Court tosses out another Da Vinci Code plagiarism case
Last Updated: Monday, November 13, 2006 | 3:38 PM ET
CBC Arts
Da Vinci Code author Dan Brown has won yet another case against him claiming copyright infringement from another writer.
The U.S. Supreme Court refused Monday to hear a case from U.S. author Lewis Perdue alleging Brown's bestselling thriller was substantially similar to his book, Daughter of God. Perdue had lost his case in 2005 in a New York district court and pursued it through the appeals court process.
The Da Vinci Code, by Dan Brown, has sold more than 60 million copies worldwide.
(Canadian Press)
The Da Vinci Code, published in 2003, has sold more than 60 million copies worldwide and spawned a movie in 2006 starring Tom Hanks.
In Monday's ruling, the court upheld a previous decision, which said no reasonable juror would find Brown's work to be significantly comparable to Daughter of God, published in 2000.
The court rejected several affidavits provided by Perdue, including one from a foreign linguistics expert who found similarities between the two books to be "striking."
The fictional premise of The Da Vinci Code centres on coded messages painter Leonardo Da Vinci left in his works, revealing that Jesus had married Mary Magdalene and fathered children and, most importantly, that the bloodline survives to the present day. The plot also alleges the Catholic church conspired to hide this fact.
Daughter of God chronicles a husband-and-wife team who unearth a document describing the life of a fourth century female Christian messiah named Sophia.
Perdue, who was seeking $150 million US in damages, said Brown lifted the underlying focus of Daughter of God, including the part about Roman Emperor Constantine decreeing a transition from a female to a male-dominated religion.
More plagiarism cases
The case is a second victory this year for Brown and his publisher, Random House.
Last April, a judge in England ruled in favour of Brown in a high profile case involving authors Michael Baigent and Richard Leigh, who had launched a lawsuit against Random House claiming that Brown had "stolen the architecture" of their 1982 book Holy Blood, Holy Grail for The Da Vinci Code.
Holy Blood, Holy Grail was a non-fiction book that focused on the same theme as Brown's book. The judge in the case said Brown was "perfectly entitled to dress up factual scenarios to give an illusion that supports his fiction."
Plagiarism charges continue to dog Brown. In the spring, yet another author claimed that Brown had stolen his premise from him.
Russian art historian Mikhail Anikin said he outlined his theory that Da Vinci's famous painting Mona Lisa was a coded theological message in his 2000 book Leonardo Da Vinci: Theology in Paint.
With files from the Associated PressShare Tools
- Spider-Man trailer: fresh take or more of the same?by Arts Online Feb. 7, 2012 5:15 PM Spider-Man? Yes. Amazing? Maybe. The first full-length trailer for The Amazing Spider-Man -- the reboot of the comic-turned-movie trilogy -- has been released. But considering the previous movie franchise ended a mere five years ago and that we've been bombarded with stories about the troubled Broadway musical adaptation since then, this reboot does beg the question: Do we really need to revisit Spider-Man?
Top News Headlines
- Manitoba trailer fire kills 4
- Four people are dead after an early-morning fire quickly engulfed a residential trailer in Selkirk, Man. more »
- Harper's China visit ends with panda pact

- Prime Minister Stephen Harper wrapped up a visit to China aimed seeking new investments by officially announcing that Beijing will loan two of the country's prized giant pandas to Canadian zoos. more »
- Attawapiskat sites not ready for modular homes
- The first two of 22 modular homes promised by the federal government to Attawapiskat are on their way to the remote northern Ontario community, but the minister handling the Aboriginal Affairs portfolio is expressing concern over the "readiness" of the lots. more »
- Romney wins Maine race, Republican officials say
- Mitt Romney eked out a narrow win in Maine's Republican caucuses, state party officials have announced, providing his campaign a much-needed boost after three straight losses earlier this week. more »
Latest Arts & Entertainment News Headlines
- World Press Photo won by Arab protest image
- Spanish photographer Samuel Aranda won the 2011 World Press Photo of the Year award Friday for an image of a veiled woman holding a wounded relative in her arms after a demonstration in Yemen. more »
- Canadian sports writer Trent Frayne dies
- Legendary Canadian sports writer Trent Frayne has died at the age of 93. more »
- Naomi Watts to portray Diana, the late Princess of Wales
- Oscar-nominated actress Naomi Watts has signed on to portray Diana, the late Princess of Wales, in a new film that will focus on her final years. more »
- Three Cups of Tea author asks judge to toss lawsuit
- Attorneys accusing Greg Mortenson of defrauding readers in Three Cups of Tea say his case is no different from that of James Frey, who admitted he lied in his memoir A Million Little Pieces. more »
Q Blog
Enter our Six-Word Modern Love Story Contest! Feb. 10, 2012 2:54 PM The goal is simple: tell a full and rich modern love tale in just six words. Funny. Sad. Sexy. Or futuristic sexy, the kind with spaceships. Winners announced on Q's February 14th Modern Love special.
CBC Books
The web celebrates 200 years of Charles Dickens Feb. 10, 2012 7:13 PM The revered English novelist turns two centuries-old this week! See the online tributes and leave your birthday message for a chance to win a copy of Charles Dickens: A Life.
- Quebec man charged with killing mother, 2 nieces
- Harper's China visit ends with panda pact
- Weed Man's sales tactics draw fire from consumer ministry
- Attawapiskat sites not ready for modular homes
- Manitoba trailer fire kills 4
- Emailed rave rape pictures earn teen probation
- Bus rolls near Redwater, Alberta, injuring dozens
- RCMP shooting suspect hoped to surrender before arrest
- Crane drops section of Port Mann bridge into B.C. river
The Da Vinci Code, by Dan Brown, has sold more than 60 million copies worldwide.

