rollover

Speed Bumps

Smart shopping for internet access

You may be surprised to learn how many choices you have for your internet access. Beyond the big cable and phone companies, there are scores of smaller providers. Here are some guidelines:

  • DSL access uses your phone line. In general, it provides a more consistent speed than cable, although that rate of speed is determined by many factors, including how far your house is from the switching station, and on the condition of the wires.
  • Cable is usually faster than DSL for bursts of raw download speed, but it is also more variable. You will usually share a cable connection with your neighbours, so your speed may drop if everybody is online at the same time.
  • If you are the kind of person who uses a CD tray as a cup holder, you might benefit from hands-on attention from a smaller ISP. Canadian ISP.com has a large listing of alternative ISPs across the country, along with reviews.
  • Check your computer. Your speed could be slow because of viruses or spyware.
  • Check your wiring. If you have DSL, replacing the phone cord from your computer to your demarcation point (that's the spot dividing your own wires from the ones the local phone company is responsible for) can mean a big improvement in speeds. Make sure you have filters on all of your phones.
  • If you use an online speed test, remember that your ISP can manage traffic flow. You may get a quicker connection to the test site than to anything else, which could make you think your overall speed is faster than it is.
  • Remember that your speed could be fast to your provider and slow down at the next hop on the internet. Much of the internet is outside your provider's control.
  • Ask your provider what its "contention ratio" is. Some providers can oversubscribe lines in certain neighbourhoods, and this can slow you down.
  • If you have a bundle, ask if it's really saving you money. Can you buy a modem instead of renting one?

Posted on November 21, 2007
•  •  Save on del.icio.us •  Post to Digg

Comments - Share your thoughts

Canadian ISP.com lists only two providers for high speed Internet on cable - they're both in Quebec and look at the website of one of them (language issues - seems that if you chose English, they assume you must live outside of Canada). Posted by: D. Lewis | Nov 21, 07 10:11 PM
I have the Shaw 10 meg service which also gives a 1 meg upload. I tried the test using the recommended server in Calgary where I live. It gave me 500K download and 380 upload. I then switched to the Seattle server and received 8.9 meg download and 980k upload speed. Ironically the PING time to the Calgary server was 194 ms and the ping to Seatle was 64 ms. All this tells me is that your speed test is a bunch of hooey. Posted by: Gary | Nov 21, 07 10:21 PM
re: managing traffic flow to test sites? Exactly what ISP does this? I know traffic shaping happens, but it is usually to limit peer to peer applications from sucking all the available bandwidth and affecting other application's performance. Rogers and Shaw have been in the news on this. Telus blocked some sites during labour negotiations that were widely publicized. There is also some talk in forums about Bell doing this. I would expect that any ISP caught doing this would face the full brunt of the Marketplace media storm... Any evidence here or is this just more sensationalist journalism I thought you guys shunned? Posted by: John Dallas | Nov 21, 07 11:16 PM
Re: Gary. Gary. That's because the Calgary server sucks. I've never had a good test there. CBC says to use the closest server thinking it will be faster. That is not true. Posted by: Nick O | Nov 23, 07 09:21 PM
The show is biased in my opinion. I have being using bell for over 8 years, at 4 different locations, never had any speed issue. Currently I am using Bell's VDSL,Paying $45/m. While I am typing, I am gettin126,688,805bytes downloading, 4,468,645bytes uploading. Posted by: unknown | Nov 24, 07 12:54 PM
You think thats bad? You want to try Aliant dial up -- since that is all we can get in this area. I guess millions of dollars wasn't enough from the government to bring it to our area. They aren't going to. Posted by: Alison Rhodes | Nov 24, 07 10:31 PM
One thing your program failed to mention when testing your speed by downloading is that how fast you can download is limit to how fast the server allow you to download. For instance, if I set the download rate at 5kb/s for anyone who downloads a file from my pc then no matter how fast your internet connection is, you will not download faster than 5kb/s. Using a speed testing website is a great idea to test your connection speed. I recommend using different ones and run test a number of time to get a more accurate read on your speed. Posted by: Kelven Kwon | Nov 29, 07 12:09 AM
I get what I think is "reasonable" speed from my ISP (Sympatico), I've used many other computers and none of them, except one, has matched my computer for speed so far. What I dislike INTENSELY about Bell is their absolutely rotten customer service. I've been off line for 2-5 days at a time about 4 times this year, always for the same reason, something to do with a technical failure at their switching station, but it's a battle to get anyone to accept responsibility. It always starts off being my fault, despite the fact they have my call-in records showing otherwise. On top of that I've had more than enough trouble with Expressvu, again their "engineers" told me, without even running a test, that the problem was with my VCR and not the satellite box, only to admit after hours on the phone that the problem was actually with the equipment they supplied. Let's not talk about the billing problems I encountered for the first 6 months of service! Sorry about my rant but I've had enough with Bell ISP/Satellite/Phone services and I fully intend to look for alternative services in the very near future. Posted by: Michael Jones | Nov 29, 07 07:35 PM
I think the ISP business is foggy at best for most consumers, which allows the providers to make claims without ever having to prove that they did or did not meet "service" guidelines. I suggest that ISPs that can make assurances of "no less than 2 Mbps and up to 5 Mbps" for instance will be far ahead of the competition - at least within their own loop. At this time I don't see anybody doing this. The "up to 5 Mbps" could mean zero at times which has happened to me either for temporary outage or some other reason. I suppose the internet is not yet considered an essential service like electricity and therefore does not need to meet similar high stringent standards of reliability and dependability...although I pay as much per month for my electricity as for internet service? Posted by: Shaw Subscriber | Dec 30, 07 10:42 PM
I totally gave up on Bell Canada/India for good. I will use carrier pigeon or smoke signals first. Morse code with a light also works. Posted by: Wayne Wales | Jan 17, 08 06:18 PM
Subscribe to the comments

Share your thoughts

Note: The CBC does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comments, you acknowledge that CBC has the right to reproduce, broadcast and publicize those comments or any part thereof in any manner whatsoever. Please note that due to the volume of comments we receive, not all comments will be published, and those that are published may be edited. But all will be carefully read, considered and appreciated.