CBC In Depth
INDEPTH: SPONSORSHIP SCANDAL
Gomery report: Highlights
CBC News Online | November 1, 2005


The following points are just a few of the more notable findings made by Justice Gomery in his report entitled "Who is Responsible?"


  • The Prime Minister's Office, via Jean Pelletier, and then-minister of public works, Alfonso Gagliano, directed the awarding of contracts through the Sponsorship Program – bypassing normal departmental oversight.

  • Pelletier essentially acted as an un-elected "minister" in implementing the Sponsorship Program.

  • Pelletier failed to take even "the most elementary precautions against mismanagement" of the disbursement of the millions of dollars in the Sponsorship Program.

  • Jean Chrétien holds personal responsibility for the actions of Jean Pelletier, his long-time chief of staff, because he was employed as a political aide.

  • Jean Chrétien ignored advice from the Privy Council Office that it would be prudent to transfer the sponsorship program to a department or let PCO run it.

  • Jean Chrétien and Jean Pelletier are both to blame for the mismanagement of taxpayer money resulting from a program that was set up without proper oversight and had no clearly articulated objectives.

  • Chuck Guité, the former bureaucrat who administered the Sponsorship Program, operated outside the normal structures of government accountability, reporting directly to Pelletier and Gagliano, and not to his immediate superiors nor to the departmental deputy minister, Ranald Quail.

  • Gomery called Guité "untouchable," because of the direct involvement of Pelletier, Chrétien's chief of staff.

  • Guité rewarded friends and Liberal-friendly ad firms with lucrative contracts, in some cases for little or no work.

  • Paul Martin, finance minister at the time, is exonerated "from any blame for carelessness or misconduct."

  • Gomery found that a kickback scheme existed. Jacques Corriveau, a close friend of Chrétien who owned a graphic design company, was "the central figure in an elaborate kickback scheme by which he enriched himself personally and provided funds and benefits to the [Quebec wing of the Liberal Party of Canada]."

  • Gomery infers that Gagliano must have known about the kickback scheme, but didn't find any evidence directly proving that inference. Gomery doesn't draw any connection between these kickbacks and the Prime Minister's Office. However, although they didn't know about the kickbacks, Gomery says that Chrétien and Pelletier can be held responsible because the program was not set up with the proper oversight.


    ^TOP
  • MENU

    MAIN PAGE TIMELINE OF RECENT EVENTS
    GOMERY REPORT: PHASE TWO RESTORING ACCOUNTABILITY HIGHLIGHTS FAQs FULL REPORT REACTION QUOTES
    GOMERY REPORT: PHASE ONE FULL REPORT MAJOR FINDINGS HIGHLIGHTS WHO KNEW WHAT REACTION KEY QUOTES ANALYSIS: Liberals' worst fears ANALYSIS: How did it go so wrong? MONTREAL REACTS: Tracey Madigan's Online Diary
    GALLERIES: Who's who photo gallery Cartoon gallery: Phase One report Cartoon gallery: Auditor general's report
    GOMERY INQUIRY: Gomery: The players Gomery: Key Companies Gomery by the numbers A summary of the testimony Testimony 2004 Follow the money Kroll report (pdf)
    PLEA TO THE NATION: Paul Martin's televised address Stephen Harper's response Jack Layton's response Gilles Duceppe's response (RealVideo runs 5:59)
    KEY WITNESSES:
    CHUCK GUITÉ 'Not all my fault' From bureaucrat to lobbyist 'No phoney invoices'
    PAUL COFFIN 'Phoney invoices'
    JACQUES CORRIVEAU: At the centre of the storm
    ALAIN RENAUD: Lobbyist extraordinaire
    JEAN BRAULT: Cash for contracts Paper trail
    PAUL MARTIN: Not in the sponsorship loop
    JEAN CHRETIEN: Economics and golf balls Editorial reviews
    VIEWPOINT: Rex Murphy: Sell the Peace Tower to Wal-Mart? Ira Basen: Watergate, the sponsorship scandal and the press
    HISTORY: Ad firms and liberals In their own words
    RELATED: The top 10 Canadian government scandals Public inquiries Auditor General's report 2004 Jean Chrétien Paul Martin

    EXTERNAL LINKS:
    CBC does not endorse and is not responsible for the content of external sites. Links will open in new window.

    Gomery Inquiry into the Sponsorship Program

    Public Works internal audit on sponsorship program, August 2000 [PDF file]

    MORE:
    Print this page

    Send a comment

    Indepth Index