Court tosses out another Da Vinci Code plagiarism case
Last Updated: Monday, November 13, 2006 | 3:38 PM ET
CBC Arts
Da Vinci Code author Dan Brown has won yet another case against him claiming copyright infringement from another writer.
The U.S. Supreme Court refused Monday to hear a case from U.S. author Lewis Perdue alleging Brown's bestselling thriller was substantially similar to his book, Daughter of God. Perdue had lost his case in 2005 in a New York district court and pursued it through the appeals court process.
The Da Vinci Code, by Dan Brown, has sold more than 60 million copies worldwide.
(Canadian Press)
The Da Vinci Code, published in 2003, has sold more than 60 million copies worldwide and spawned a movie in 2006 starring Tom Hanks.
In Monday's ruling, the court upheld a previous decision, which said no reasonable juror would find Brown's work to be significantly comparable to Daughter of God, published in 2000.
The court rejected several affidavits provided by Perdue, including one from a foreign linguistics expert who found similarities between the two books to be "striking."
The fictional premise of The Da Vinci Code centres on coded messages painter Leonardo Da Vinci left in his works, revealing that Jesus had married Mary Magdalene and fathered children and, most importantly, that the bloodline survives to the present day. The plot also alleges the Catholic church conspired to hide this fact.
Daughter of God chronicles a husband-and-wife team who unearth a document describing the life of a fourth century female Christian messiah named Sophia.
Perdue, who was seeking $150 million US in damages, said Brown lifted the underlying focus of Daughter of God, including the part about Roman Emperor Constantine decreeing a transition from a female to a male-dominated religion.
More plagiarism cases
The case is a second victory this year for Brown and his publisher, Random House.
Last April, a judge in England ruled in favour of Brown in a high profile case involving authors Michael Baigent and Richard Leigh, who had launched a lawsuit against Random House claiming that Brown had "stolen the architecture" of their 1982 book Holy Blood, Holy Grail for The Da Vinci Code.
Holy Blood, Holy Grail was a non-fiction book that focused on the same theme as Brown's book. The judge in the case said Brown was "perfectly entitled to dress up factual scenarios to give an illusion that supports his fiction."
Plagiarism charges continue to dog Brown. In the spring, yet another author claimed that Brown had stolen his premise from him.
Russian art historian Mikhail Anikin said he outlined his theory that Da Vinci's famous painting Mona Lisa was a coded theological message in his 2000 book Leonardo Da Vinci: Theology in Paint.
With files from the Associated PressShare Tools
Whitney Houston's final song Celebrate debuts by Jessica Wong May. 23, 2012 2:46 PM It seems fitting that Whitney Houston's final release is an upbeat and uplifting duet in which she passes the torch to a younger singer with vocal powerhouse potential. In the high energy song Celebrate, from the upcoming film Sparkle, Houston duets with singer and former American Idol Jordin Sparks.
Top News Headlines
- Prince Charles and Camilla get royal Regina treatment
- Neither fog, nor wind, nor rain could keep Regina's royal watchers from coming out to see Prince Charles and Camilla on Wednesday. more »
- Canadian Everest victim warned by guide to turn back
- A Toronto woman who died on Mount Everest did not heed warnings for her to turn back, according to the Nepalese tour company who organized her expedition. more »
- Tuition talks to resume between Quebec minister, students
- Student leaders say a compromise over the tuition crisis is within reach, but Quebec is firm that its emergency protest law will not be part of new talks. more »
- Finley expected to detail EI changes Thursday
- Human Resources Minister Diane Finley is expected to put an end to speculation about the government's plans to change employment insurance on Thursday when she holds a news conference. more »
Latest Arts & Entertainment News Headlines
- Security breach alleged in making of bin Laden raid film
- A House committee chairman charged Wednesday in Washington that the CIA and Defence Department jeopardized national security by co-operating too closely with filmmakers producing a movie on the raid that killed Osama bin Laden. more »
- Tom Wesselmann celebrated in new Montreal exhibit
- With Beyond Pop Art: Tom Wesselmann, the Montreal Museum of Fine Arts is trying to give the reserved, modest American art icon the attention he deserves. more »
- Mario Bros. creator gets Spain's Asturias Award
- Japan's Shigeru Miyamoto, considered the father of the modern video game, has been awarded Spain's Prince of Asturias Award for Communication and Humanities. more »
- David Cronenberg exhibit planned at TIFF
- With Canadian director David Cronenberg drawing attention at Cannes with the upcoming release of Cosmopolis, the TIFF Group is getting ready to celebrate his film career with a new exhibition. more »
Q Blog
Stephen Merchant stands up for himself May. 23, 2012 4:44 PM The comic best known for collaborating with Ricky Gervais on hit TV shows "The Office" and "Extras," talks to Jian about recently returning to his stand-up comedy roots, whether there are taboos in comedy, and more.
CBC Books
The problem with modern motherhood May. 23, 2012 5:26 PM French writer Elisabeth Badinter has written a controversial new book about modern motherhood. It in she argues that parenting methods like attachment parenting undermine women. She explains why to Day 6.
- Canadian climber describes Everest as 'a morgue'
- Mom can't leave Canada with children, or stay either
- Canadian Pacific Railway strike leads to 2,000 layoffs
- Shareholders sue Facebook over botched IPO
- Massive Montreal rally ends with police clashes
- 'Save me' last words of Mount Everest climber
- Bear drags Winnipeg man from camp outhouse
- Atlantic City stabbing victims identified
- 15 ways to use a 450-page federal budget bill
The Da Vinci Code, by Dan Brown, has sold more than 60 million copies worldwide.

