Story Tools: PRINT | Text Size: S M L XL | REPORT TYPO | SEND YOUR FEEDBACK

In Depth

The 39th Parliament

Net debt, national debt. What's the difference?

Last Updated November 28, 2006

Finance Minister Jim Flaherty (Tom Hanson/Canadian Press)

When Finance Minister Jim Flaherty said that net debt would be eliminated within a generation in his November 2006 fiscal update, he left a lot of people scratching their heads. Journalists and pundits quickly looked at the massive $480 billion national debt and wondered how it could be whittled down to zero in 15 years, representing payments of more than $30 billion a year.

Was this voodoo math or fiscal magic?

What is net debt?

Net debt is a measure used by the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), though not a very well-known one. Net debt takes a measure of Canada's total financial liabilities and subtracts assets of the government.

The federal government promise, therefore, includes its own debt ($481 billion) and the debt of the provinces, territories and local governments, but also includes assets, such as the massive Canada Pension Plan, which has more than $100 billion in assets.

It's the inclusion of Canada's enormous pension funds such as the CPP that has critics questioning why the government is trumpeting the elimination of net debt as the measure of a healthy economy. The CPP's assets are forecast to grow over the next 15 years as it builds up to deal with the aging population. After 2021, the year Flaherty has targeted to eliminate net, the pension plan will see benefit payments exceed its contributions for the first time, as a large number of Canadians cash in their pensions.

Net debt or net financial liabilities (OCED, November 2006)
Year OECD net debt to GDP ratio
2000 46.6%
2001 42.8%
2002 41%
2003 35.3%
2004 31.1%
2005 26.3%
2006 20%
2007 14.9%

Then there are critics, like Liberal MP John McCallum, a former bank economist, who call net debt "an arcane statistic."

In the fiscal update, the government said its OECD-defined net debt had fallen to 30.2 per cent as a percentage of gross domestic product in 2005, compared with a 52.7 per cent for other OECD countries. Days after the fiscal update was released, the OECD released even rosier numbers, saying Canada's net debt was actually 26.3 per cent in 2005 and is forecast to drop to 14.9 per cent in 2007.

The finance minister noted that the government would not be doing anything new to reduce the debt other than follow its plan to pay $3 billion a year. But it also handed down two qualifications: "if provincial-territorial governments maintain balanced budgets and the Canada Pension Plan/Quebec Pension Plan continue to build assets as currently projected." The 2021 target to eliminate net debt has a lot to do with factors Ottawa can't control.

"This is almost a way of bragging a bit without really changing what they planned to do," said Doug Porter, a senior economist with BMO Financial, to Canadian Press.

How else can you look at debt?

There are many measures of debt. One that's in use, and published annually by Statistics Canada, is called the consolidated net financial debt.

This measure takes in financial accounts of all levels of government "to yield aggregate unduplicated financial statistics."

According to this measure of debt, in 2004, consolidated debt was at $798.4. More telling is perhaps the per cent of debt-to-GDP ratio, which in 2004 was at 63.7 per cent. In recent years, the consolidated debt has been dropping.

Consolidated net financial debt (Statistics Canada, April 2006)
Year Consolidated debt GDP
2000 $832.7 billion 79.9%
2000 $832.7 billion 79.9%
2001 $800.3 billion 71.8%
2002 $796.7 billion 71.2%
2003 $794.5 billion 65.5%
2004 $798.3 billion 63.7%

What about national debt?

Most people are familiar with the national debt, which in 2006 stood at $481 billion. This measure is well known to Canadians, as the debt level is published often, and the government has been heralding how it has dramatically lowered the debt-to-GDP ratio since it started turning out surpluses in the mid-1990s.

This number is easier to understand, especially when it can be seen how surpluses (or, on the other hand, deficits) affect the national debt. So when the government posted a surplus of $13.2 billion in 2005-06, it was able to pay down the national debt by the same amount.

One pledge that Flaherty did make during his fiscal update was to reduce its debt-to-GDP ratio to 25 per cent by 2012-13. If achieved, it would be one year faster than the Liberals under Paul Martin had forecast. But it can also be pointed out that the government is merely on the same road that Martin put the country on while he was finance minister.

The national debt
Year National debt Debt to GDP ratio Surplus/Deficit
1996-97 $562.88 billion 67.3% -$8.7 billion
1997-98 $559.92 billion 63.4% $2.9 billion
1998-99 $554.14 billion 60.6% $5.7 billion
1999-00 $539.89 billion 55% $14.2 billion
2000-01 $519.99 billion 48.3% $19.9 billion
2001-02 $511.95 billion 46.2% $8 billion
2002-03 $505.33 billion 43.8% $6.6 billion
2003-04 $496.18 billion 40.9% $9.1 billion
2004-05 $494.72 billion 38.3% $1.5 billion
2005-06 $481.50 billion 35.1% $13.2 billion

So with all these different measures, what's the bottom line? For one thing, all three measures — while revealing different aspects of Canada's balance sheet — do show a trend of falling debt and debt ratios.

The Dominion Bond Rating Service credit rating agency, which said some of the projections on net debt were overly optimistic, still noted that Canada's economic picture looked good.

"Adherence to these initiatives [in the fiscal update] will support further improvement in the already solid credit profile of the government," the agency said, but added one qualification: "Benefits will take years to materialize."

Debt ratios stacked up
Year Net debt Consolidated debt National debt
2000 46.6% 79.9% 48.3%
2004 31.1% 63.7% 38.3%

Go to the Top

[an error occurred while processing this directive]
Story Tools: PRINT | Text Size: S M L XL | REPORT TYPO | SEND YOUR FEEDBACK

World »

updated UN Security Council blames Syrian regime for massacre video
The UN Security Council condemned the Syrian regime at an emergency meeting Sunday, holding president Bashar al-Assad's military responsible for the massacre of more than 100 people, dozens of whom were children younger than 10 years old.
Ryder Hesjedal wins prestigious Giro d'Italia video
Victoria, B.C., native Ryder Hesjedal has become the first Canadian to win one of the cycling world's three Grand Tour events, wrapping up the 2012 Giro d'Italia with an excellent performance in the final stage in Milan.
IMF chief blasted for chastising Greeks on tax evasion
International Monetary Fund chief Christine Lagarde is backtracking from recent remarks that she has more sympathy for poor African children than Greeks suffering under the country's economic problems and austerity measures.
more »

Canada »

Quebec students, government to resume talks video
Quebec's university student federation has confirmed negotiations between student leaders and the provincial government will resume Monday afternoon.
updated CP Rail negotiations stalled, union says video
Negotiations between Canadian Pacific Railway Lt. and the union representing 4,800 striking locomotive engineers and conductors have come to a "stall" after the government-appointed mediator walked out at 2 p.m. ET, a union spokesman says.
updated Man charged in blast that killed Alberta mom
Police make an arrest in the Innisfail explosion that killed a disabled mother.
more »

Politics »

updated CP Rail negotiations stalled, union says video
Negotiations between Canadian Pacific Railway Lt. and the union representing 4,800 striking locomotive engineers and conductors have come to a "stall" after the government-appointed mediator walked out at 2 p.m. ET, a union spokesman says.
Western premiers to talk environment, energy and Tom Mulcair
The environment, energy and federal NDP Leader Tom Mulcair are on the agenda Tuesday when leaders of the western provinces and territories get together.
N.L. premier 'at odds' with Peter MacKay audio
Kathy Dunderdale, the premier of Newfoundland and Labrador, tells CBC Radio's Evan Solomon she's growing increasingly 'at odds' with Conservative MP Peter MacKay.
more »

Health »

Chronic fatigue may be reversed with exercise
Taking it easy is not the best treatment for chronic fatigue syndrome, rather exercise and behaviour therapy are, a large study finds.
AT&T buys T-Mobile USA for $39B US
AT&T Inc. said Sunday it will buy T-Mobile USA from Deutsche Telekom AG in a cash-and-stock deal valued at $39 billion US, becoming the largest cellphone company in the U.S.
Milky Way home to 50 billion planets: NASA
Scientists have compiled the first cosmic census of planets in our galaxy: at least 50 billion planets are estimated to call the Milky Way home.
more »

Arts & Entertainment»

Love film a 2nd win for Cannes director
Michael Haneke won the Cannes Film Festival's top trophy for a second time with his film about love and death, Amour.
Quebec actress captures Cannes prize
Canadian Suzanne Clement has been awarded the Best Actress prize in the Cannes Film Festival's sidebar competition, Un Certain Regard.
Lady Gaga nixes Indonesia show after threats
Lady Gaga cancelled her sold-out show in Indonesia after Islamist hard-liners threatened violence, claiming her sexy clothes and provocative dance moves would corrupt the youth.
more »

Technology & Science »

Astronauts enter world's 1st private supply ship video
Astronauts have entered the Dragon, the world's first commercial supply ship, which is docked at the International Space Station.
South Africa, Australia to share world's largest telescope
South Africa and Australia will jointly host the Square Kilometre Array, which promises to be the world's largest telescope, the international consortium in charge of the project said Friday.
Bonavista, N.L., 'coyote' was really wolf, tests confirm
Wolves have not been seen in Newfoundland since around 1930 and were believed to have been hunted to extinction on the island, but genetic tests have confirmed that an 82-pound animal shot on the Bonavista Peninsula in March was, in fact, a wolf.
more »

Money »

analysis What a Greek euro exit could mean for Canada
A tumultuous Greek exit from the eurozone would have a harder impact on Canada's economy than the credit crisis recession of 2008 and 2009, a report from a major Canadian bank warns.
Bankia asks Spain for €19B video
The board of directors of Spain's troubled bank, Bankia, has asked the Spanish government for €19 billion ($24.5 billion Cdn) in financial support.
EI reforms aim to boost employment, Flaherty says
Finance Minister Jim Flaherty defended his government's proposals to change employment insurance, saying the aim is to remove "disincentives to employment."
more »

Consumer Life »

Honda recalls Fit subcompacts
Honda Canada says it will recall 14,640 of its 2009 and 2010 Fit subcompact cars to replace lost motion springs.
U.S. travel fee proposal criticized by Harper
Prime Minister Stephen Harper says he doesn't think much of a new border tax that's being proposed by the United States, calling it a cash grab designed to help a budget crisis.
Bell class action suit approved by Que. court
A Quebec Superior Court judge has authorized a class action lawsuit to go ahead against Bell Mobility.
more »

Sports »

Scores: NHL NBA

Ryder Hesjedal wins prestigious Giro d'Italia video
Victoria, B.C., native Ryder Hesjedal has become the first Canadian to win one of the cycling world's three Grand Tour events, wrapping up the 2012 Giro d'Italia with an excellent performance in the final stage in Milan.
Franchitti wins in wild finish at Indy 500
Dario Franchitti has won the Indianapolis for the third time, taking advantage when Takuma Sato crashed on the final lap.
Stanley Cup final: The most intriguing people
Here are a dozen intriguing individuals to get to know as the Los Angeles Kings and New Jersey Devils prepare to meet in the championship series opener in Newark on Wednesday.
more »

Diversions »

[an error occurred while processing this directive]
more »