Story Tools: PRINT | Text Size: S M L XL | REPORT TYPO | SEND YOUR FEEDBACK

In Depth

Middle East in Crisis

Ehud Olmert's gamble

Last Updated July 17, 2006

Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon, left, and Vice-Premier Ehud Olmert attend a ceremony at the prime minister's office in Jerusalem on Wednesday, Jan. 4, 2006. At the time, Sharon was expected to briefly hand over power to Olmert during a medical procedure to seal a small hole in his heart. Hours later, Sharon suffered a major stroke. (Eliana Aponte/Associated Press)

Four months ago Ehud Olmert won his first general election, largely on the promise of withdrawing Jewish settlements from disputed lands in Gaza and parts of the West Bank and consolidating Israel's borders behind its imposing steel and concrete security barrier.

That was then. Now, in the space of two short weeks, Israel's new prime minister finds himself heading a government that is back to fighting a war in two territories it had previously abandoned, Gaza and southern Lebanon. In the past both proved to be political and military quagmires that sapped Israel's strength for long periods and undermined its standing in the international community.

In this case, there is little doubt Israel was provoked into action. On June 25, Hamas militants tunnelled under the Gaza border into Israel, killed two Israeli soldiers at a border post and took a third, Cpl. Gilad Shalit, hostage. They later offered to trade him for some of the estimated 9,000 Palestinians in Israeli jails.

Then, on July 12, Hezbollah militia in southern Lebanon crossed into Israel and attacked a military convoy, killing seven soldiers and taking two others, Ehud Goldwasser and Eldad Regey, hostage. They, too, are being held in trade for Lebanese militants in Israeli jails.

Both actions, direct violations of a country's borders, were egregious breaches of international law, and Israel promptly declared them akin to a declaration of war and responded with punishing ferocity.

In Gaza, Israeli planes and tanks destroyed roads, bridges and power supplies, while its soldiers arrested a number (some say a third) of Hamas legislators and attacked a series of suspected safe houses.

In Lebanon, Beirut's harbour was sealed by Israeli gunships, and the runways at the airport and the main roads out of town were blown up, allowing Israeli troops to tighten their noose on the southern suburbs of Beirut where Hezbollah is said to enjoy the most support.

World opinion divided

The boldness of the Israeli attack can be seen as part of its long-held policy of punishing retribution. Nonetheless it appears to have strongly divided the international community. The U.S. supports Israel's actions, as does Canada's Conservative government, though Washington is fretting about the destabilization of Lebanon's fragile democracy, newly emerged from Syrian control.

The European Union, on the other hand, denounced Israel's "disproportionate" use of force and the UN has set up a fact-finding and mediation team. Meeting in Russia for their annual summit, the G8 leaders issued a statement blaming the extremist Arab groups for the conflict, while calling on Israel to halt its military incursions into Gaza and Lebanon.

By most estimates, at least 80 Palestinians were killed in the two weeks of Gaza assaults, and at least twice that number died in the first five days of fighting in Lebanon.

Israel's harsh response has raised questions within the country and elsewhere as to whether this is a strategic blunder by the new Olmert government or a calculated risk to take out its Hamas foes, as well as Hezbollah, which has been amassing new Iranian-supplied rockets near Israel's northern border. (Two Israelis were killed and more than 40 wounded in Hezbollah rocket attacks on the town of Dweir. Eight Israeli workers were killed in a rocket attack on the northern city of Haifa.)

For months now, since the surprise election in January that enabled it to control the Palestinian legislature, Hamas has been under huge pressure from Israel and most of the international community (including Canada) to moderate its extreme views regarding Israel, return to peace talks and recognize the Jewish state.

Not much has happened on that front. But after the Israeli pullout from Gaza, a consensus appears to have emerged among ordinary Palestinians that Israel must release at least some of the many Arab prisoners it holds, according to news reports from the region. That same sentiment among Lebanese families who wanted their loved ones back may also be what pushed Hezbollah into action (though more cynical motives cannot be discounted).

If that's the case, there may have been huge miscalculations on all sides. After Hamas militants captured Cpl. Shalit, Olmert took a hard line and refused to entertain any kind of negotiation or trade. This even though Israel has negotiated prisoner releases in the past, and even though Hamas seemed to be trying to make this notion politically palatable by asking first for the release of women and boys under 18.

But if Olmert was having second thoughts about negotiating, that option was probably foreclosed after Hezbollah struck. Having taken a hard line with Hamas over what might have been a containable incident in Gaza, Olmert was probably forced to do no less when Hezbollah broadened the conflict considerably.

Who is Ehud Olmert?

Not well known outside Israel, the 60-year-old Olmert is a lifelong politician who was first elected to the Knesset at 28. He officially became prime minister in April but had been the acting PM since January when his mentor Ariel Sharon, one of the giants of Israeli politics, suffered a massive stroke and was incapacitated.

Olmert, though, is no Sharon, the former general whose legend was larger than life on both sides of the Israeli-Arab divide. Olmert's political career has been spent more on the domestic side of Jewish politics. A lawyer, he is a former finance minister and minister of trade and development. He spent two terms (1993-2003) as mayor of Jerusalem, concentrating on development and transit issues.

His military training, especially when compared with almost every other Israeli leader, has been brief. He was injured during his compulsory military service and released early. He completed his military duties as a journalist for the armed forces magazine and was a military correspondent during the Yom Kippur War in 1973.

Politically, he did an about-face, like Sharon, and went from refusing to give up Jewish settlements in certain occupied territories to withdrawing from them in the pursuit of land for peace. But perhaps because he did not have Sharon's stature as a military tough-guy, he felt he couldn't afford to negotiate with hostage takers, especially this early in his regime.

Just two years ago, Sharon authorized the release of 420 Palestinian and Lebanese prisoners in exchange for a captured Israeli businessman and the bodies of three soldiers who had been killed much earlier.

Peace activists have encouraged Olmert to make a similar deal now, noting that the previous exchange did not appear to harm Sharon's electoral chances. But that earlier transaction reverberated, often harshly, through the Israeli media for months, especially when it turned out the businessman had been in Dubai to discuss a drug deal, which he later admitted to in a plea bargain in an Israeli court.

Tightening the noose

Militarily, the Israeli actions in Gaza and Lebanon seem to be similarly designed. In both cases, air and artillery attacks were first unleashed to cut transportation routes and cordon off key areas so the Israeli hostages could not be moved out of the region. The army is now moving in to tighten the noose.

The problem with this kind of manoeuvre is the civilians killed in bombardments or cut off from supplies, water especially in the case of Gaza, in the heat of summer.

Israel at this point seems determined to prevent its captured soldiers from being whisked out of the country to either Syria or Iran, where the potential exists for a much broader international incident that might drag in the U.S.

Even French President Jacques Chirac, who strongly criticized Israel's foray into Lebanon, musing whether it was designed to destroy the Lebanese regime, seemed to imply that Syria and Iran, which both back Hezbollah, were behind the hostage taking.

"I have the feeling, if not the conviction, that Hamas and Hezbollah wouldn't have taken the initiatives alone," Chirac told the Associated Press.

Meanwhile, Jan Egeland, the top U.N. humanitarian official, said the Israeli blockade of Lebanon's borders and seaports meant civilians and children "cannot get their daily needs met." He was also sharply critical of Hezbollah and Hamas but called Israel's military reaction excessive.

"It is in violation of international law, and it is also in violation of common sense," he said at the UN's European headquarters in Geneva. "You are supposed to do something to the armed group. You are not supposed to hurt the children of people who have nothing to do with this."

Go to the Top

RELATED

Reports from Abroad

Mideast Dispatches
CBC's foreign correspondents report from the field

Photo Galleries

The children of war
Getting out
Leaving Beirut
Brink of war
Escalating tension

Video

Brian Stewart reports on the diminshed role of the U.S. (Runs: 10:19)
July 25, 2006

In Depth

When is a war a War?
Robert Sheppard, Reality Check
Intentionally or not, Harper took sides
John Gray, Reality Check
Middle East
Dual citizenship

Viewpoint

As the world shrugs
Jim Reed
Escape from Beirut
Zoë Horn
A Letter from Tel Aviv
Signe Katz
Harper's Mideast policy
Larry Zolf

Quick Facts

  • Israel and Lebanon have never signed a peace deal.
  • In 1969, Lebanon signed a deal that allowed Palestinian guerrillas access to southern Lebanon.
  • In 1978, Israel invaded Lebanon.
  • In 1982, Israel invaded again on a wider scale in an attempt to destroy the Palestine Liberation Organization.
  • In May 2000, Israel pulled out of Lebanon.
[an error occurred while processing this directive]
Story Tools: PRINT | Text Size: S M L XL | REPORT TYPO | SEND YOUR FEEDBACK

World »

Afghan avalanches kill 157 people
At least 157 people have been killed in a series of avalanches that blocked a mountain pass north of Kabul, trapping hundreds more in their snowbound vehicles, Afghan officials said Wednesday.
Sri Lankan parliament dissolved
Sri Lankan president Mahinda Rajapaksa has dissolved parliament, setting the stage for new elections a day after authorities arrested Gen. Sarath Fonseka, his chief rival and the leader of the opposition.
Haitian man pulled from rubble Video
A 28-year-old man has been pulled from rubble in Port-au-Prince, Haiti, claiming to have been trapped there since the massive earthquake on Jan. 12.
more »

Canada »

Health costs push Alberta budget deficit to $4.75B Video
Alberta's Progressive Conservative government is projecting a record $4.75-billion budget deficit and planning cuts in many departments while increasing health-care spending.
Trenton colonel's charges spur cold case review Video
The 2001 slaying of a Nova Scotia woman at CFB Trenton in eastern Ontario is among the cases being re-examined after murder charges were laid against Col. Russell Williams.
Neighbours stunned by arrest of Col. Williams
Ottawa resident Michael Gennis was stunned when he found out his new neighbour, Col. Russell Williams, had been charged with killing two women in eastern Ontario.
more »

Politics »

Tories need plan for isotope shortage: Ignatieff
Liberal Leader Michael Ignatieff accused the Conservative government of having no plan of action to deal with a medical isotope shortage expected to worsen later this month.
Ottawa to appeal injection site ruling Video
The federal government is asking the Supreme Court of Canada for leave to appeal a lower court ruling that sanctioned Vancouver's supervised drug injection site.
Montreal inventor unveils 3-D baggage scanner Video
A Montreal inventor has developed a three-dimensional baggage scanner that he says can make air travel safer and more convenient for passengers.
more »

Health »

Ottawa to appeal injection site ruling Video
The federal government is asking the Supreme Court of Canada for leave to appeal a lower court ruling that sanctioned Vancouver's supervised drug injection site.
Antidepressant interferes with breast-cancer drug
Women taking the breast cancer drug tamoxifen should avoid taking the antidepressant Paxil because the antidepressant may cancel out the benefits of the cancer treatment, researchers say.
Obamas aim to improve kids' health, fitness
A nationwide campaign to combat childhood obesity was launched Tuesday by U.S. President Barack Obama and his wife Michelle.
more »

Arts & Entertainment»

Perez Hilton, Black Eyed Peas manager settle
A civil lawsuit stemming from a scuffle between outrageous celebrity blogger Perez Hilton and a manager for the Black Eyed Peas has been dropped.
Winners, losers emerge in native art deal Audio
When Vancouver was granted the Olympics, the organizing committee struck a formal partnership with four First Nations who claim the lands where the Games are to be held and spoke of showcasing native culture to the world. But some native people say the promise of jobs, training, and business opportunities for aboriginals is proving empty.
Halifax concert raises $270K for Haiti
Thousands of people packed the Halifax Metro Centre Monday night to raise hundreds of thousands of dollars to help the people of earthquake-devastated Haiti.
more »

Technology & Science »

Google adds social media to Gmail
Google is introducing Buzz, a group of features that add Facebook and Twitter-like functionality to Gmail.
Montreal inventor unveils 3-D baggage scanner Video
A Montreal inventor has developed a three-dimensional baggage scanner that he says can make air travel safer and more convenient for passengers.
Tech buying bounces back in 2009: NPD
Canadians spent $4.66 billion on computer and information technology products in 2009, up one per cent from 2008.
more »

Money »

Health costs push Alberta budget deficit to $4.75B Video
Alberta's Progressive Conservative government is projecting a record $4.75-billion budget deficit and planning cuts in many departments while increasing health-care spending.
Honda recalls 378,000 cars for airbag defect
Honda Motor Co. is adding more than 378,000 cars to a safety recall for airbag inflation problems.
Toyota recall spreads to Prius and beyond Video
Toyota is recalling 437,000 Prius and other hybrid cars worldwide to fix brake problems — the latest embarrassing safety defect for the world's largest automaker.
more »

Consumer Life »

Tim Hortons defends customer ban
Tim Hortons is defending a New Brunswick store owner's decision to ban a customer who complained repeatedly about its decaffeinated coffee.
500,000 cribs recalled in U.S.
Government safety officials in the U.S. have announced a recall of more than 500,000 drop-side cribs sold at Buy Buy Baby, Kmart, Wal-Mart and other stores after the death of three infants.
Montreal inventor unveils 3-D baggage scanner Video
A Montreal inventor has developed a three-dimensional baggage scanner that he says can make air travel safer and more convenient for passengers.
more »

Sports »

Scores: NHL NBA

Senators keep marching with win over Flames
The Ottawa Senators notched their 12th win in the last 13 games with a 3-2 come-from-behind win over the visiting Calgary Flames on Tuesday.
Canucks struck down by Lightning
Martin St. Louis had two goals and one assist as the Tampa Bay Lightning beat the Vancouver Canucks 3-1 on Tuesday night.
B.C. Lions owner Braley buys Argonauts
Toronto Argonauts co-owners David Cynamon and Howard Sokolowski have completed an agreement to sell the franchise to B.C. Lions owner David Braley.
more »