CBC In Depth
INDEPTH: DISASTER IN ASIA
Tsunami orphans
CBC News Online | Jan. 7, 2004


Jagan, center, listens to his guardian as he sits along with other children at a newly opened orphanage for children at Sikkal, in the southern Indian state of Tamil Nadu, Jan. 3, 2005. (AP Photo/Gurinder Osan)
The United Nations estimates the Dec. 26, 2004, tsunami has left more than five million people homeless, including about 1.5 million children, most of whom may be orphaned.

Since the disaster, adoption agencies around the world have been fielding phone calls from well-meaning families wanting to adopt a child from one of the countries hit.

Adoption experts say the best thing people can do is to donate money to causes that directly help the children. They say it's wrong to take a traumatized child away from the environment that they have grown up in.

"Adoptions, especially inter-country ones, are inappropriate during the emergency phase as children are better placed being cared for by their wider families and the communities they know," said the charity Save the Children in a statement released Jan. 6, 2005.

"The last thing they need to do is be rushed away to some foreign land," said Cory Barron of Children's Hope International, an American adoption agency. "We have to think of the child first."

The Canadian response


Children survivors sit outside their makeshift tent in the middle of the road in Banda Aceh, the capital of Aceh province, Dec. 31, 2004, in northwest Indonesia. (AP Photo/Bullit Marquez)
The Canadian government says it will expedite requests for reuniting individuals in the affected areas with family members living in Canada.

"If the person in the tsunami region has no family there, and only has family in Canada, then we will take action," announced Immigration Minister Judy Sgro at a news conference on Jan. 7, 2005. Sgro says immigration officials will examine applications on a case-by-case basis. Under the family class designation, spouses, brothers, sisters, nieces and nephews can be reunited with family in Canada.

Canadian immigration officials are already on the ground in Asia processing some of the people, fast-tracking their security and medical checks.

To help the process along, the Ontario government will be waiving fees on international adoptions of children orphaned by the disaster. Children's Services Minister Marie Bountrogianni said the province will scrap the $460 it charges for international adoptions involving relatives and $925 for non-relatives.

An estimated 600,000 people in the Toronto area have family in the tsunami region and many would be hard-pressed to come up with the fees on top of legal expenses.

Displaced children – what happens in the meantime

QUICK FACTS
The tsunami's impact on children:

  • Children will be experiencing an immense sense of loss and grief.
  • They will need to know what they feel is normal and that they're not going crazy.
  • They need to be with people they know and to feel as safe as possible.
  • They need to establish a daily routine as soon as possible to reduce their fears.
  • They should play with other children to have time away from their fears and allowed to have creative expression such as materials to draw.
  • Those separated from family members need to be registered as soon as possible and reunified quickly.
  • Putting children in a temporary care facility or an orphanage should be the last resort.

SOURCE: World Vision Canada

Aid groups on the ground are keeping their eyes out for children who may be separated or orphaned by the tsunami. Any child seen wandering is approached and asked about his/her situation.

"Our staff are trained to watch for this," Linda Tripp, vice-president for World Vision Canada, told CBC News Online. "In these situations, families tend to stick together so it's fairly easy to spot an errant child."

Tripp says her charity is setting up safe places for children; more than 20 are up and running in Indonesia. Children are allowed to play and since they're in a specific area, staff can make sure they get the water, food or vaccines they need.

"They have access to counselling and there are child-care workers, so they are taken care of emotionally and physically," says Tripp. World Vision workers are also taking notes on the children they come in contact with.

Eventually, the aid organizations will be co-ordinating a more formal process of cataloguing the children along with the United Nations.

Meanwhile, the UN children's fund UNICEF confirmed on Jan. 7, 2005, the first case of trafficking in children in the disaster zone. Officials say a four-year-old boy was taken from Banda Aceh, Indonesia, by a couple claiming to be his parents.

Counter-trafficking experts have been deployed in the tsunami-hit regions to raise awareness of the problem as aid agencies struggle to identify the children affected. The International Organization for Migration (IOM), a UN agency, estimates a quarter of a million people are trafficked through Southeast Asia annually. Many are exploited sexually or used for domestic labour.

Police guards have been posted at tsunami refugee camps in Indonesia to prevent the kidnapping of children by traffickers. UNICEF officials say criminal gangs are posing as aid workers or family friends to gain access to orphaned or displaced children.

These concerns have prompted the governments of Indonesia and Sri Lanka, the two hardest-hit countries, to forbid anyone from taking children under 16 out of the affected areas. Aid officials estimate more than 35,000 children have been orphaned in Indonesia and another 300 in Thailand, while in Sri Lanka, officials are attempting to count and identify children among the 800,000 people who have been displaced.

The disaster aside, most countries in the region have strict rules on international adoptions because of fears of sexual abuse or child slavery. Indonesia and Malaysia rarely allow non-Muslim adoptions. Both nations require prospective parents to live in the country for at least two years prior to adopting.

The U.S. State Department as well as several European countries, such as Germany, France and Italy, have ruled out the adoption of children from the tsunami zone, at least for the next several months. Franco Frattini, the European commissioner for justice and home affairs, said the European Union might make it easier for Europeans to become temporary foster parents for children in those areas.

"My proposal is to … allow young people from the areas hit by the tsunami to come to Europe, spend some months here and then go back home."

Whether the children end up with family members or with people who want to care for them, "they are marked for life," as one UNICEF official said.

EXTERNAL LINKS

Citizenship and Immigration Canada: international adoptions

Adoption Council of Canada

Family Helper: list of adoption agencies




^TOP
MENU

DISASTER IN ASIA: MAIN PAGE DEALING WITH THE CRISIS TSUNAMI FAQs NEWS ARCHIVE MAP: COUNTRIES HIT TSUNAMI'S PATH DEAD AND MISSING THE LUCKY ONES A FLICKER OF HOPE TSUNAMI WARNING SOUTH COAST DISASTER: Newfoundland's tsunami
HOW TO HELP: HELPING TSUNAMI VICTIMS FOLLOWING THE MONEY CANADA FOR ASIA BENEFIT CONCERT CONSUMER TIPS: Charities HOW CHARITIES SPEND TSUNAMI ORPHANS
SURVIVORS' STORIES: Laura and Jeremy Rowley Oliver van Straaten Monique Smith Craig Logan
PHOTO GALLERIES: A year of recovery Six months later Banda Aceh rebuilds Tsunami strikes Jan. 21: Eid al-Adha in Aceh Jan. 19: Sustenance and spirit Jan. 18 Back to school, back to the sea Jan. 14/12: Relief and recovery Jan. 6: Latest satellite images Jan. 11: Tsunami aftermath Jan. 10: Aid and rebuilding Jan. 7: Restoring health and hope Jan. 6: Relief and rebuilding Mourning the tsunami victims Calang: Ground zero Phuket in ruins Photos from Jan. 4 Photos from Jan. 3 Photos from Dec. 31 Photos from Dec. 30 Photos from Dec. 28/29 Photos from Dec. 26/27 Satellite images
INTERACTIVES: Return to Banda Aceh How Simeulue survived the tsunami (Flash) Banda Aceh hospital (Flash) Calang: Ground Zero (Flash) Interactive map (Flash) Asian disaster (from CP - requires Flash)
WEB RESOURCES: BLOGS
CBC ARCHIVES: CANADA'S EARTHQUAKES AND TSUNAMIS
RELATED: UNTOLD STORIES: the fifth estate DEBT RELIEF FAQS WORLD'S WORST NATURAL DISASTERS TSUNAMI EARTHQUAKES DART: Canada's rapid response team REFUGEES: Anatomy of a refugee camp [Flash]
VIEWPOINT: Tsunami Relief Effort: Oxfam Diaries Rex Murphy's Point of View Robin Rowland: Tsunami '64
VIDEO FEATURES: Craig Logan
(Real Video Runs 3:01)
Transcript of the Logan interview Paul Cougurier
(Real Video Runs 2:48)
Sonja Podstawskyj
(Real Video Runs 1:38)

AUDIO FEATURES: How does the media choose what pictures to show from the tsunami disaster? CBC Halifax host Don Connolly asks three experts (Real Audio Runs 13:20) Jason Doucette
(Real Audio Runs: 11:18)


EXTERNAL LINKS:
CBC does not endorse and is not responsible for the content of external sites. Links will open in new window.

Canadian International Development Agency

U.S. Geological Survey

Tsunami FAQs

International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies

MORE:
Print this page

Send a comment

Indepth Index