the Treasury’s general fund where it is available to finance government operations just like with proceeds of bond sales or additional tax revenues," he wrote.
"Once the debt limit is raised, the Fed could ship the coin back to the mint where the accounting treatment would be reversed and the coin melted. The coin would never be “issued” or circulated and bonds would not be needed to back the coin."
Leaving nothing to chance, Oregon Republican Greg Walden said Monday he's planning to introduce a law that would bar the Treasury from minting such coin.
"This scheme to mint trillion-dollar platinum coins is absurd and dangerous, and would be laughable if the proponents weren’t so serious about it as a solution," he said in a statement. "I'm introducing a bill to stop it in its tracks."With files from The Associated Press
Top News Headlines
- Will alleged Rob Ford video overshadow Toronto casino debate?
- A debate about a proposed downtown casino is supposed to take centre stage at Toronto City Hall on Tuesday, but it seems a safe bet that a still-unseen video of Mayor Rob Ford will continue to be a topic of conversation. more »
- Harper to address Tory caucus amid Senate scandal
- Conservatives gathered Monday night to mourn the passing of a key architect in their rise to power — and to brace for the toughest test Prime Minister Stephen Harper's government has faced since taking office on a promise to clean up politics in the national capital. more »
- Keith Boag: Have you heard about the murderous abortion doctor?
- The gruesome trial and murder conviction of Philadelphia abortion provider Dr. Kermit Gosnell is unlikely to change American abortion law, Keith Boag writes. But it has U.S. journalists questioning their priorities and how they cover such a sensitive issue. more »
- Baseball fuels dreams, desperation in Dominican Republic
- The Toronto Blue Jays have a number of stars from the Dominican Republic, but in the shadow of these successful players is an equally important story about hope and poverty, and a country desperately struggling to balance the two. more »
Latest Business Headlines
- Russell 2000 small-company index surpasses 1,000
- The Russell 2000, an index of small-company stocks, rose above 1,000 for the first time. The index is outpacing the Dow Jones industrial average and the Standard & Poor's 500 index this year. more »
- Yahoo buys Tumblr blogging site for $1.1B
- Yahoo is buying online blogging forum Tumblr for $1.1 billion as CEO Marissa Mayer tries to rejuvenate an internet icon that had fallen behind the times. more »
- Xbox launch Tuesday highly anticipated
- Microsoft's next-generation Xbox expected to be revealed Tuesday, and anticipation for the entertainment console's latest evolution is running high. more »
- Wealth management key for banks amid slow growth in retail
- As Canada's biggest banks prepare to report their second-quarter results, analysts say those that rely more heavily on wealth management and global markets will fare better amid slowing growth in Canadian retail banking. more »
Lang & O'Leary Exchange
The data on this site is informational only and may be delayed; it is not intended as trading or investment advice and you should not rely on it as such.
- 51 dead after tornado levels Oklahoma suburbs
- Huge tornado hits Oklahoma City suburb, kills 51
- Edmonton driver, 62, charged in boy's patio death
- Unknown remains found on Dellen Millard's farm
- Will alleged Rob Ford video overshadow Toronto casino debate?
- Netflix and the rise of binge TV watching
- B.C. man feared kidnapped in Mexico
- Ray Manzarek of The Doors dies at 74
- Canadian on EI shut out amid foreign worker influx