Marketplace
CBC MARKETPLACE: HEALTH » HEALTH CHECK LABEL
Reading between the lines of the Health Check label
Broadcast: November 30, 1999 | Producer: Sharon Hanson; Researcher: Terry Weber

Some people are worried we're not getting enough information on food labels to make wise choices

'Low in fat' ... 'High in fibre' ... 'A good source of Vitamin C.' There is a lot to keep in mind when you go grocery shopping, if you want to eat healthy. But some people are worried we're not getting enough information to make wise choices.

A program called Health Check aims to change that. "The Health Check program is designed to make the healthy food choice the easy choice," according to Doug MacQuarrie of the Heart and Stroke Foundation of Canada - the sponsor of the Health Check program.

"Consumers are bombarded with nutritional information," says MacQuarrie. "And while they're very interested in nutrition, they find that when they're in the stores it's potentially confusing. There's lots of information on packages, there's lots of competing things for their attention. So they're interested in a quick way to identify healthy food choices. Health Check is a way for us to do that."

'Consumers are interested in a quick way to identify healthy food choices,' says Doug MacQuarrie

This is the type of message you'll see on a package carrying the Health Check logo: "When choosing meat, choosing leaner meats more often is part of healthy eating." Or, "Florida oranges are very high in dietary fibre and high in folacin; emphasizing vegetables and fruit is part of healthy eating."

The Health Check program, which has been around for a year, is voluntary. Companies have to apply to take part and their food has to meet specific nutritional requirements.

If it does, the company can put the Health Check logo on its product by paying a fee - anywhere from $150 to $3,000 for each product.

That raises a red flag for critics. They say it gives people the wrong impression, that a product carrying the Health Check logo is more nutritious than a competitor's, when in fact the logo has been paid for.


Bill Jeffery doesn't like the idea that companies pay the Heart and Stroke Foundation to take part in the program

Bill Jeffery is one of those critics. He's with a consumer group called the Centre for Science in the Public Interest.

Jeffery doesn't like the idea that companies pay the Heart and Stroke Foundation to take part in the program. He says they gain an unfair advantage.

For example, Jeffery is concerned about products like Generation brand fruit products - the only ones on the shelf with the Health Check logo. "The problem with that," says Jeffery, "is that all of the fruits on this shelf would be eligible for that label. That may not be apparent to the consumer who's walking down the aisle of the grocery store.

"They may think they're getting some kind of an edge with the Generation product and so they may be drawn to it for the wrong reasons. Some of these other fruits may actually have more vitamin C or less added sugar and they would be better choices from a health perspective."

Jeffery is all for nutritional labelling, but he thinks it should be mandatory for all food products.

'It's a great marketing tool for industry," says Jeffery

Right now there aren't that many products carrying the Health Check logo. The current total is 200, ranging from juice to eggs to bananas. In the sea of food items available at any grocery store, that hardly seems enough to make a change in people's nutritional choices.

"It's a great marketing tool for industry," Jeffery says. "Unfortunately it doesn't really help consumers reliably separate the wheat from the chaff."

We asked Chiquita Banana if the Health Check program is just a form of glorified advertising. "It is certainly part of our marketing efforts in that everything we do is to communicate the benefits of eating a Chiquita banana every day," says Chiquita's David Lund.

'We want them to be able to make informed decisions about healthy food choices,' says Lund

He adds that when the program was first launched, Chiquita's sales went up by about 10 per cent for a couple of weeks, and then returned to normal.

That may not sound like much, but Chiquita sells millions of pounds of bananas a year. A 10-per-cent increase in sales, even for a couple of weeks, is significant, especially if you consider the low cost of joining the program.

Chiquita would have paid an initial fee of $525, plus an annual fee of $3,000. And for that, the company is getting continuous exposure for a year.

So, nutritional education becomes good marketing.

"At 4:00 in the afternoon 60 per cent of consumers don't know what they're going to have for dinner," says Lund. "And so a lot of consumers are coming in trying to decide what they're going to eat. We want them to be able to make informed decisions about healthy food choices and this is a nice way to reinforce that bananas are something they should be considering."

'I would want to know why these bananas have that check mark,' says Cheryl

Marketplace's informal survey of grocery shoppers suggested that Lund is right. Many of the people we talked to said the Health Check logo -once they knew what it meant- would make a difference in their buying decisions.

But there are some inquiring consumers who want to know more. We asked one woman if the Health Check label might sway her. "Well, I guess I would want to know why these bananas have that check mark," said Cheryl. "What makes them different?"


^TOP
Jobs | Contact Us | Permissions | Help | RSS | Advertise
Terms of Use | Privacy | Ombudsman | CBC: Get the Facts | Other Policies
Copyright © CBC 2013
A new season. A new website. Click here to watch our latest programs
MENU

HEALTH CHECK LABEL: MAIN PAGE
MORE MARKETPLACE: GM FOOD LABELLING ARCHIVES: YOUR HEALTH
RELATED:

CBC Consumers: Deciphering nutrition labels

Health Canada sets mandatory food labels (January 22, 2003)

Ottawa reveals proposed nutrition labels for foods (June 18, 2001)

New food labels can claim to fight heart disease (June 15, 2001)

Liberal MP pushes for better food labelling (November 10, 2000)

More nutritional information to go on food labels (October 19, 2000)

EXTERNAL LINKS:

CBC does not endorse and is not responsible for the content of external sites. Links will open in new window.

Health Check- website, linked to the Heart and Stroke Foundation, offers details of the Health Check program

Nutrition Labelling Bill - private member's bill introduced to the House of Commons November 17, 1999, that urges mandatory labelling of nutritional information

Centre for Science in the Public Interest - an advocacy group supporting health and nutrition, CSPI's Canadian site features many articles and links concerning the nutrition labelling issue

Canada's Food Guide - for many, it's the Bible of nutritional eating. The Guide contains data on what's inside food and how to keep a balanced diet

Heart and Stroke Foundation - creators of the Health Check program, the Foundation's site contains pages devoted to maintaining a healthy cardiovascular system. Essential to that: eating wisely

MORE:
Print this page

Send a comment
MARKETPLACE MURMURS
Marketplace Murmurs is taking a break – in the meantime, if you have stories to share with the show, please contact us.
MARKETPLACE SCHEDULE

Watch Marketplace Fridays at 8:30PM

HELP THE SHOW
Have an idea for a story you'd like to see on Marketplace? Get in touch with us!
CONTACT MARKETPLACE
We'd love to hear your feedback and story suggestions - get in touch!

Call us toll-free at: 1-866-535-3786