The mouth that roars
British author Martin Amis defends his new book on 9/11
Last Updated: Monday, May 5, 2008 | 4:55 PM ET
By Andre Mayer, CBC News
Known mainly for his cutting satirical novels (including Money, London Fields and The Information), British author Martin Amis has turned social commentary into a profitable sideline. Whether he’s taking on the cinematic works of Brian De Palma, the cruel reign of Josef Stalin or his own family history, the 59-year-old British author is clever, pointed and unafraid to get up people’s noses.
His latest work requires little explanation. The Second Plane: September 11: Terror and Boredom collects his writings on this century’s galvanizing event and its explosive fallout. The volume includes his first response (in London’s Guardian newspaper on Sept. 18, 2001) and a 10,000-word essay on the futility of satire in “the age of horrorism,” as well as two short stories: one about Saddam Hussein’s torture palace and another entitled The Last Days of Mohammed Atta (about the man suspected of leading the Sept. 11 attacks).
Ever the provocateur, Amis has been dodging charges of racism after venting to a reporter in the summer of 2006. The quote in question: “There’s a definite urge – don't you have it? – to say, ‘The Muslim community will have to suffer until it gets its house in order.’ What sort of suffering? Not let them travel. Deportation, further down the road. Curtailing of freedoms. Strip-searching people who look like they're from the Middle East or Pakistan... Discriminatory stuff, until it hurts the whole community, and they start getting tough with their children.” Amis’s salvo inspired outrage in the British press. Suffice it to say, the release of The Second Plane has only emboldened his critics.
Though fierce in print, Amis gives a gracious, garrulous interview. Speaking to CBCNews.ca from his home in London, Amis discussed his evolving views on 9/11, the so-called Race Row and his dreams of a “multiracial” — not multicultural — society.
Q: What should readers take from The Second Plane?
A: It’s not different from any other kind of writing in that respect. You just want to stimulate and get people thinking. What I would stress is that there are no recommendations in that book. I’m unaffiliated; I don’t represent any bloc or party. In the political arena, that habit of assigning you those positions, and everything you say sends a signal to some other signal — I’m not used to that kind of discourse. All I hope to represent is an independent mind.
Q: In the essay “The Lonely Voice in the Crowd,” you examine the need of so many novelists to respond journalistically to Sept. 11. What were your own motivations for weighing in?
A: The answer I give in that essay is that they wrote about Sept. 11 because they couldn’t write about anything else. I adduced the Kafka story about Josephine, the opera-singing mouse. It’s a typical Kafka story: here’s a mouse who goes around doing concerts and singing opera. At the last concert she gives, someone turns around and says, ‘Sing? She can’t even squeak.’ I think a lot of novelists felt like that in the weeks after Sept. 11. It’s the measure of the event, that something of this weight and mass happens, and your confidence in your ability to contribute to anything is crushed. You have to wait for your fighting spirit to get going again. I talked to novelists about this, and they said, not only what they were writing but everything they’d written seemed, in that time, to have shrunk into miserable autism, really, and insignificance. I wanted to get going again, and not be like Josephine, and try and project a voice again.
Q: Reviews of The Second Plane have been largely unkind. Many have stated that the writing is stylish but lacking in original ideas. How do you respond to that?
A: I don’t see what’s so threatening about that. I cast myself as a non-expert, a novelist in the street. This is my contribution; the measure of it is whether it’s stimulating.
I felt a kind of license in writing about this in that I did think it called on habits of mine that had been groomed in me by writing fiction, and by writing satirical fiction. I don’t think it’s a very rational landscape, and I felt I could respond to it with certain tendencies in satire. Is the discourse so narrow that it can’t accommodate that?
Q: Have you sensed any difference in the reactions of American and British reviewers?
A: It’s mixed the picture up a bit. [The book] got pretty even-handed treatment here [in Britain], and it seems more fierce in America. I think there’s a fair bit of proprietoriality [in reviews by American critics]: this is our event, this is our territory, and we don’t want someone else wading in; our wounds are too tender for that.
The cover of Martin Amis's The Second Plane: September 11: Terror and Boredom. (Random House Canada) Q: In The Second Plane, you say that Islam is “totalist” — that it makes a total claim on a person’s existence. Isn’t that a generalization? Surely, there is nuance among the world’s one billion Muslims.
A: There’s every kind of nuance. But I think [Islam] distinguishes itself from the other monotheisms. As the Ayatollah Khomeini used to say — in scandalized terms — affiliates of other religions think that they can go to church once a week, or even pray once a day, and that’s that. He said, Islam isn’t like that. The whole wave of Islamism is the revival of the idea that Islamism is the total guide to existence, that it’s not on the edges but right in the centre. If you adhere to this literalist way, [Islam] does follow you into every room in the house. It’s without its grandeur and beauty if you deny this central severity.
Q: But you’re quoting the Ayatollah Khomeini, whose interpretation of Islam was clearly zealous and not representative of the entire faith.
A: Yeah, sure. I am talking about the fundamentalist wing, which is the one that has emerged. It’s in direct contravention of other schools of Islam. But we’re not hearing from Sufi Muslims; we’re hearing from Salafi Muslims.
Q: There’s been a great deal of controversy over your remarks about the Muslim community in the summer of 2006. Can you clarify what you meant?
A: I made those remarks preceded by the words “There’s an urge to say,” and on the day I said it, there was an urge to say it. I’m not a politician. I am not ashamed to have these ugly thoughts, which lasted 24 hours. And let me remind you of the context: it was just after the revelation of the third plot in 13 months to cause random death on British and American citizens, in this case with 10 transatlantic airliners.
I was chastened to see that these remarks set off, activated, certain revulsions. It was a stupid thing to say, an aggressive thing to say, but I didn’t advocate it. I just came out with it. Nabokov, in one of his essays, says, “I think like a genius; I write like a distinguished man of letters; and I talk like an idiot.” I’ve written in praise of the multiracial society on many occasions.
I’ve always been a passionate multiracialist; what I’ve never been is a passionate multiculturalist. I don’t think anyone really is. If you recast any of the arguments we’ve been having as feminist questions, no one thinks that female circumcision or nine-year-old brides or honour killing is something we can feel good about. One of the brave things that Barack Obama has said is that female circumcision is not something that any civilized country can tolerate.
Q: Non-believers like Christopher Hitchens and yourself stress that the majority of Muslims are peace loving. At the same time, you dismiss all people of faith as inherently irrational. If I were a Muslim, I’d be confused, and not a little offended.
A: It sounds like a simple-minded view, but individuals are on the whole very manageable. It’s conglomerates of individuals that give us the world’s ills. Part of [Islam] has been taken over by an ideology. It’s an ideology grafted onto a religion; it’s two-ply. It’s a feeling of mine that an ideology is always going to be violent; religion not at all, necessarily. When you commit yourself to a total system of belief, a system that will answer all questions — which, when you think about it, no system can do — once you make that leap, it feels very empowering, because you’re with the like-minded. But it will always tend to be violent. When the orthodoxy is challenged, it can’t defend it with mind alone, because there’s such a commitment to the irrational. The response is always likely to be glandular. It’s always likely to include body heat, because you need the body to defend, because you can’t do it with mind alone.
The Second Plane is published by Random House and is in stores now.
Andre Mayer writes about the arts for CBCNews.ca.
- Jedward on the MMVA red carpet by Laura Thompson Jun. 17, 2013 12:48 PM Cheerful pop duo Jedward had much to say to CBC News on the red carpet Sunday night at the Much Music Video Awards in Toronto. A lot of their excitement came from seeing Avril Lavigne, complete with spiky hairband. Check out the Irish twins in this video clip.
Top News Headlines
- Obesity now recognized as a disease
- The American Medical Association has voted to recognize obesity as a disease, while doctors in Canada say they also treat it as such. more »
- B.C. First Nation sets fires to save bison
- A First Nation band is reviving the age-old practice of controlled burning in order to improve the health of forests and restore the population of the wood bison in a corner of northeastern B.C. more »
- 1 in 8 bird species threatened with extinction
- One in eight bird species worldwide faces the threat of extinction, according to a report released by Birdlife International. more »
- Canada buys rare War of 1812 collection for $573K
- The government of Canada was the winning bidder for a large collection of letters, maps and other papers that once belonged to Sir John Sherbrooke, the lieutenant-governor of Nova Scotia who conquered Maine for the British during the War of 1812. The collection sold for $573,000 at auction in London. more »
Latest Arts & Entertainment News Headlines
- Monsters University's Billy Crystal, Dave Foley
- Pixar returns to the story of animated duo Mike and Sulley in this summer's Monsters University, with Billy Crystal and Dave Foley among the notable cast of actors lending their voices to the kids' film. more »
- Guillermo del Toro calls Pacific Rim a family movie
- Director Guillermo del Toro' monsters vs. machines movie Pacific Rim is a summer spectacle that sets out to be different from other movies of its kind. more »
- Laval's corrupt image scares off choral festival sponsors
- The founder and driving force behind Laval, Que.'s annual international choral festival says allegations of corruption at Laval city hall have driven away some of the festival's sponsors. more »
- Dolce and Gabbana convicted of tax evasion
- A Milan court has convicted fashion designers Domenico Dolce and Stefano Gabbana of tax evasion, finding the pair guilty of failing to declare €1 billion ($1.37 billion Cdn) in income to authorities. more »
- Guillermo Del Toro's Monsters Jun. 19, 2013 1:47 PM The award winning director stops by Studio Q to chat about his upcoming blockbuster Pacific Rim.
- This summer's must-read mysteries Jun. 19, 2013 6:02 PM If you like a good thriller or whodunit to read while basking in the sun, then this roundup of books is for you!
- Sopranos star James Gandolfini dies in Italy
- Wearing a mask at a riot is now a crime
- Dozens of children seized from Manitoba Mennonite community
- B.C. teacher duct-taped students' mouths
- B.C. First Nation sets fires to save bison
- Obesity now recognized as a disease
- Richmond widow racks up $1,800 hospital parking bill
- Bob Rae quits as MP in 'very emotional' decision
- Hail, flash floods hit southeast Alberta