Michael Hlinka: Cheers to a company squarely hitting the marketing mark
- April 30, 2009 8:44 AM |
- By Michael Hlinka
Money Talks is a business column from CBC radio.
By Michael Hlinka, CBC business columnist:
In my line of work – and that’s commenting on business – it’s really easy to be critical. I tend to be particularly hard on the advertising and marketing professions, and there’s a simple reason why. If I may generalize, they spend most of their time and efforts worrying about the sizzle, when it’s the steak that matters. But today I’m going to lavish praise on McDonald’s Restaurants of Canada, for the smartest and timeliest promotion I’ve seen in a long time: Until this Sunday May 3rd, McDonald’s is giving out free coffee to people who visit one of its stores during morning hours.
That’s right. Free. No strings attached. No other purchases necessary. And available at any of their 1,400-and-some-odd locations.
There’s an interesting back-story behind the timing of this give-away. Last year, McDonald’s switched coffee suppliers. Friends of mine who are big fans of the franchise used to describe the coffee as terrible. Now they claim it’s the best in the marketplace. Clearly, others agree: For the first three months of 2009 compared to 2008, the chain’s coffee sales were up by double digits. But the message wasn’t getting out fast enough … hence the promotion – free morning coffee for two weeks.
The genius works on so many levels.
First, how can you beat “free” during a recession. Coffee sales in restaurants have actually slumped in Canada over the past year as people watch their budgets more carefully. But it’s still a huge market - nearly 2 billion cups were sold last year - and the margins are incredible (in the neighbourhood of 90 per cent). Which means, of course, that the give-away isn’t costing McDonald’s too much. The 10-ounce cup retails for $1.22. My guess is that the “hard” costs to McDonald’s are perhaps 15 cents per. So all in, I’m guessing that the promotion might be costing the company just a little bit more than $1 million. And if I’m right – that’s a bargain.
This is also a template for other marketers about how to get their marketing message right. We are in a recession. People are more conscious of their spending. But when I see advertisement after advertisement on television, it seems that company after company is blissfully unaware/ Let me speak for the typical consumer: I want something of real value, and that doesn’t mean slickly produced commercials with beautiful people and silly pranks. I want you to give me a reason why you deserve my business.
A free trial is about as good a reason as I can think of. So congratulations, McDonald’s, not only for coming up with a great promotion – congratulations for showing everyone else how marketing should be done.
Categories
- Andrew Wahl (19)
- Andrew Willis (13)
- Bob LeDrew (10)
- Dan Noel (1)
- David Baskin (18)
- David Berman (1)
- David Colman (14)
- Deborah Yedlin (29)
- Duncan Stewart (29)
- Ellen Roseman (90)
- Jacqueline Drew (10)
- Jim Bray (25)
- Jim Jubak (6)
- John Gilchrist (4)
- Kelly VanBuskirk (6)
- Kira Vermond (73)
- Loraleigh Kovacik (9)
- Michael Hlinka (183)
- Peter Vincent (16)
- Pierre Battah (1)
- Todd Hirsch (1)
All News blogs
Most Commented
Most Recommended
Money Talks
Most Commented
Most Recommended
Recent Entries
- Kira Vermond: Resolutions for Work
- New Year, new you. At least that's what you're shooting for in 2012 at your workplace. This is the year that you're going to ditch your wallflower ways, speak up in meetings and take the initiative.... Continue reading this post
- Ellen Roseman: Air Miles-Use them or lose them!
- If you're collecting Air Miles, you now have only five years to use them. And if you don't redeem in time, you'll lose them.... Continue reading this post
- Kira Vermond: New Year's resolutions
- Sure, Hanukkah has begun and Christmas is still a few days away, so it feels a little early to fast forward to the New Year. But that's exactly what you've got to do if your resolution is "find another... Continue reading this post
Comments (15)
The fact of matter is that MacDonalds is losing industry leadership in Canada big time to Tim Hortons. Now frustrated by its performance in Canada they jumping into the core business of Tim's. No matter what they offer free they are still not keeping coffee fresh like Tims and they cannot beat the loyality of Tims customrs like me.
Had an opportunity to try the new coffee at a location in Kingston, en-route to T.O. It's great! However, McD's policy of not filling travel mugs, and insisting on selling hot beverages only in disposable cups isn't exactly forward thinking. I'll be at the competion's, enjoying breakfast, and drinking coffee from my favorite (no waste!)thermal mug next time!
Dated strategy, McDonald's is not the first one to use it nor it will be the last.
From the 36 Stratagem -"EXCHANGE A BRICK FOR A JADE"
Give away something on which you place relativeely little value in exchange for something you value much more.
For more information on Innovation and Strategy go to www.kaimethod.com
I don't get the rabid loyalty of the Tim Horton's customer. The donuts & muffins are sub-par & are not made from scratch on the premises, the 20 mins coffee is a low quality
blend, that needs the " double,double to make it palatable,& ladies & gentlemen, it's not Canadian, it's owned by Wendy's, who are American........yet, I guess there is no end of lazy people, who idle their cars & trucks in long lines to get to the drive-in window to buy bad food & drink.
I haven't had a cup of McD's coffee in about 5 years. The last one I had was the worst coffee experience of my life... it was more like drinking motor oil.
When I heard that they had switched suppliers I thought nothing of it, they've never been known for their coffee and besides, I was a loyal Tim's fan. Last week I heard about the promotion on the radio so I dropped by my local shop to see what all the fuss was about. I was amazed at how good and fresh it tasted. I've been drinking it ever since. I actually prefer it to Tim's and if they sold it in a take home tin I would happily buy it.
I'm not a fan of fast food and would never eat a meal there but I will be buying coffee there from now on. It's that good!
Re: Tony's comments
This was an article about McDonalds, not Tim Horton's. But to set the record straight, Tim Horton's is no longer owned by Wendy's. The companies split some time ago.
The one thing McDonalds really needs to work on is the noise level in their restaurants. It's not a relaxing atmosphere in the least. The message is simple: Get in, spend your money, get out!
I was one of those Tim's people who would wait too long in the drive-thru, because I thought it was the only decent coffee out there. Well, I took advantage of the free coffee offer, told them I usually get a medium rather than a small being offered. "No problem" I was told with a smile. In and out in a tenth of the time I usually spend waiting for my Tim's...the best part of it however was the taste of the coffee itself...Tim's lost a loyal customer...who da thought?
Good promotion. One funny item I heard is that McDonalds won't fill up reusable cups for their free promotion. The customer was told McDonalds does not do that as everything has to be regimented in to a paper cup. So more free coffee equals more pollution.
A little more common sense would be the order of the day. Yes, I understand their coffee is good but until they switch to fair trade, I will sit on the sidelines.
One should try to stay away from all fast food places inluding McDonald's and Tim Hortons.
Reason? Not good for you.
I occasionally go to Macdonalds to get my kids a treat. I tried the new blend and it was great. No long line ups, cheaper than Tims and tastes better.........sold new customer!
Free? No strings attached? No other purchases necessary?
I went with some friends to the downtown Victoria McDonald's last week and were told a food purchase was required before we could take advantage of the free coffee promotion. Knowing McD's food quality, I walked away without the coffee.
And to comment on Jim from Vancouver's comments about the atmosphere in McD's....you're right about the noise. The colours are horrible too. I've read that fast food restaurants are built to be uncomfortable. That will ensure you'll get in and get out as quick as you can, thereby quickly vacating your seat for the next customer to use.
What is the cost to the producer??
If Tim's or MacD's went 100% Fairtrade therers a story!
I laugh when I read the comments of those poeple who say they never would eat at Mc Donald's but find themselves in line for a free coffee. Not only are they hypocrits but cheap ones at that!
How about buying your coffee from an independently owned local coffee shop run by people who care about you and your community...I think it's worth the buck twenty five...and the coffee rocks any fast food joint.
I think that it is despicable when I see people waiting in their cars to get coffee rather than park and go inside. Actually I would rather make it at home. Always the way I like it and at a 80% discount. Tims is usually OK but that lineup is silly. McD's far to much cream even when I ask for 1/2 a cream. Perhaps I should ask for a hint of cream. My preference is for a strong coffee flavour which is generally hard to get when someone does it for you.