Yukon paper takes CBC to court over sources
CBC News
Posted: Mar 17, 2011 7:21 PM ET
Last Updated: Mar 17, 2011 7:21 PM ET
A CBC News reporter in Whitehorse is going to court next week to protect her sources from a Yukon newspaper, which wants the public broadcaster to reveal those sources.
Lawyers for the CBC and the Yukon News will appear before the Yukon Supreme Court in Whitehorse on Monday. (CBC) The Yukon News is asking the territorial Supreme Court to make the CBC reveal the identities of sources who spoke to reporter Nancy Thomson as part of an investigative series that aired in 2004.
Lawyers for the newspaper and the CBC will appear in a Whitehorse courtroom on Monday. The court could order Thomson to name her sources, and she could be found in contempt of court if she refuses.
"I'm completely stunned that one news organization would sue another news organization to reveal their sources," said Ivor Shapiro, a journalism professor at Ryerson University.
Shapiro, who teaches media law at the Toronto university, said he has never heard of a case like this before.
Prescription drug abuse probed
Thomson's 2004 report looked into drug abuse and other social problems in Watson Lake, a town of about 1,500 in southern Yukon.
Her investigation included interviews with 11 people who spoke on the condition of anonymity about the increased use of Tylenol 3 and other prescription drugs in town.
Thomson reported at the time that Watson Lake's sole doctor, Dr. Said Secerbegovic, was also the town's only pharmacist.
The CBC investigative series sparked a public discussion that went all the way to the territorial legislature.
The Yukon News wrote an editorial that praised Thomson's series and made its own claims about Secerbegovic and Yukon Premier Dennis Fentie, who is also the MLA for Watson Lake.
The newspaper was later sued by Secerbegovic for defamation.
Important principle, lawyer argues
As part of its defence, the Yukon News wants the CBC to reveal the identities of Thomson's original sources.
Edmonton-based media lawyer Fred Kozak, who is representing Thomson and the broadcaster, said he is not aware of any case like it in Canada or elsewhere.
"I am confident that all of the players involved — so both the plaintiff [and] the defendant, and their counsel and the court — recognize that this is an important principle, not only for Nancy Thomson but for journalists and reporters everywhere," Kozak said.
"It's the lifeblood of what they do. They gather information and they have to be able to offer some protection to people who are in vulnerable circumstances."
In a release, the group Canadian Journalists for Free Expression said it can be very difficult for journalists to produce investigative reports "if people fear their identities will be exposed if they blow the whistle on what they believe are wrongdoings."
"Although CBC News is not directly involved in this defamation case and its journalism has not been questioned, we note that protection of confidential sources is fundamental to freedom of the press and an important component of high-quality, independent journalism," said Jennifer McGuire, general manager and editor-in-chief of CBC News.
"We fully support our journalist Nancy Thomson, who has declined to provide her sources to lawyers for the Yukon News in this matter."
Share Tools
FILM REVIEW: Jack the Giant Slayer by Eli Glasner Mar. 3, 2013 10:40 AM Bryan Singer, a director known for his superhero cinema (including X-Men and Superman Returns), is injecting a dose of modern movie magic into the classic tale of Jack and the Beanstalk. Though Jack the Giant Slayer features a strong cast, the action adventure sacrifices story for spectacle, says Eli Glasner.
Top News Headlines
- Cardinals begin pre-conclave meetings amid scandal
- Cardinals from around the world gathered inside the Vatican for their first round of meetings before the conclave to elect the next pope, amid scandals inside and out of the Vatican and the continued reverberations of Benedict XVI's decision to retire. more »
- Dad gets $22,000 data roaming 'shock' from Fido
- A B.C. dad is accusing Rogers of price gouging, after his 11-year-old mistakenly racked up $22,000 worth of data charges on his father's phone, during a family trip to Mexico. more »
- Queen remains in hospital after overnight stay
- Queen Elizabeth remains in a London hospital for a second day because of an apparent stomach infection. more »
- Egypt's politician skewer, testing the limits of post-revolution satire
- Meet Egypt's Jon Stewart, a former heart surgeon turned late-night TV host whose biting satire has not endeared him to the country's political class. But, as Nahlah Ayed reports, comedian Bassem Youssef may be the revolution's real star. more »
- Quebec papal contender 'ready' but wary of media spotlight
- Quebec Cardinal Marc Ouellet, who is considered by some to be a leading contender for the Vatican's top post, tells CBC's Peter Mansbridge in an exclusive interview he knows he must be ready to become the next pope as cardinals prepare to select Benedict's successor. more »
Latest Arts & Entertainment News Headlines
- War Witch triumphs at Canadian Screen Awards gala
- War Witch swept away nearly all competition at the inaugural Canadian Screen Awards broadcast gala Sunday night, with the searing child soldier drama capturing best picture and nine other trophies, while TV favourites Flashpoint and Less Than Kind also earned further accolades.
more »
- The Miracles founder, Motown singer Bobby Rogers dies
- Bobby Rogers, a founding member of Motown group The Miracles and a collaborator with Smokey Robinson, has died. He was 73. more »
- Jack the Giant Slayer sacrifices story for spectacle
- X-Men director Bryan Singer injects modern movie magic into Jack the Giant Slayer, but despite a strong cast, the action adventure sacrifices story for spectacle, says Eli Glasner. more »
- Why an Oscar-winning visual effects firm has gone broke
- VFX veteran Scott Ross explains to Day 6's Brent Bambury what led to the dire state of the industry today, why even Life of Pi's Oscar-winning firm Rhythm & Hues can go broke and what visual effects artists must do to turn things around. more »
- Justin Bieber: 19 key moments as the pop star turns 19
- Friday is Justin Bieber's 19th birthday and he faces a watershed moment: transitioning from pop upstart to credible adult artist with appeal beyond teen girls. CBC looks at 19 moments of his remarkable career so far. more »
Q Blog
Rebecca Marino on tennis and depression Mar. 1, 2013 4:34 PM
CBC Books
The future of the book Mar. 1, 2013 4:16 PM Journalists Sean Prpick and Dave Redel explore the rise of e-books, social reading, and whether they'll fundamentally change the way we consume and share stories.
- Baby born HIV-positive apparently cured, say scientists
- Dad gets $22,000 data roaming 'shock' from Fido
- Quebec papal contender 'ready' but wary of media spotlight
- Body of man found in home where police officer was killed
- War Witch triumphs at Canadian Screen Awards gala
- Heavy snow blankets southern Alberta
- Florida sinkhole home mostly demolished
- Expectant NYC couple dies in car crash, baby delivered alive
- Iceland tests find meat pies contain no meat at all


