Story Tools: PRINT | Text Size: S M L XL | REPORT TYPO | SEND YOUR FEEDBACK

In Depth

Science

Nanotechnology

Small science generates big questions

January 8, 2007

Nanotechnology, the science of manipulating things smaller than 100 nanometers — more than 800 times smaller than the width of a human hair — promises to deliver everything from vastly more efficient computers and stronger building materials to microscopic cancer-fighting agents.

But could this tiny technology also bring hidden dangers?

In 1986, nanotech pioneer Eric Drexler floated the idea that an incautious approach to nanoscience could result in runaway self-replicating nanobots, whose reproductive frenzy would consume everything on the planet and leave only "grey goo." This apocalyptic scenario caught the public's imagination (Michael Crichton even wrote a book about it), although scientists, including Drexler, subsequently pointed out that the concept is far more the stuff of fiction than of science.

Even though we don't have to worry about being turned into "grey goo" anytime soon, there are a variety of less colourful — but more credible — risks associated with nanoscience.

A recent report in the science journal Nature was critical of government and industry for, among other things, not mandating appropriate testing on nanotechnologies before allowing them to reach the public. Andrew Maynard, lead author of the report, says we should be asking, "Is the ability to manipulate matter to an extent that we've never, ever been able to do before going to bring about new risks? And if so, how do we identify those risks and ultimately manage them?"

"There probably are risks, but we just don't know what they are, and that's the problem," Pat Mooney, executive director of ETC Group, an organization that studies the environmental and social impact of emerging technologies, said. "We're eating [nanotechnology], we're using it in all kinds of products that we wear on our skin and our clothing, and yet governments have no capacity to understand or regulate it."

Potential hazards

While many nanomaterials are simply tinier forms of existing chemical compounds, the results of nanotechnology-based manufacturing processes are anything but simple. They can exhibit entirely new and unpredictable characteristics.

"What we do know is that chemicals which are benign at the macro scale can become very toxic at the nano scale, or they may have the same toxicity, but be able to get into parts of the body that a larger-size particle wouldn't be able to," Carolyn Cairns, a researcher for Consumer Reports magazine who specializes in technology, said. "Some of these materials are being used in very exposure-intensive applications, like skin creams, sunscreens and food applications."

Kristen Kulinowski, director of the International Council on Nanotechnology at Rice University, added that, "The hazard studies that have been done show evidence that nanomaterials have the potential to cause oxidative damage, to punch holes in cell membranes, to kill cells in culture, and to have harmful impacts on populations in ecosystems."

Kulinowski noted, however, that it's unclear whether these laboratory results can be extrapolated to the outside world.

Little regulation

At present there is no requirement under the laws of any industrialized country that a chemical compound being used at a macro scale be re-evaluated for use at a nano scale, even if its characteristics are completely different.

Neil Gordon, president of the Canadian NanoBusiness Alliance, said that to some degree, the market will regulate potential hazards, noting that companies have a vested interest in ensuring the safety of their products. "Because there are new ways of doing things, a portion of the investment budget should go into safeguards. One of the great things about industry is that if things go out of whack, you have the ability to sue a manufacturer and put them out of business."

Many experts, however, take the approach that some form of regulation is necessary. And the question of potential hazards is made more urgent by the growing number of nanotech products already on the market. The Project on Emerging Nanotechnologies' Consumer Products Inventory, for example, lists more than 350 consumer products already on sale to the public, none of them specifically regulated as nanomaterials.

Why has so little been done on nano regulation? For one thing, there's the question of figuring out exactly what to regulate.

Nanotechnologies cut across a broad variety of scientific disciplines, and a health researcher may label something a nanoparticle based on its size, while a physicist might define it only by its novel properties.

"There's this whole debate on definitional issues for regulatory purposes," Lori Sheremeta, a project leader at the National Institute of Nanotechnology at the University of Alberta, said. "If we can't define what we're talking about accurately, how are we going to regulate it? And that's the issue that the regulators are facing right now — they're being called upon to do something, and there's not enough data to determine what they should be asking for from parties who want to put products on the market."

Another reason for the widespread lack of regulation is the approach of some manufacturers towards their nano products.

"There's a sort of doublespeak with respect to the risks," Rice University's Kulinowski said. "This is an entirely new class of materials with new chemical and physical properties, but some companies are trying to have it both ways. They'll say 'My product is better because I'm using nanomaterials, these new sexy exotic materials that are doing all kinds of wonderful things,' and out of the other side of their mouth, they're saying to the regulators, 'It's just the same old stuff, only smaller,' so there's no need to treat it any differently, or even to look any more carefully at its potential impacts."

Action slow to happen

So far, there has been little public pressure to regulate nanotechnologies. Some say this is simply because most people aren't even aware that nanotechnology is now part of a number of consumer products they use regularly. A recent U.S. poll conducted for the Project on Emerging Nanotechnologies found that 68 per cent of Americans knew little or nothing about nanoscience.

But after a slow start, a few things are starting to happen, especially in the United States.

In November 2006, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency advised Samsung Electronics that a washing machine that produces "nanosilver" particles to kill bacteria in clothing would be regulated as a pesticide. The EPA is playing coy, stating publicly that the move "does not represent an action to regulate nanotechnology," although in fact it appears to be exactly that.

At a local level, in December 2006, the city of Berkeley, Calif., passed a law requiring researchers and manufacturers to report any nanotechnology materials they are working with, and to release details on how the tiny materials are handled.

Meeting the challenges

The recent Nature paper recommends addressing five "Grand Challenges," which involve creating tools and methods to measure toxicity and other environmental impacts of new, engineered nanomaterials. However, undertaking these challenges will require investment by government and industry, which to date has not been forthcoming.

In Canada, for example, a report on the state of nanotechnology was submitted to the Liberal government in late 2005. However, since the Conservative government came into power in January 2006, no action has been taken and no funding has been allocated to further initiatives in this area of science.

Anthony Seaton, another author of the Nature report, says: "There is international agreement among scientists that something needs to be done, but no government yet has really agreed put money into it. But in the meantime, many products are coming to market, and that's the slightly alarming thing."

Go to the Top

Menu

Science main page
Left-handed presidents
Relationships
The chemistry of love and attraction
Alien invasion
Arrival of foreign species into native ecosystems a worldwide problem
Home invasion
Some ants can make homeowners cry uncle
Amateur astronomy
Graduating to telescopes
Star gazing
Amateur astronomy
Going deep
Canadian students build an autonomous underwater robot to get to the bottom of things
Large Hadron Collider
Digs go high-tech
Computers open new windows to the ancient world
The beetle and the damage done
Hydrogen power
National Research Council scientist David Ghosh on the potential and problems of hydrogen fuel cells
A sweet science
Maple sap tapped as potential green products source
Unravelling DNA
Much ado about nothing
Solar storms have little impact on modern technology, experts say
Music and the brain
Solar substorms
Mind over money
Nanotechnology
Ocean innovation
Thorium comes clean?
Transgenics
Unobtainium
Part 1
Part 2
Blu-ray and hd-dvd
Laptop batteries
LCD: how it works
Ornithopter
Ornithopter: How it works
Toxic tech
Story Tools: PRINT | Text Size: S M L XL | REPORT TYPO | SEND YOUR FEEDBACK

World »

Iranian-Canadian journalist talks of prison ordeal Video
Iranian-Canadian journalist Maziar Bahari says he was regularly beaten and threatened with execution while imprisoned in Iran for 118 days.
Indonesian ferry sinks in storm
Rescuers saved more than 240 people aboard an Indonesian passenger ferry that sank Sunday in rough waters off Sumatra island, but at least 29 people have died, officials said.
Iranian forces practise defending nuke sites
Iran on Sunday began large-scale air defence war games aimed at protecting the country's nuclear facilities against any possible attack, state television reported.
more »

Canada »

Afghan prisoner transfers halted 'more than 1 time' Video
Canadian officials have halted the transfer of prisoners to Afghanistan's intelligence service "more than one time," because of the possibility of torture, Canada's chief of defence staff said Sunday.
Teens named in 4-death crash near Calgary
Police have released the names of three young women killed in a two-vehicle crash south of Calgary on Saturday afternoon, but have yet to reveal the name of a fourth woman who died.
Vancouver Island residents survey flood damage
Hundreds of people on south Vancouver Island forced from their homes by flooding have been allowed to return, but most won't be able to stay because of damage to their houses.
more »

Politics »

Journalists enhance Canadians' freedom: PM
Prime Minister Stephen Harper urged journalists to "shine light into dark corners" of government affairs during a speech late Saturday, but wouldn't take questions from reporters covering the event.
Colvin's job safe despite Afghan torture testimony Video
The Conservatives will not try to remove Richard Colvin from his post in Washington, Defence Minister Peter MacKay says, even though they question the credibility of his testimony on Afghan prisoners.
Hillier didn't hear detainee torture allegations Video
Former chief of defence staff Rick Hillier says he's never heard suggestions that Canada may have been complicit in the torture of detainees in Afghanistan.
more »

Health »

More H1N1 vaccine, ventilators to come Video
Ontario supplied hospitals with 200 additional ventilators on Friday in anticipation of a surge in swine flu cases.
Trade show pitches surgical passages to India Video
Exhibitors at a Toronto trade fair are hoping to add surgery to the list of reasons Canadians travel, but a medical ethicist questions the lack of oversight.
Weight gain in pregnancy guides updated
Health Canada is formally replacing its guidelines on weight gain during pregnancy to match new U.S. recommendations.
more »

Arts & Entertainment»

Plaskett double winner at Canadian Folk Music Awards
Joel Plaskett's triple album Three earned the Halifax singer-songwriter a double win at the Canadian Folk Music Awards on Saturday.
Kirov ballerina steps out at Cultural Olympiad
Uliana Lopatkina, principal dancer with the Kirov Ballet, will make her Canadian debut Feb. 10 at the Vancouver 2010 Cultural Olympiad
Documentary explores carbon trading business
Carbon Hunters is about a new breed of entrepreneurs working to get rich and save the planet at the same time.
more »

Technology & Science »

Bell quietly drops system access fee
The cellphone system access fee is all but extinct. Bell Canada has quietly axed the charge, joining rivals Rogers and Telus.
Beam sent around Large Hadron Collider
The operators of the Large Hadron Collider have successfully sent a beam of particles around the ring of the world's largest particle collider in Switzerland.
Astronauts complete 6-hour spacewalk
Astronauts from space shuttle Atlantis completed the second of three scheduled spacewalks Saturday, spending just over six hours installing equipment on the International Space Station.
more »

Money »

Ottawa will stay course on stimulus: Flaherty Video
Rather than turning off the stimulus taps or pouring more fuel on the economic fire, Ottawa will stand pat with the $61 billion in stimulus spending announced in January, Finance Minister Jim Flaherty says.
Canada Post struggles to innovate
Canada's postal service is reinventing itself as it struggles to make up for dwindling demand in the face of a devastating global economic slowdown.
The 10-billion-barrel battle
Henry Lyatsky wants B.C.'s coast opened to oil drilling but environmentalists stand opposed.
more »

Consumer Life »

Bullying is a public health issue: researcher
Bullying should be considered a public health problem and governments should adopt national strategies against it, says a Canadian professor who led a study of bullying in 40 countries.
Early Canadian stamps auction nets $3.2M US Video
A New York stamp collector auctioned parts of his collection in New York on Thursday, including a Canadian-issued stamp that is one of the world's rarest.
Fake hairstyling irons pop up in Regina
Hundreds of knock-off hairstyling irons were seized Friday morning by RCMP acting on a hot tip.
more »

Sports »

Scores: NHL NBA

Roughriders will meet Alouettes in Grey Cup
The Saskatchewan Roughriders are headed to the Grey Cup in Calgary after Darian Durant passed for 204 yards and three touchdowns in a 27-17 win over the defending champion Stampders in Sunday's West Division final.
Alouettes off to Grey Cup after devouring Lions
The Montreal Alouettes humbled the B.C. Lions on Sunday afternoon, earning their seventh trip to the Grey Cup game since 2000.
Virtue, Moir clinch Skate Canada gold
Tessa Virtue and Scott Moir put down a superb free program to win the ice dance competition at the 2009 HomeSense Skate Canada International.
more »