First Nations chiefs say comments on CBC website a forum for hate
Last Updated: Thursday, February 12, 2009 | 3:25 PM ET
CBC News
First Nations leaders in Manitoba are accusing the CBC of providing a forum for the expression of hatred on its website.
At a news conference Wednesday, the Southern Chiefs Organization asked Manitoba's Justice Department to investigate the CBC's Manitoba website.
The organization has been monitoring the websites of some of the major news outlets in the province for the past year and said it had found dozens of reader comments posted about news stories on the CBC that referred to aboriginal people as drunks, criminals or lazy.
"The world will always have racists and kooks and people who just don't know what they are talking about. But the CBC, by not enforcing its own policies, has provided them with a forum they can use to attack our people," Chief Morris Swan-Shannacappo said.
He said many of the comments he complained to CBC about were eventually removed, but he said it often took hours for the post to be taken down because the website relies on the public to draw attention to objectionable comments.
"Comments that should have never appeared have been posted again and again. These postings cannot be dismissed and they are certainly not accidental or unavoidable. CBC has provided a forum that allows for that expression of hatred," Swan-Shannacappo said.
He said the CBC is violating its own policy by allowing such comments to be posted.
MLA Steve Ashton, the province's acting attorney general, said his government supports the chiefs in their efforts to have the matter investigated. But he questioned whether the province has the jurisdiction to look into the complaint because the CBC is a Crown corporation.
In an eight-page news release issued Wednesday, the Southern Chiefs Organization documented many of the postings it found offensive, including comments related to the deaths of a child in a house fire, the deaths of a young aboriginal teen and several stories about First Nations involvement in land or development deals.
Hateful comments are made "under the anonymous cloak of a pseudonym or alias," the organization said in the release.
The CBC sets guidelines for posters, and advises them to remain civil and refrain from offensive or racist remarks.
The comments are moderated by an outside company, based in Manitoba. CBC gets more than 200,000 comments from readers a month and more than 10,000 comments a day when there is a contentious issue in the news.
A CBC spokesman said the corporation is working with the Southern Chiefs Organization in response to the complaints.
"What we said … was that having a comment section that sets up a forum providing, as we do, as free as possible exchange of views on any subject matter, brings with it risks," said Jeff Keay, head of media relations for the CBC.
"That said, we can probably do a better job of monitoring. It's something we're looking at doing."
There is a mechanism in place where people can report abuse and guidelines are in place to discourage unacceptable comments, but that doesn't mean objectionable postings won't still appear, Keay said.
"There is a lot of grey area on what is acceptable. There are certain subjects where that line gets crossed," he said.
Along with aboriginal issues, news items related to subjects such as abortion and the Middle East also provoke commentary by readers that falls into these grey areas, Keay said.
But Keay said CBC is reviewing its practices around commentary and considering everything from stricter guidelines on what is considered acceptable to preventing comments from being posted on some news stories.
"This is kind of a new world — all news organizations are struggling with this," he said.
Share Tools
- Spider-Man trailer: fresh take or more of the same?by Arts Online Feb. 7, 2012 5:15 PM Spider-Man? Yes. Amazing? Maybe. The first full-length trailer for The Amazing Spider-Man -- the reboot of the comic-turned-movie trilogy -- has been released. But considering the previous movie franchise ended a mere five years ago and that we've been bombarded with stories about the troubled Broadway musical adaptation since then, this reboot does beg the question: Do we really need to revisit Spider-Man?
Top News Headlines
- Whitney Houston death shows no signs of trauma
- Whitney Houston's life of glorious song and unnerving self-destruction apparently ended on Grammy weekend, but it could be weeks before investigators know exactly why she died. more »
- Greece cleans up after anti-austerity riots
- Firefighters douse smouldering buildings and cleanup crews sweep rubble from the streets of central Athens after a night of rioting during which lawmakers approved harsh new austerity measures. more »
- 5 unforgettable moments from the Grammy Awards
- Adele made a triumphant return after vocal chord surgery, Jennifer Hudson wowed the crowd with a moving tribute to Whitney Houston, and other key moments from Sunday night's show. more »
- Manitoba wants ER death lawsuit thrown out
- The Manitoba government is making a court bid Monday to quash a lawsuit by the family of Brian Sinclair, a homeless man who died after waiting 34 hours in a hospital emergency room in 2008. more »
Latest Arts & Entertainment News Headlines
- Whitney Houston death shows no signs of trauma
- Whitney Houston's life of glorious song and unnerving self-destruction apparently ended on Grammy weekend, but it could be weeks before investigators know exactly why she died. more »
- Britain's BAFTAs honours The Artist
- Silent movie The Artist dominated the British Academy Film awards, the U.K. equivalent of the Oscars, winning seven awards, including best picture. more »
- CBC digital music service launches today
- CBC is diving into the world of online music with the goal of providing listeners access to their favourite tunes, and a way to discover new artists and connect with fellow music fans. more »
- Whitney Houston's death sparks chorus of grief
- Regular music fans and superstar performers joined together in a chorus of grief upon hearing that Whitney Houston had died at age 48 on the eve of the Grammy Awards. more »
Q Blog
Enter our Six-Word Modern Love Story Contest! Feb. 13, 2012 10:50 AM The goal is simple: tell a full and rich modern love tale in just six words. Funny. Sad. Sexy. Or futuristic sexy, the kind with spaceships. Winners announced on Q's February 14th Modern Love special.
CBC Books
Watch: Sunshine Sketches of a Little Town Feb. 13, 2012 11:49 AM If you missed the CBC-TV adaption of Stephen Leacock's classic comedic story, don't fret! You can watch the entire show online here.
- 'Disgusting' court backlog may free hit and run accused
- Adele wins best album, best record Grammys
- Whitney Houston autopsy results withheld
- Quebec town 'heartbroken' after killing of woman, sisters
- Ice road closed after 2 incidents
- Greece cleans up after anti-austerity riots
- CBC digital music service launches
- Whitney Houston death shows no signs of trauma
- Manitoba man dies after falling off moving SUV


