MANITOBA VOTES 2007

Parties & Leaders

The Progressive Conservative Party:
Hugh McFadyen

CBC Online News | Updated April 3, 2007
 

It has been a whirlwind last few months for Hugh McFadyen, who moved from the political backroom to the Opposition's corner office in less than 18 months.

McFadyen, a champion curler and lawyer, was elected to the legislature in December 2005, just two months before he threw his hat into the ring for the Conservative party's Manitoba leadership.

He took the reins of the Opposition party from former leader Stuart Murray in a decisive first-ballot victory at the Tories' leadership convention last April. Murray stepped down after receiving only lukewarm support at the party's annual general meeting.

Sharp, young and polished, the rookie MLA looked to some like just the man to lead voters back to the party. But others worry about a repeat of the party's years under Stuart Murray: both were lauded for their youthful appeal and "coolness," and each had only just emerged from behind the political curtain before taking the party's helm.

But the change appeared to appeal to Manitobans: a poll last summer put the Tories ahead of the NDP for the first time since they lost power in 1999.

That momentum has continued, with the Tories ending up just ahead of the NDP in nearly every poll since, until a March poll by Probe Research put the party neck and neck with the NDP.

Even so, the new leader has a fine line to walk.

To get back in office, the Conservatives must convince voters in Winnipeg to give the party back the seats it lost to the NDP in 1999. And while wooing Winnipeggers, McFadyen must also take care not to alienate the party's traditional rural base.

Fund may be a key issue

The party has seized on the failure of the Crocus Investment Fund as its hot-button issue to criticize the NDP government. 

However, a Probe Research poll of Manitobans in March found almost 80 per cent of Manitobans were not paying close attention to the issue, despite the oppositions' constant haranguing, and only nine per cent blamed the NDP government for the fund's problems.

Worse, from the Tories' perspective, the people mostly likely to be angry about the Crocus affair are those who lost money when the fund failed — and those who would have invested in the labour-sponsored fund may, arguably, tend to be left-leaning politically anyway, so the Crocus issue alone may not be enough to turn them blue come election day.

Recent polls have suggested health care is the biggest issue on Manitobans' minds as the election approached, but it's a tough row to hoe for the Tories. While the party has tried to attack the NDP's approach to health care, the government never misses the opportunity to remind voters that the Tories, when last in power, were responsible for cuts to it. 

Promises to cut 'red tape'

Law and order has also been a major focus area of Tory criticism. Certainly it would seem that voters, especially urban voters dealing with auto theft and near-daily headlines about violent crime, could be swayed by a call for more anti-crime measures.

But, as political analyst Paul Thomas points out, NDP Attorney General Gord Mackintosh already talks a hard line on crime, frequently calling on Ottawa to increase penalties for criminals.

McFadyen has suggested his party will focus on ending government mismanagement and keeping Manitoba youth in the province, mainly by bringing down taxes and cutting the "red tape" that blocks the efforts of entrepreneurs.

"If you want productivity, if you want growth, you need to get out of the way of people who are building our province, and once that happens we'll see growth," he said shortly after taking the party's helm. "Tax revenues will come up even though we bring our tax rates down."

Whether Manitobans find the message — and the man behind it — persuasive enough to change their vote remains to be seen.

 

The CBC does not endorse and is not responsible for the content of external sites. External links will open in a new window.External link opens in a new window


Go to the Top

Riding Profiles

Quick Facts

Born:  May 31, 1967, Selkirk, Man.

Family: wife Jennifer, two preschool-aged children.

Education: University of Manitoba faculty of arts and law school

Life before politics: Lawyer in London, England, consultant in Toronto, advisor to Winnipeg Mayor Sam Katz and chief of staff for former premier Gary Filmon. 

Politics: past president of the Tory party's youth wing. elected MLA for Fort Whyte in a December 2005 byelection, became party leader April 29, 2006.

More Manitoba Votes Headlines »

NDP wins historic 3rd majority in Manitoba Video: Heather Hiscox interviews Manitoba Premier Gary Doer for CBC-TV
Manitoba NDP Leader Gary Doer has led his party to a historic third majority government in the province's 39th general election, taking 36 of 57 seats.
PCs win 19 seats, lose ground from 2003
The Progressive Conservatives won 19 out of 57 ridings Tuesday — a drop of one seat from 2003.
Liberals hold 2 seats
Voters denied the Liberals official party status on Tuesday, although the party held its two existing seats.
Greens make slight gains
The Green party's dreams of a breakthrough quickly wilted on Tuesday night.
16 cabinet ministers re-elected, one loses nailbiter
Sixteen members of Premier Gary Doer's former NDP cabinet in Manitoba were re-elected Tuesday, but Trade Minister Scott Smith lost the riding of Brandon West in a squeaker.
more »