Little chance of federal budget surplus in 2014-2015: TD report

A TD economist is making a dire prediction about federal finances for the coming year. In a research note released this morning, Randall Bartlett writes the government will likely face a budget deficit for the next two fiscal years, before returning to surplus in 2017-18.

Economist says low oil prices make fiscal deficit more likely

Prime Minister Stephen Harper, centre, shown Monday, said in mid-December that there was 'no doubt that the government will balance its budget next year.' However, a TD economist says in a research note released Tuesday that the government’s fiscal outlook is much weaker than predicted in the fall fiscal update. (Sean Kilpatrick/The Canadian Press)

The federal government will likely face a budget deficit for the next two fiscal years, before returning to surplus in 2017-18, TD Economics senior economist Randall Bartlett says. 

Bartlett's research note released Tuesday morning flies in the face of the government’s repeated assurances that a $1.6-billion surplus is on the way.

In mid-December, Prime Minister Stephen Harper said there was “no doubt that the government will balance its budget next year.”

“Even with dramatically lower oil prices,” said Harper, “we will balance the budget.”

According to Bartlett, those dramatically lower oil prices are the reason a surplus is unlikely.

Using a proprietary forecasting model, Bartlett determined that the government’s fiscal outlook is actually much weaker than predicted in the fall fiscal update.

That update relied on the price of West Texas Intermediate crude oil remaining at U.S. $81 per barrel. Since then, prices have continued to fall. As of noon on Tuesday, WTI crude was trading in the U.S. $45 range.

Bartlett's analysis assumes that oil will regain some of its lost value, averaging U.S. $67.50 per barrel this year, and U.S. $80.25 next year.

Economic promises in an election year

Balancing the budget is seen as a key election-year pledge from the Harper government. The election is currently scheduled for October 19 of this year, although the government could potentially call Canada to the polls earlier.

In addition to preventing a surplus, the low price of oil could keep the government from introducing tax cuts and economic policies that would appeal to voters.

Bartlett writes it could be a “challenge” for the government to introduce “significant new policy measures, such as enhancing the Tax Free Savings Account, in the current fiscal environment.”

The government could also stick to its policy pledges without raising taxes by reducing spending in other areas, noted Bartlett. But that might be a poor long-term strategy.

"Operating expenses are currently at an all-time low as a share of the economy," writes Bartlett, "and history has shown that a prolonged low level of program spending is generally unsustainable and ultimately leads to rapid spending growth down the road."

Bartlett did acknowledge that a surplus is technically possible, if unlikely.

“These expected deficits are less than the federal government’s annual $3 billion set aside for contingencies,” wrote Bartlett. “As such, surpluses over the next couple of years cannot be ruled out.”

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.