CBC In Depth
INDEPTH: PERSONAL FINANCE
Students in Debt – Profiles of Struggle
by Lani Krantz, CBC News Online | September 20, 2004

Debts, and the payments that go with them, are forcing many former students to delay the usual rites of passage of young adulthood – buying a home, a car, even having children – while they deal with a problem they may not have even seen coming.

There's no such thing as underemployment insurance


Mary Webster (Photo Credit: Cristina King)
Mary Webster graduated from the University of Western Ontario in 1999 with a bachelor of arts in media information. Every year, she needed student aid to make ends meet. Then she entered a post-graduate program at Fanshawe College – another year, and another loan. She finished it all in 2001. Six months after she left school, the first loan payment was due and the interest clock began to tick. Since she was earning below what the National Student Loans Service Centre considered a minimum income, she got some interest relief. When she eventually took an entry-level position with a small digital network, she started to feel like her education was finally paying off.

But the first thing to start being paid off was her student loan.

Over five years, Mary had received almost $20,000 in student loans. She was thankful for the help.

But now, she has to make almost $200 in monthly payments. And even then, her debt won't be paid off for 10 years. And she also owes $10,000 on another loan co-signed by her father.

It hasn't been easy. Mary's shiny new job nets only $1,800 per month.

With her loan payments, rent and utilities, she has almost $1,400 in monthly expenses. With the other $400, she must pay for transportation ($100), groceries ($150) and any other incidentals that may arise. And that same $400 is also supposed to be the source of personal savings, monthly contributions to an RRSP and spending money.

Saving for a down payment on a home isn't anywhere on her horizon.

"Sometimes I feel really positive about my future, but other times it feels bleak. I don't know how I'm going to do it, but I have to hope there will be some way."

Stuck in a rut

Andrea Wilson and her boyfriend are trying to kick-start a future together.

Working as a registered massage therapist, Andrea has spent the past two years building her clientele in Toronto. She's been successful and has established a reputation for herself in the field.

Andrea attended a private massage therapy school in London to get her qualifications – an education that cost her $15,000 a year for two years.

Now she has a $16,000 student loan to pay back to the government. And she's had difficulty dealing with the National Student Loans Service Centre. Her loan is now in arrears and the NSLSC has sent it to a collection agency.

She's understandably worried.

Her gross monthly income seems good – it hovers just over $2,500. But RMTs are self-employed, so out of that, she pays for supplies, rent, utilities, insurance, transportation and other expenses. She also has to make tax instalments.

Andrea's immediate future is foggy, but she tries to stay positive. "If I can make larger payments, I'm hoping that I can clean up my credit in order to qualify for a mortgage before I'm 32," she says.

Didn't education used to mean 'easy street'?

According to University of Toronto Financial Aid Services, 20 per cent of the university's undergrads leave school with debt levels exceeding $15,000. Two per cent had debt in excess of $30,000.

For these students, each year of education has cost between $9,000 and $16,000, depending on their program and whether or not they live at home. For those coming from families where money is tight, much of this expense has to be funded by loans.

Part of the problem is a lack of education during students' academic careers. They are encouraged to place emphasis on success in their studies, but they are given little, if any, financial counselling.

According to Andrea Wilson, "the woman who took care of the loans told you when instalments were coming and when the forms needed to be signed. I thought you had a year's grace to start paying. I didn't know about arrears. I had no idea how it was actually going to work."

Most schools do offer financial counselling for students who ask for it. But the basic process of getting a loan often involves only a line-up thick with other students, a flash of identification, a signature or two and a short wait for the cash to come rolling in. Before they can say "credit," their tuition is paid, as is their first month's rent. They may even have a new pair of shoes.

If the school year lasted a month, there would be nothing to worry about.


EXTERNAL LINKS:
CBC does not endorse and is not responsible for the content of external sites. Links will open in new window.

2004/2005 University Tuition Fee Survey – from Statistics Canada

Student Loan Estimator Calculator – from Human Resources and Skills Development (HRSDC)

Education Cost Calculator – from HRSDC

Student Budget Estimator Calculator – from HRSDC

Loan Repayment Calculator – from HRSDC

Edulinx Canada

National Student Loans Service Centre

Lifelong Learning Plan – from Canada Revenue Agency

Canada Student Loans – from The Canadian Federation of Students

CanadaStudentDebt.ca

Consumer Tips on Collection Agencies – from Industry Canada





^TOP
MENU


TAXES: TAX SOFTWARE
SOCIAL PROGRAMS: CLAWBACKS
DEBT: PAYDAY LOANS CANADIANS AND DEBT CREDIT CARDS PROFILES OF STRUGGLE DEALING WITH DEBT DEBT HELP CHECKING YOUR RATING
INVESTMENTS: EXCHANGE-TRADED FUNDS LABOUR-SPONSORED INVESTMENT FUNDS: FAQs CANADA SAVINGS BONDS INCOME TRUSTS: FAQs
STOCK MARKETS: BULLS AND BEARS THE TSX VS. THE DOW NORTEL
RELATED: RRSPs

EXTERNAL LINKS:
CBC does not endorse and is not responsible for the content of external sites. Links will open in new window.

Canada Revenue Agency list of certified tax programs and web links

Canada Revenue Agency Netfile page

General income tax package - from Canada Revenue Agency

Toronto Stock Exchange

About the S&P/TSX Composite Index - from Standard & Poor’s

New York Stock Exchange

The Dow Jones Averages website

Morningstar Canada

Government of Ontario - LSIF Guide (PDF File)

Debt:

Financial Consumer Agency of Canada

Canadian Institute of Mortgage Brokers and Lenders

Mortgage Analyzer Calculator

Statistics Canada

Statistics Canada

Financial Consumer Agency of Canada

The Current State of Canadian Family Finances - from the Vanier Institute of the Family

Credit Counselling Canada

List of Credit Counselling Agencieis - from Credit Counselling Canada

Budget Planner - from Credit Counselling Services of Alberta

Information about bankruptcy - from Bankruptcy Canada.com

Personal Bankruptcy Predictor - from Bankruptcy Canada.com

Dealing with Debt: A Consumer's Guide - from the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy

Clawbacks external links:

Old Age Security program information

Guaranteed Income Supplement information

Employment Insurance information

Canada Child Tax Benefit information

The National Child Benefit Supplement Charter Challenge - from the Income Security Advocacy Centre

Sharing Your Pension - from Social Development Canada

C.D. Howe Institute - "New Poverty Traps: Means-Testing and Modest-Income Seniors" [pdf format]

MORE:
Print this page

Send a comment

Indepth Index