Marketplace
CBC MARKETPLACE: ENVIRONMENT » HIGH-TECH TRASH
Tossing your computer? Read this first
Reporter: Erica Johnson; Producer: Ines Colabrese; Researcher: Colman Jones
Broadcast: Oct 22, 2002
computer trash
North American computer waste is increasingly winding up in places like China.

Canadians have come to rely heavily on high-tech conveniences – cellphones, fax machines, and computers. Some of us say our lives now depend on them. But what happens when they’re no longer useful? They become high-tech trash — a dirty secret the Canadian government is doing little about.

We're throwing away millions of pieces of high-tech equipment a year. At Trent Wolodko's recycling plant in Calgary, he can’t keep up with it. Wolodko says the material is loaded with toxic ingredients:

"We’ve got the plastic from the computer. We’ve got the tin and metals and steel and things like that. Now the stuff that gets a little bit brickier is the copper and aluminum wiring with the PVC insulation."

Wolodko lists a number of other ingredients that are tough to recycle, including:

  • lead
  • cadmium
  • phosphorus

When computers reach the end of their useful lives, some wind up stored in our attics and basements. Some are recycled. Some are just thrown out. But more and more, our high-tech trash is shipped out of Canada, causing problems in other parts of the world.

That's where Jim Puckett comes in. He works for the Basel Action Network — a Seattle environmental group. Puckett recently shot some video he shot in China that he says is evidence of the high-tech trade’s dirty little secret.

Puckett's group is trying to get countries to keep their hazardous waste in their own backyards. His investigation took him to the province of Guiyu in Southeastern China.

"We found villages of women and children that all they did, all day long, was sort wires by day, burn them at night."

Puckett’s video is a snap shot of 100,000 people in neighbouring villages, toiling to recover copper and gold. He found ditches filled with high tech debris — a town’s river transformed into a floating garbage dump.

Puckett says the drinking water is no longer drinkable.

"We found the lead levels in the river there to be 300 times the World Health Organization standard."

'A real cocktail of toxic agents'


This label was taken from computer waste in China. We traced it back to the Department of National Defence.

Marketplace wondered what handling toxic materials with bare hands can do to people’s health. So, we showed the video to Dr. Chris Van Netten at the University of British Columbia. He analyzes health hazards.

"That’s a real cocktail of toxic agents, when you come to think of it."

Van Netten says burning the plastic around copper wires creates dioxins, which can change our molecular structure. Mercury exposure can lead to neurological problems. Lead fumes may cause brain defects and kidney damage.

If you think what’s going on in China has little to do with Canada, think again.

In amongst piles of rubble, Puckett’s group found a label from a small firm in Vancouver. There was also a label that we tracked to Canadian Airlines. And one that led Marketplace to a federal government office.

We showed some of the video to Judy O’Brien. She buys and sells computers for the Department of National Defence in Esquimalt, just outside Victoria, BC.

"I’m shocked that so much of it ends up over there, and that this is what they’re doing with it," O'Brien said.

Computer trash taced back to DND

When Marketplace showed O'Brien a label that could be traced to her office, she said, "I’m a little bit embarrassed."

But not so embarrassed that she’ll recommend the military make sure its toxic trash doesn’t go overseas.

The Chinese government passed a law in the summer of 2002 making it illegal to import computer junk. But recycler Trent Wolodko says that’s not stopping some Canadian computer brokers from shipping their trash to China.

"Payments. Back door payments," Wolodko said.


Sorting wires for a living.

Jim Puckett — of the Basel Action Network — says Canada shouldn’t be shipping e-waste to China for another reason: the Basel Convention. The international treaty was signed 13 years ago, to stop rich countries from dumping their high-tech trash into poorer countries. Canada has signed the Convention — but Puckett says Canada’s negotiators are trying to undermine it.

"They’re the only country in the world that we’re aware of that’s a party to the Basel Convention that is saying that electronic waste is not hazardous waste."

Ottawa's position

According to Ottawa, an old computer — full of toxic stuff — isn’t hazardous waste until it’s broken down into parts.

To sort out Canada’s position Marketplace headed to Environment Canada, the folks who negotiated the Basel Convention.

We showed the video from China to John Arseneau, who works with the Toxics Pollution Prevention program.

Arseneau says there’s no problem with Canada shipping computer trash overseas — the federal government doesn’t define it as hazardous.

"We're currently reviewing that, but as it is right now, under our regulations, it isn't considered hazardous waste."

That position doesn't sit well with the Basel Action Network's Jim Puckett.

"Well I’m sorry, the Treaty they signed says it’s hazardous waste. So either they get out of the Treaty, or they respect it."

What about the manufacturers? They’re the ones putting hazardous materials into computers.

"If you’re putting something toxic on the planet, somebody’s going to have pay somewhere," Puckett said.

Canada’s computer industry says the people who buy computers should pay to get rid of the waste. The industry wants to add a $25 fee to the cost of computers to cover recycling.

Since Puckett’s investigation, more recycling sites have been discovered in other parts of China and in other countries — like India, Pakistan and Korea.

"There’s no reason why we could not take care of this equipment here in Canada. We wouldn’t have to send them to China, Pakistan, India or any other country," Calgary recycler Trent Wolodko says. "It could stay right here and we could take care of the problem properly."

That's not likely to happen until computers are made less toxic and recycled in Canada.



^TOP
Jobs | Contact Us | Permissions | Help | RSS | Advertise
Terms of Use | Privacy | Ombudsman | CBC: Get the Facts | Other Policies
Copyright © CBC 2012
A new season. A new website. Click here to watch our latest programs
MENU

HIGH-TECH TRASH: MAIN PAGE POISONS INSIDE YOUR PC WHAT HAPPENS TO OLD COMPUTERS? DISPOSAL POLICIES IN CANADA WHAT'S BEING DONE? COMPUTERS AND CORPORATE ACCOUNTABILITY CHINA'S MOVE TO HALT E-WASTE THE BASEL CONVENTION WHAT TO DO WITH YOUR OLD PC 'GREEN' COMPUTER DESIGN

MORE MARKETPLACE: TRASH TALK OVERPACKAGING MARKETPLACE ARCHIVES: THE ENVIRONMENT
RELATED:

Alberta sets electronic recycling fees (May 7, 2004)

Computer microchip weighs heavily on environment (November 7, 2002)

Canadian computer trash dumped in developing world (October 22, 2002)

Old cellphones are a threat to the environment (May 10, 2002)

EXTERNAL LINKS:

CBC does not endorse and is not responsible for the content of external sites. Links will open in new window.

Environment Canada's National Office of Pollution Prevention

Environment Canada - Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) and stewardship

Information Technology (IT) and Telecommunication (Telecom) Waste in Canada (PDF)

Canadian Association of Recycling Industries

Computer & Telecommunications Recycling - Computer Scrap and Dismantling Category

From Ground Zero, Taking Aim at Electronic Wastes

Basel Action Network

Silicon Valley Toxics Coalition

California Global Corporate Accountability Project (CAP)

B.A.N. February 25, 2002 report: "Exporting Harm: The High-Tech Trashing of Asia"

Export of Harm: The Canadian Story (PDF report by the Basel Action Network)

Information on Recycling Computer Monitors and Television Sets

Electronics Recycler’s Pledge of True Stewardship (PDF)

Environmentalists Expose Illegal Canadian Electronic Waste Dumping In Asia (October 22, 2002 press release)

E-Waste Photos

How does a cathode ray tube work?

California Department of Toxic Substances Control - Response to Questions Regarding Management of Cathode Ray Tubes

Obsolete Computer Museum

Towards Waste-Free Electrical and Electronic Equipment (PDF)

International Association of Electronics Recyclers

MORE:
Print this page

Send a comment
MARKETPLACE SCHEDULE

Watch Marketplace Fridays at 8:30PM

HELP THE SHOW
Have an idea for a story you'd like to see on Marketplace? Get in touch with us!
CONTACT MARKETPLACE
We'd love to hear your feedback and story suggestions - get in touch!

Call us toll-free at: 1-866-535-3786