Microsoft appeal on i4i patent goes to top court
Last Updated: Monday, November 29, 2010 | 2:39 PM ET
CBC News
The U.S. Supreme Court will hear a $290-million US dispute between Microsoft Corp. and Canadian technology company i4i Inc. over complaints that the former's ubiquitous Word program violates one of i4i's patents.
Loudon Owen, left, i4i chair, and founder Michel Vulpe first sued Microsoft for patent infringement in 2007. (Mark Blinch/Reuters) The high court on Monday agreed to hear an appeal from the Redmond, Wash.-based Microsoft, which wants the multimillion-dollar judgment against it erased.
In its appeal, the world's largest software maker says the lower court that handles patent cases makes it too hard for those accused of infringement to argue that a patent should never have been granted initially. Tech giants Apple Inc. and Google Inc. have taken the unprecedented step of publicly backing their rival Microsoft in the dispute.
In Microsoft's appeal, Apple told the justices that the patent system “is tilting out of balance,” giving disproportionate power to people who secure patents of questionable legitimacy, Bloomberg reported.
Toronto-based i4i first sued Microsoft in 2007, saying it owned the technology behind the XML used in Microsoft Word. The technology in question gave Word 2003 and Word 2007 users an improved way to edit XML, which is computer code that tells the program how to interpret and display a document's contents.
The lower courts say Microsoft wilfully infringed on the patent, and ordered it to pay i4i $290 million US and stop selling versions of Word containing the infringing technology.
"The attack on patent holders and the adverse implications from the standard Microsoft is proposing is unprecedented and would deal a devastating blow to any U.S. patent holder, large or small," i4i chairman Loudon Owen said.
The ruling is the largest ever upheld by an appeals court in a patent case, but Microsoft has yet to pay any of the funds as it appeals the decision.
Microsoft now sells versions of Word that do not contain the technology in question. It's believed that more than 500 million people in the world use some version of the Microsoft Word software.
Microsoft executive David Howard said the company is glad the justices decided to hear their appeal.
The court’s decision to hear the case “is a clear affirmation that the issues raised in this case are critical to the integrity of our patent system,” he said. "We look forward to presenting our case to the Supreme Court."
Chief Justice John Roberts did not take part in the consideration or the decision in this case. He reported owning between as much as $250,000 US worth of Microsoft stock in 2009 on his annual disclosure report.
The court will hear the case in early 2011.
Share Tools
Top News Headlines
- Syria massacre toll up to 108, UN monitor says
- The UN Security Council is holding an emergency meeting Sunday to discuss the recent massacre in the Syrian town of Houla, in which 108 people died, many of them children under the age of 10. more »
- Montreal protesters march in peaceful defiance
- The clanging of pots and pans sounded throughout Montreal's downtown core Saturday night and into early Sunday morning, as thousands of protesters marched on in peaceful — but loud — defiance of Bill 78. more »
- Love film a 2nd win for Cannes director
- Michael Haneke won the Cannes Film Festival's top trophy for a second time with his film about love and death, Amour. more »
- Lady Gaga nixes Indonesia show after threats
- Lady Gaga cancelled her sold-out show in Indonesia after Islamist hard-liners threatened violence, claiming her sexy clothes and provocative dance moves would corrupt the youth. more »
Latest Business Headlines
- Bankia asks Spain for €19B
- The board of directors of Spain's troubled bank, Bankia, has asked the Spanish government for €19 billion ($24.5 billion Cdn) in financial support. more »
- EI reforms aim to boost employment, Flaherty says
- Finance Minister Jim Flaherty defended his government's proposals to change employment insurance, saying the aim is to remove "disincentives to employment." more »
- Employment Insurance review boards to be scrapped
- The federal government is scrapping two review boards used by people appealing decisions made about their employment insurance. more »
- Ottawa moves to limit foreign investment reviews
- The federal government is raising to $1 billion the amount of foreign money that can go into a Canadian company before the investment is reviewed. The review has been used in the past to block foreign takeovers of MDA and Potash Corp. more »
Lang & O'Leary Exchange
Markets
| Index | Last Trade | Change |
|---|---|---|
| TSX COMPOSITE | 11576.47 | 10.4 |
| DOW | 12454.83 | -74.92 |
| NASDAQ | 2837.53 | -1.85 |
| SP 500 | 1317.82 | -2.86 |
| NYSE COMPOSITE | 7534.32 | -18.01 |
| AMEX | 2227.37 | 1.45 |
| TSX-VENTURE | 1309.27 | 26.8 |
The data on this site is informational only and may be delayed; it is not intended as trading or investment advice and you should not rely on it as such.
Business Features
- Teen struck by lightning in Ottawa dies
- Missing Winnipeg children found in Mexico
- Quebec tornadoes cause millions in damage
- Montreal protesters march in peaceful defiance
- Syria massacre toll up to 116, UN monitor says
- Woman's remains found in hockey bag on Cape Breton river
- Everest team unable to bring down Toronto woman's body
- WWE apologizes to Brazil over Canadian's flag stomp
- Pope's butler arrested in Vatican leaks scandal

